Cindysphinx
G.O.A.T.
Whoa! Suddenly Anna Karenina seems like a lucky break for you all.
Who picks these stinkers?
Since you asked . . .
Everyone in the group makes 2-3 recommendations, pitching them to the group. Then there is a blind ballot to pick the ones that make the cut. So there is a consensus for every book chosen.
Almost all of the books I listed above were of more interest to me than Anna Karenina. I can assure you that I voted against it. . . .
My recommendations rarely are chosen because I always go with non-fiction.