In the recent playoffs I hit an unretunable serve. The opposing team did not call it out. Thr roaming official who I thought was not in a good position to see it called it out. Was he right to do this?
I thought roving officials were not supposed to intervene when one team is giving the other the benefit of the doubt on a line call and play and out ball.
I thought they weren't allowed to intervene unless directly asked, but that may only be a college rule.
There was a big hullabaloo in my area last year because the officials never intervened except when asked and many of the officials thought that was the way it was supposed to be. It was finally communicated to all the officials and tournament players (they handed out these flyers explaining the role of officials) that the officials are indeed supposed to correct any incorrect call or make any missed call (eg: foot faults) whether they are asked to or not. But this is USTA; I don't know the policy in colleges.
Yes ... they are allowed to make any call at any time from any position.
However, my experience has more often been that they have been reluctant to make calls such as foot faults or line calls. I have found that the officials are at least as interested in socializing and resting than paying attention to the courts in question.
I played in a Senior Tournament, on a center court, so the match had a chair-umpire. On the first serve to me to the ad court, the ball was about a foot wide. I called it "out" and the chair ump over-ruled me and called it "in". He said he would be making the line calls for the match. Since I haven't had a chair-ump for many matches prior to this one, my natural instinct was to call an out ball out. The ump was making the call, on a ball furthest away from him, that I had the best view of. I didn't make an issue out of it since it was only the second point of the match and did't want to make an ass out of myself in front of several hundred spectators. Either the chair-ump was blind, or wanted to assert himself, that he would be making all the line calls for the match.
There were several hundred spectators watching a seniors tournament? Wow
I had 16,000 people watch me win Districts singles.
No really.
At a USTA junior tournament this summer my daughter called a serve out. It was clearly wide. The roving official said it was in and gave the other girl the point. On the changeover the other girl said "that serve was out by about two inches".
It didn't matter as my daughter won that game and the match. Just a strange case of the official trying a little too hard.
I think a player can overrule even the official can't they? Not that they would in most cases but I think I've heard that the player that was awarded the point can change the call over everyone if they deem the ball good? Has anyone else ever heard this?
I thought roving officials were not supposed to intervene when one team is giving the other the benefit of the doubt on a line call and play and out ball.
I would say the official was wrong unless there was something else going on (like, opponents aren't calling serves out until they see whether their return is a winner).
If this was a doubles match, I'm fairly sure that you are allowed to appeal to the ref to ask if the serve was out, even after you miss the volley because it happens so quickly. I have seen this in a couple matches.
^^^^ actually, due to Mac's disdain for the refs in general i recall seeing him give up a few points (been a long time now) when he knew they a blew a call against his foe.
Not what he claims in his book