I just went thru
the least dominant Slam runs of the OE (scroll to the bottom) to see if anyone has ever come close to earning this disputably dubious distinction:
1973 USO - This is the most bookend-y run I've come across, Newk eking out a 5-set W in 1R/F but largely breezing through the rest of the draw (including pre-'74 Jimbo in QF).
1975 AO - Newk had to survive a whopping FOUR 5-setters in 2R/4R/QF/SF, and the 4-set F vs. Jimbo was no walk in the park, either. It's almost a miracle this doesn't top (if that's the way to put it) Goran's Cinderella run as the most difficult of the OE (in GW%).
1985 AO - Edberg had to fend off Masur and Lendl in 5-set 4R/SF, but he had a bye into 2R and the AO field wasn't quite 100% yet. Far from the most demanding Slam run.
1985 Wimbledon - Boris' stunning run as a 17-year-old teen - unsurpassed to this day at SW19 and bested only by Chang at '89 RG - was understandably bumpy with 5-set 3R/4R vs. Nystrom and Mayotte, but his QF/SF/F were fairly uneventful 4-setters except for the 2 TBs vs.
red-hot Curren.
1989 RG - Perhaps the most famous of all gutsy Slam runs and I'm surprised that this failed to make the (pre-'14) OE top 20. But that's because Chang went the distance only vs. Lendl and Edberg in 4R/F.
1992 USO - Yes, this is Stefan's legendary run where he had to suffer grueling 5-setters vs. Krajicek, Lendl and Chang in 4R/QF/SF followed by a hardly gimme F vs. pre-Pistoling Pete. But his first three rounds were straight-set routs.
1999 RG - Dre needed 5 sets to dispatch Clement and a rejuvenated A. Medvedev in 2R/F, but the rest were relatively straightforward affairs.
2000 USO - Marat did struggle early including in 5-set 2R/3R, but as you'd gather from that spectacular beatdown on Pistol he did raise his game later on.
2001 Wimbledon - Everyone knows about Goran's nail-biters vs. Henman and Rafter. Before the SF/F, though, he was actually in commanding form with some of
the most sensational serving you'll ever see.
2004 RG - Yes, this is the one with the infamous F vs. Coria, and Gaudio also needed 5 sets to fend off Canas and Jiri Novak in 1R/2R. At the same time he broke serve a possibly OE-record (
confirmed at least since '91) 62 times.
2014 Wimbledon - Somewhat surprisingly this is Djoker's toughest Slam title, with the 5-set QF/F vs. Cilic and Fraud and tight sets throughout. That gives him 58.0% of GW (160/276), #19 at the bottom of the OE ladder.
2017 AO - Though Fraud did have those 5-setters vs. Kei, Stan and Bull in 4R/SF/F he didn't drop a set in the other rounds, just barely managing to stay out of the OE top 20 in lowest GW% at 58.3% (155/266).
2021 RG - Strictly speaking Djoker did have two 5-setters vs. Musetti and Tsits in 4R/F, but the last 3 sets of both matches were lopsided in his favor, hence
his above-average 62.2% of GW.
2022 AO - The so-called asterisk Slam with its greatest champ out, and Bull's 5-set struggles against Shapo and Med in QF/F seem to support that view... except he was never pushed for the rest of the fortnight.
2022 USO - Y'all already know about Carlitos' 5-setters vs. Cilic, Sinner and Tiafoe in 4R/QF/SF, but this still doesn't make the OE top 20 of the least winning Slam runs, just 0.2% (58.2% or 160/275) below Djoker's '14 Wimby and Stan's '16 USO (also 58.0% or 163/281).
So close but no cigar. Though '75 Newk seems to "win" this contest with a whopping 9 dropped sets only the SF was a notable 5-setter against a worthy opponent in Roche as opposed to '92 Edberg's heroic
consecutive battles against Krajicek, Lendl and Chang. And Stefan's 2nd USO is widely and justly considered one of the clutchest performances ever, which means, yes, a prolonged and gutsy run is arguably even more impressive than a perfect/dominant one.
Well, given his H2H vs. your boy that year one could say Fraud wins the whole shebang if he ekes out that 3rd-set TB vs. Delpo. But I know how you feel about Fedal at the majors.