My knees love these shoes...

R

ricardo

Hall of Fame
I have been using these shoes (https://www.costco.com/Kirkland-Signature-Men’s-Athletic-Shoe,-White.product.100281319.html) for about a month and my knees are very thankful I did.
It is wide and comfortable.
It is as wide as my NB 806 4E and as comfortable as my Asics GR5 and Prince T22.
No pain at all. No side pinching and no toe jamming.
I haven't tripped on the court, it is stable side-to-side, forward/back.
No toe jamming on hard stops.

I originally bought these shoes for casual use.
However, after a few minutes of walking in these shoes, I knew I can use it for tennis on hard courts.
 
Last edited:
how long they last on hard surface? I am costco member and always thought they are not durable shoes (6 to 8 hours of play per week)
 
tennissavvy said:
how long they last on hard surface? I am costco member and always thought they are not durable shoes (6 to 8 hours of play per week)
Click to expand...

After about 10 hours, minimal wear on the outsole (heel and forefoot areas).

Your experience may vary because shoe durability depends on amount of use and your weight and how you use it. The heavier you are, the faster you wear shoes.
If you slide a lot, the more you will wear out your shoes.

For me, I think it will last for about 6 mos to a year, playing 10-15 hours/week on hard courts.
 
At that price, they just might be worth a try. Worst case scenario, I'll have another pair of gardening shoes. Good lookin' out! I am all about shoes that will help with knee soreness.
 
damn for $17, it might be worth a try.
Currently spending ~60 (after 6mo warrantee) on barricades or gel resolutions (2mos @5hr/w)
anyone have a comparison to barricades or gel resolutions?
what level do you guys play?
 
ricardo said:
After about 10 hours, minimal wear on the outsole (heel and forefoot areas).

Your experience may vary because shoe durability depends on amount of use and your weight and how you use it. The heavier you are, the faster you wear shoes.
If you slide a lot, the more you will wear out your shoes.

For me, I think it will last for about 6 mos to a year, playing 10-15 hours/week on hard courts.
Click to expand...
i'd argue the more active your feet, the faster you wear out your shoes. being heavier for most folks means slower less active feet.
 
That's great. You found your best tennis shoe for only $17, and if you have an Executive membership it will even add to your rebate! For that much, I might be tempted to try it except that I have narrow feet, so it clearly won't work for me. The look actually reminds me of some New Balance shoes. Maybe it's made in the same factory. I think it shows that good cushioning is not rocket science. It's all about compromising cushioning vs weight and court feel.
 
nytennisaddict said:
i'd argue the more active your feet, the faster you wear out your shoes. being heavier for most folks means slower less active feet.
Click to expand...

being heavier for most folks means slower less active feet.

If you are implying 'fat' or 'obese' I fully agree.

For a given volume, muscles is 4x heavier than fat.
For example, if muscular Nadal weights 100 lbs, a 'fat/obese' person would appear to be 4x bigger than Nadal, although they weight the same.
 
gino said:
Probably EVA foam. I won't step into a pair of shoes that doesn't have advanced midsole tech or a supportive upper. This shoe has neither
Click to expand...

I won't step into a pair of shoes that doesn't have advanced midsole tech or a supportive upper. This shoe has neither

I have had problems with the following:
  1. Pinky toe side-pinching
  2. Toe jamming
  3. Sore knees
I am very thankful that these shoes eliminate all of the above and allows me to continue enjoying tennis.
 
gino said:
Probably EVA foam. I won't step into a pair of shoes that doesn't have advanced midsole tech or a supportive upper. This shoe has neither
Click to expand...

thick enough eva is fine for me. i was fine with them 10 years ago( ok. i was younger then).

anyway, most of tennis shoes these days gone low profile with advanced material. all i need is old school shoes. :)
i'm gonna try these at costco and see how it feels.

...and i might consider paint these shoes if i do end up getting these.
 
ricardo said:
I won't step into a pair of shoes that doesn't have advanced midsole tech or a supportive upper. This shoe has neither

I have had problems with the following:
  1. Pinky toe side-pinching
  2. Toe jamming
  3. Sore knees
I am very thankful that these shoes eliminate all of the above and allows me to continue enjoying tennis.
Click to expand...


If you;re looking for a shoe that can truly remediate those issues and be durable, try these:

Vapor 9 Tour
Vapor 9.5 Tour
Lunar Vapor 8
Lunar Vapor 7

All of the above shoes have a VERY wide toe box and excellent cushioning. The V9/V9.5 need a nice insole to truly accommodate and provide nice under foot cushioning.
 
chikoo said:
Regular EVA is great, but has a pretty short life span as it relates to cushioning properties.
Click to expand...

It only has to last as long as the outsole. Besides, I'm guessing you'll get more than $17 worth of wear out of it.

I suppose if someone is into advanced midsole technology it's better to buy a pair of Nikes for $200 and hope that the air bubbles don't pop. LOL
 
Booger said:
I'll wait for the velcro version. If someone accuses me of being unfashionable, I'll just say I'm wearing them ironically.
Click to expand...

Don't forget the Hawaiian shirt, walker cane with the tennis balls on the legs and cap that says USS Nebraska.
 
steve s said:
What size did you wear with the NB 806 VS the Kirkland???
Click to expand...

Same.
Size 10 NB 806 4E
Size 10 Kirkland Athletic Shoes.
I feel the Kirkland to be a little bit wider.
It could be due to a more flexible upper.

The Kirkland is significantly more cushioned than the NB
and the uppers are more comfortable too.

The Kirkland outsole is wider than the NB outsole providing more stability during side-to-side movements.

I actually prefer the Kirkland over the NB, especially in terms of comfort.
 
ricardo said:
Same.
Size 10 NB 806 4E
Size 10 Kirkland Athletic Shoes.
I feel the Kirkland to be a little bit wider.
It could be due to a more flexible upper.

The Kirkland is significantly more cushioned than the NB
and the uppers are more comfortable too.

The Kirkland outsole is wider than the NB outsole providing more stability during side-to-side movements.

I actually prefer the Kirkland over the NB, especially in terms of comfort.
Click to expand...

I used to wear the NB 804 (predecessor to 806) in B width. I thought it was very well cushioned and comfortable compared to other shoes I've worn. My only problems were stability (I would lose my footing sometimes), and fit. Despite being a B width it was too roomy for me.
 
Ramon said:
I used to wear the NB 804 (predecessor to 806) in B width. I thought it was very well cushioned and comfortable compared to other shoes I've worn. My only problems were stability (I would lose my footing sometimes), and fit. Despite being a B width it was too roomy for me.
Click to expand...

My only problems were stability (I would lose my footing sometimes)

I have stability problems too if I wear narrower shoes.
I occasionally wear an Adidas Rod Laver tennis shoes on hard courts
and I almost always lose my footing when moving sideways.

Currently, I just wear my Adidas Rod Laver for show.
For playing tennis, forget it.
 
ricardo said:
After about 10 hours, minimal wear on the outsole (heel and forefoot areas).

Your experience may vary because shoe durability depends on amount of use and your weight and how you use it. The heavier you are, the faster you wear shoes.
If you slide a lot, the more you will wear out your shoes.

For me, I think it will last for about 6 mos to a year, playing 10-15 hours/week on hard courts.
Click to expand...


ricardo, how about giving us an update on how they are holding up, and how the knees are feeling, every couple of weeks or so. Thanks
 
ricardo said:
My only problems were stability (I would lose my footing sometimes)

I have stability problems too if I wear narrower shoes.
I occasionally wear an Adidas Rod Laver tennis shoes on hard courts
and I almost always lose my footing when moving sideways.

Currently, I just wear my Adidas Rod Laver for show.
For playing tennis, forget it.
Click to expand...

Have you tried other cheapo shoes ? not quite $17 but plenty available at $20-30 range... thanks.
 
Plenty of good tennis shoes for 6 months warranty. It comes to 30/40 max per pair. I am not sure Costco shoes will last 30 days for heavy users. It cost 100+ in 6 months unless they are super durable (doubt)
 
ultradr said:
Have you tried other cheapo shoes ? not quite $17 but plenty available at $20-30 range... thanks.
Click to expand...

Yes.

I tried Asics Gel Equation 8 Wide (4E) https://www.amazon.com/ASICS-Mens-GEL-Equation-Running-Shoe/dp/B00Q2JCISK.
I found it from Burlington Coat Factory for $33 bucks.

I bought it initially for running, but when I used it for tennis (hard courts), I felt it is better than any of my other tennis shoes.
I actually prefer it over Asics GR5 or T22 or Babolat SFX.

It may not be as durable as my Asics GR5, but again, my old knees prefer this.

I actually prefer this over my Kirkland shoes.
The only problem is that they are hard to find at that price point while Kirkland is always available from Costco.
 
There is a lot of profit in the shoe business. The reality is that shoes cost about $10 - $15 to manufacture. Costco does not make products, they are a retailer. Those shoes are probably made in the same factories by the same people that make other shoes. I'll be waiting for ricardo's updates. His updates may help people to make up their minds to try or not.

Then there is the old adage that, "you get what you pay for."
 
i think one of main issues is that industry went low profile on tennis shoes. So for some people, it's better avoid high end shoes with extreme low profile with advanced materials.
 
ultradr said:
i think one of main issues is that industry went low profile on tennis shoes. So for some people, it's better avoid high end shoes with extreme low profile with advanced materials.
Click to expand...

I agree. I alluded to it earlier. The young, sturdy pros want light shoes with good court feel, but older guys need more protection. The new technology usually doesn't give us more protection. It's used to make shoes lighter and lower to the ground while giving just enough protection for the pros.
 
Ramon said:
I agree. I alluded to it earlier. The young, sturdy pros want light shoes with good court feel, but older guys need more protection. The new technology usually doesn't give us more protection. It's used to make shoes lighter and lower to the ground while giving just enough protection for the pros.
Click to expand...

I think the tennis shoe industry will continue to market to The young, sturdy pros and ignore the older guys who need more protection.

I have to take care of my knees so I can continue playing tennis.
I have to look at tennis shoes alternatives, like running shoes.
Running shoes bolsters comfort instead of durability.

I wear wide running shoes, and the wide width promotes stability.
I don't have a toe-dragging problem, so running shoes are Ok for me.
 
I was at costco...nothing special here ... 9.5 my size felt tighter on the top. I know memory foam doesn't last longer (sweating)
 
Probably Adidas Barricade Boost are good for protect the knees, don't try them myself (they're not cheap) but hear some good replies.
 
BorgCash said:
Probably Adidas Barricade Boost are good for protect the knees, don't try them myself (they're not cheap) but hear some good replies.
Click to expand...

That's what I wear and they are great for the knees, but the OP has 4E wide feet and the Barricades are narrow. The Costco shoes are probably better for him.
 
BorgCash said:
I've never heard about Costco before. Is it budget shoes company?
Click to expand...

It's a big superstore that sells groceries, appliances, clothes, furniture, etc. I buy mostly bulk food there. You pay an annual membership fee and you get to shop there and pay low prices. Sam's Club is similar.
 
BorgCash said:
I've never heard about Costco before. Is it budget shoes company?
Click to expand...

No.
It is like Walmart.
They sell almost everything, from food to clothing to shoes to sports equipment etc.
But they sell mostly in bulk.
For example, they sell tennis balls, but in boxes of 24 cans instead of individual cans.
 
Ramon said:
It's a big superstore that sells groceries, appliances, clothes, furniture, etc. I buy mostly bulk food there. You pay an annual membership fee and you get to shop there and pay low prices. Sam's Club is similar.
Click to expand...

Ok, i think we got Metro that ia smth like this.
 
ricardo said:
Yes.

I tried Asics Gel Equation 8 Wide (4E) https://www.amazon.com/ASICS-Mens-GEL-Equation-Running-Shoe/dp/B00Q2JCISK.
I found it from Burlington Coat Factory for $33 bucks.

I bought it initially for running, but when I used it for tennis (hard courts), I felt it is better than any of my other tennis shoes.
I actually prefer it over Asics GR5 or T22 or Babolat SFX.

It may not be as durable as my Asics GR5, but again, my old knees prefer this.

I actually prefer this over my Kirkland shoes.
The only problem is that they are hard to find at that price point while Kirkland is always available from Costco.
Click to expand...

I hear you. I love my running shoes and used that to play too...that is until I twisted my ankle one day. A good reminder that the running shoes do not have the stability the tennis shoes have. In fact the best shoe would be my running shoes with the stability without all the excessive weight & sole stiffness that has made me less nimble :(
Just as a reference my New Balance 860 running shoes weigh 10.2 oz.
 
ricardo said:
No.
It is like Walmart.
They sell almost everything, from food to clothing to shoes to sports equipment etc.
But they sell mostly in bulk.
For example, they sell tennis balls, but in boxes of 24 cans instead of individual cans.
Click to expand...

Ok, i think we got Metro that ia smth like this. And they have their own shoes line?
 
chikoo said:
I hear you. I love my running shoes and used that to play too...that is until I twisted my ankle one day. A good reminder that the running shoes do not have the stability the tennis shoes have. In fact the best shoe would be my running shoes with the stability without all the excessive weight & sole stiffness that has made me less nimble :(
Just as a reference my New Balance 860 running shoes weigh 10.2 oz.
Click to expand...

Exactly. I once tried to play in ruinning shoes, Adidas in my case, they lack in stability, especially when you you move side-to-side and forward-back.
 
Tennis shoes feel like these compared to the running shoes.

usnavyboots.JPG
 
BorgCash said:
Ok, i think we got Metro that ia smth like this. And they have their own shoes line?
Click to expand...

They are not a shoe company. I shop there and I didn't even know they sold athletic shoes. It's a small fraction of their business, so I'm sure another company does the work of making it. Costco uses the name "Kirkland" for their store brands.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

R
ASICS GR6 Wide: The best shoes for my Wide feet...
Replies
11
Views
3K
d-quik
d-quik
R
Prince T22: I am glad I bought these shoes
Replies
32
Views
4K
Chotobaka
Chotobaka
ByeByePoly
Compare weight of your left and right shoes
Replies
7
Views
1K
jmacdaununder2
jmacdaununder2
ByeByePoly
If true 4E tennis shoes produced again, post here
2
Replies
75
Views
6K
GeoffHYL
GeoffHYL
R
Adidas Barricade Court Wide 2E is not wide enought for me...
Replies
2
Views
951
ricardo
R
Back
Top