Nadal criticises Madrid Masters

maximo

Banned
Ce n'est pas vrai parce que la pigmentation est obtenue avec differents materiaux. De toute facon l'idee est esthetiquement absurde et motivee par l'appat du gain, pas le desir d'ameliorer la qualite du sport donc pour moi a rejeter vigoureusement.

j'en suis persuade que ca change rien...
 
Last edited:

gj011

Banned
because we want to see our beloved sport grow, not continue to fade away. watch what you wish for, in the coming years if something doesnt change, youll only have TV coverage of slams and possibly the year end. fewer and fewer tourneys are being televised as time goes on. its time to make a change in some way or loose our sport forever. why is this still a tough decision for you?

I don`t think this is true. Tennis is losing popularity in US, mainly because of lack of top US player, but not in the rest of the world. So I don`t think any big change is needed, especially I don`t think blue clay would make any difference in that respect.
Change not always means something will be better, so you should also watch what you wish for, because due to changes tennis might lose lots of current fans.
For example, what they did to doubles, with stupid new scoring rules is ridiculous and completely ruined the game.
 

veroniquem

Bionic Poster
you couldnt have had better timing with your chime in, rofl.

can someone other than a nadal fan please rebuke this idea on this thread today?
Can someone other than a Nadal hater harass me to no end over the issue? You have your opinion, I have mine. Stop trying to terrorize me into changing it because I won't and get off my back. You like the idea of multicolored clay courts, I don't. We have each expressed our reasons why, let's leave it at that and see what happens.
 
Last edited:

TheTruth

G.O.A.T.
You did not understand what Nadal complained about. He didn't complain about Madrid being the wrong altitude in general, that would be pretty stupid indeed, he said that he would have preferred a tournament like Barcelona to be the last one before RG because, due to the altitude, Madrid plays completely differently than RG and is not a good preparation for it. He suggested to switch the dates so that the last master before RG would be more similar to the way RG plays.
About blue clay, you're plain wrong. What's next, paint the grass red? It won't bring any spectators and will purely and simply ruin clay as a surface.
Finally, Nadal is totally entitled to have his opinions and express them. His opinions are at least as valid as yours (as a pro player's they're probably more valid actually). You're free to disagree but you have absolutely no business and no prerogative to "call him out on it". That is 100% out of line.

Great post! That's the way I read it too.
 

veroniquem

Bionic Poster
I don`t think this is true. Tennis is losing popularity in US, mainly because of lack of top US player, but not in the rest of the world. So I don`t think any big change is needed, especially I don`t think blue clay would make any difference in that respect.
Change not always means something will be better, so you should also watch what you wish for, because due to changes tennis might lose lots of current fans.
For example, what they did to doubles, with stupid new scoring rules is ridiculous and completely ruined the game.
So true, I dislike the new rules in doubles as well and I don't see that it has made the doubles any more popular with the masses.
 

veroniquem

Bionic Poster
j'en suis persuade que ca change rien...
Est-ce que tu es Europeen? Tu as vu le court bleu? J'aime la coherence dans la terre battue en Europe. Si tu commences a creer des divisions, tu mets en danger l'avenir de la surface en general. Je n'ai pas envie qu'elle se retrouve reduite a 2 tournois par an comme l'herbe. Tu connais l'expression: "diviser pour mieux regner"?
 
Last edited:

djones

Hall of Fame
who's insecure

3 of the 4 in the Champions league semis were from england

its common knowledge that spanish and italian football allows cheating as a legitimate tactic

its in their nature

and as much as i love C.Ron, he's a cheater

That counts for every single soccer player, they are all taught to cheat.
 

veroniquem

Bionic Poster
read this thread entirely please. would you as a tennis fan rather watch blue clay matches once per year, or loose televised matches per year. of course this is stretching the facts by a great extent, but until its tried who really knows. check the nielsen ratings over the past decade or so, were loosing this sport entirely.

League time, have fun with this debate.
You mean US viewers would want to watch more clay court tennis on TV if the clay was blue? (or just any color but red?) Good luck with that idea.
 

TheTruth

G.O.A.T.
The fact that the players are criticizing it is valid enough. So far, Nadal, Federer, and Serena have come out as being opposed to it, three of the biggest stars in the sport, who are these unnamed stars who are ok with it? Do they get far enough for it to matter.

There is no logical reason for changing the clay and doing it so abruptly before the preparation of the second slam, especially without the players knowing about it. Roger said he found out when he drove past it. That is totally wrong no matter how you try to slice it.
 

maximo

Banned
Est-ce que tu es Europeen? Tu as vu le court bleu? J'aime la coherence dans la terre battue en Europe. Si tu commences a creer des divisions, tu mets en danger l'avenir de la surface en general. Je n'ai pas envie qu'elle se retrouve reduite a 2 tournois par an comme l'herbe. Tu connais l'expression: "diviser pour mieux reigner"?

Oui, je viens d'Europe. Et je n'ai jamais vue la terre battue en bleu.
 

veroniquem

Bionic Poster
Last edited:

Frankauc

Professional
Est-ce que tu es Europeen? Tu as vu le court bleu? J'aime la coherence dans la terre battue en Europe. Si tu commences a creer des divisions, tu mets en danger l'avenir de la surface en general. Je n'ai pas envie qu'elle se retrouve reduite a 2 tournois par an comme l'herbe. Tu connais l'expression: "diviser pour mieux regner"?

Mais l'expression "diviser pour mieux regner" ne veut pas dire justement que des couleurs de terre battue différentes seraient bénéfiques?
 

veroniquem

Bionic Poster
Je suis Francais, mais j'habite en Angleterre depuis 10 ans. ;)
Ah super! Je suis francaise mais j'habite aux USA depuis 11 ans. L'Europe me manque beaucoup, pas tant la France en particulier mais l'Europe en general. Ceci dit, j'aime la ville de NY.
 

GameSampras

Banned
Whats he whining about? he won the damn event. Shut up and play. The more ****** complains about tournaments he get cakewalks through the more I cant stand him. Hes turning into a whiny primadonna. Its like he complains about everything today even if he wins
 
Last edited:

maximo

Banned
Ah super! Je suis francaise mais j'habite aux USA depuis 11 ans. L'Europe me manque beaucoup, pas tant la France en particulier mais l'Europe en general. Ceci dit, j'aime la ville de NY.

il n'y a pas beaucoup de travail en France, alors j'ai decide de partir. :(
 

Leonidas

Professional
Je suis Francais, mais j'habite en Angleterre depuis 10 ans. ;)
Man i see you´re french. No wonder you are always talking trash about nadal. Roland Garros is the only place where the crowd is disrespecful towards Nadal. The guy won it 4 times and they still whistle when he tries to find a ball mark. the worst crowd ever. It was terrible whenm he played Grosjean and another time i remember he played mathieu. Nadal was 18 years old or so and the crowd tried hard to scare him. i guess they are sick of Spanish players winning there again and again. Im sorry for that crowd, since you´ll probably see him winning the FO more years ;)
 

dem331

New User
who's insecure

3 of the 4 in the Champions league semis were from england

its common knowledge that spanish and italian football allows cheating as a legitimate tactic

its in their nature

and as much as i love C.Ron, he's a cheater

Pathetic!!!!!!!!!!
 

veroniquem

Bionic Poster
Mais l'expression "diviser pour mieux regner" ne veut pas dire justement que des couleurs de terre battue différentes seraient bénéfiques?
Non, du point de vue de l'ATP qui represente les interets de la surface dure, il faut diviser la terre battue pour mieux conquerir ses proponents. L'expression signifie diviser l'adversaire pour mieux le dominer ensuite.
 

deltox

Hall of Fame
Can someone other than a Nadal hater harass me to no end over the issue? You have your opinion, I have mine. Stop trying to terrorize me into changing it because I won't and get off my back. You like the idea of multicolored clay courts, I don't. We have each expressed our reasons why, let's leave it at that and see what happens.

harrass you, you respond to my remarks and i reply, get over it, your not going to get the last word, grow up. im not A NADAL HATER, I DONT DISLIKE THE GUY AT ALL. in fact read my first post where i declare this to be the FIRST time i disliked something he said in a PC. Secondly, ive asked you to PROVE your points which you have avoided like the swine flu. your a *******, it a well known fact. the fact your hero dislikes the surface is why you dislike it. ive simply given rebuttle of your points with great success while you have merely added more opinions.

also, tennis as a whole based on ratings and advertising commercial costs have went down WORLDWIDE!
at least GJ011 has simply said he doesnt believe it to be true, and he personally dislikes it, being perfectly honest about his opinions and not trying to hide behind half facts and heresay


its simple here, those that wish to be Rafas lovers on here simply cannot look past his words. if you want to shut me up, provide simple facts to the argument you are so passionately providing, otherwise, you should be the one to get off my back and shut up. i provided relevant arguments, while you fall back on opinion each time. grow up Veronique, chick or not your acting like a child about this whole thing.
 
Last edited:

deltox

Hall of Fame
I don`t think this is true. Tennis is losing popularity in US, mainly because of lack of top US player, but not in the rest of the world. So I don`t think any big change is needed, especially I don`t think blue clay would make any difference in that respect.
Change not always means something will be better, so you should also watch what you wish for, because due to changes tennis might lose lots of current fans.
For example, what they did to doubles, with stupid new scoring rules is ridiculous and completely ruined the game.

i agree what they did to doubles sucks, but as for the sport loosing interest in the us alone, please google some commercial costs and ratings and viewer numbers. its declined at a steady rate since the mid 90s. even during federers prime it was going down. why do you think its so hard to find televised events outside your countries respectively, thus being forced into live streams with choppy reception and copyright infringments.
 

veroniquem

Bionic Poster
Man i see you´re french. No wonder you are always talking trash about nadal. Roland Garros is the only place where the crowd is disrespecful towards Nadal. The guy won it 4 times and they still whistle when he tries to find a ball mark. the worst crowd ever. It was terrible whenm he played Grosjean and another time i remember he played mathieu. Nadal was 18 years old or so and the crowd tried hard to scare him. i guess they are sick of Spanish players winning there again and again. Im sorry for that crowd, since you´ll probably see him winning the FO more years ;)
I disagree. Rafa has a lot of fans at RG. During the final a lot of fans who cannot get seats for the court Chatrier, gather outside (but inside the stadium) to celebrate another Rafa win, it's much more difficult to get tickets there than in NY for instance, the arena is much smaller and they don't put all the seats up for general sale. A lot of the seats are reserved for club players and those can be very jingoistic, support the French unconditionally and make a point of showing their difference from regular casual fans by snobbing the most popular player of the moment (they used to dislike Agassi as well). They usually support classical traditional players like Fed. They're mostly present during the second week and they do not represent the crowd at large.
 

cucio

Legend
I mostly watch tourneys on the internet. RG and Rome are okay, but watching Monte Carlo at stream quality is tough on the eyes, worst tournament to follow the ball by light-years, I think it is a combination of the colour of the court and the position/angle of the camera.

I don't see anything wrong with giving it a try. Even if the reason is to mimic a sponsor corporate colour. Hellooooo! The sponsors pay the big bucks to keep the sport going, I see the value in accommodating them to make the sponsoring more attractive, as long as it doesn't degrade the game and the broadcast quality.

So those are to me two valid and logic reasons, and a brand new tournament is the ideal place to test new things out. Will I miss the traditional colour of the clay? Yes. Do I think the idea has merit and might turn out good for the sport? Yes.
 
Sure she is :). Whats her major? Extortion of pro tennis players? I wonder who is paying her tuition? LOL.

Lol shes not as bad as Mirka who gets to travel round the world watching Roger and shes does nothing apart from stay in all the fancy hotels he pays for and orders room service that he pays for.
 

veroniquem

Bionic Poster
harrass you, you respond to my remarks and i reply, get over it, your not going to get the last word, grow up. im not A NADAL HATER, I DONT DISLIKE THE GUY AT ALL. in fact read my first post where i declare this to be the FIRST time i disliked something he said in a PC. Secondly, ive asked you to PROVE your points which you have avoided like the swine flu. your a *******, it a well known fact. the fact your hero dislikes the surface is why you dislike it. ive simply given rebuttle of your points with great success while you have merely added more opinions.

also, tennis as a whole based on ratings and advertising commercial costs have went down WORLDWIDE!
at least GJ011 has simply said he doesnt believe it to be true, and he personally dislikes it, being perfectly honest about his opinions and not trying to hide behind half facts and heresay


its simple here, those that wish to be Rafas lovers on here simply cannot look past his words. if you want to shut me up, provide simple facts to the argument you are so passionately providing, otherwise, you should be the one to get off my back and shut up. i provided relevant arguments, while you fall back on opinion each time. grow up Veronique, chick or not your acting like a child about this whole thing.
Prove what? I've already given all my arguments. If they don't convince you, too bad. Maybe you could read Federer and Serena's statements as well (I gave a link to that) and you'd be more prepared to give them some credit.
 

GameSampras

Banned
Lol shes not as bad as Mirka who gets to travel round the world watching Roger and shes does nothing apart from stay in all the fancy hotels he pays for and orders room service that he pays for.

You know what I mean? Why would any guys put with that ? GET A JOB women.. ya know?
 
Top