Other (possible) records for Nole

Actually, that was deliberate. And it was in response to this statement of yours:

"You didn't address my point that even if it makes it psychologically easier, this doesn't mean that the player who surpasses the record doesn't have to become greater to do so."

(Yes, five re-reads make that jumble no more comprehensible. :) )

Double negative city may not have been your clearest route.

Briefly, another angle here would be to point out that records by definition require the bettering of existing marks. Many are the categories in which he's trailing. Going to take a Herculean effort even to come close.

There were no double negatives there... also I dont see how the statement of yours with "not" in it which makes perfect sense with it removed wasnt a mistake nor do I see how that is in anyway corresponds to the paragraph of mine you're taking grammatical isue with.

You've also now moved the goalposts to other records. Your position was the slam record (or a given record in general) needs to be surpassed significantly by the chaser for him to have truly surpassed the record holder. I assert that this is absurd.
 
There were no double negatives there... also I dont see how the statement of yours with "not" in it which makes perfect sense with it removed wasnt a mistake nor do I see how that is in anyway corresponds to the paragraph of mine you're taking grammatical isue with.

You've also now moved the goalposts to other records. Your position was the slam record (or a given record in general) needs to be surpassed significantly by the chaser for him to have truly surpassed the record holder. I assert that this is absurd.
How is confusing the rhetoric going to win you the argument?

It's tough enough when the facts are against you. Using double-talk as some sort of misdirection tactic doesn't work, either.

P.S. *...with which I'm taking issue. :) You're welcome. But anyway, the issue is clarity, not grammar.
 
How is confusing the rhetoric going to win you the argument?

It's tough enough when the facts are against you. Using double-talk as some sort of misdirection tactic doesn't work, either.

P.S. *...with which I'm taking issue. :) You're welcome. But anyway, the issue is clarity, not grammar.

The postscript doesnt help the issue if you want people to think you are interested in clarity and not intentionally diverting things with grammar concerns...
 
The postscript doesnt help the issue if you want people to think you are interested in clarity and not intentionally diverting things with grammar concerns...
You've already conceded the argument with the lingual smoke and mirrors stuff.

That postscript is a total aside at this point. Throwing you a bone more than anything.
 
You've already conceded the argument with the lingual smoke and mirrors stuff.

That postscript is a total aside at this point. Throwing you a bone more than anything.

Your tone is unwarranted. Think I'm gonna back out of this. You can believe you won. Peace
 
With Djokovic (hopefully) back in the picture on a consistent basis, I'm now feeling much more comfortable about Nadal's future. Djokovic knows how to handle him better than anyone else ever has. With a bit of luck, he might even one day be able to break Nadal's unbeaten moral streak, although that does admittedly seem impossible.
No one else handles those moonballs better than Nole. :)
 
1) not true since winning all four has been a goal of tennis players for decades
2) not true since Laver won the CYGS with even less surface differentiation.

You should edit the heading in original post to include ‘Djokovic fans only’. Otherwise there is bound to be a large number of Nadal and Fed fans chime in and the thread ends up being hijacked and turns into another GOAT debate.
 
No it isn't. And humorously enough he was saying those that came after Sampras had it easier, so that would include Federer. It is funny how people try to suit this so their favorite isn't included in the chasing.

As far as the main point, we could agree or disagree as to whether it truly makes it easier.

But let's grant the point as I did in my last post for the sake of argument: it is easier to have a target to chase.

You didn't address my point that even if it makes it psychologically easier, this doesn't mean that the player who surpasses the record doesn't have to become greater to do so.

Using your value system, there would be almost no point in any records in sports, the original 1st guys to acheive something would go down as the best forever in that metric.

It just doesn't make sense. It's illogical.
Well Federer got to 15 still in his prime so it's not like the chase fueled him up to keep going later in his career when say Sampras would retire/fall off.

And this is really no different from other records, you have to evaluate numbers based on the era they were compiled in, e.g. Wilt's 50 ppg average. I'm not saying Federer/Nadal counts are inferior than Sampras simply because they came later but they sure as hell aren't 6 and 3 slams better, and the only reason they are is because in the current era, it's easier to play longer. If the tennis talent pool keeps falling and some Murray level talent comes along and sweeps up a ton of majors by default, that has to be taken into context when ranking them.
 
I am surprised no one has mentioned HC Goat-Hood for Djoker.

@ the moment it stands

HC Slams 11-8 Fed

WTFs 6-5 Fed

HC M1000s 22-21 Djoker.

HC Slam (more important in my opinion) & WTF GOAT isn't high up on the list after the obvious Total Slam Count?

I am surprised by this as GS SFs & QFs seem to take precedence over my aforementioned potential records for Djoker to acquire?

As a Fed fan i'd gladly give Djoker the All-Time QF/SF counts over overall HC Goat-Hood & WTF Goat-Hood. The only way i am taking this is ... if in essence Djoker continues to block Nadal from the overall slam record in the process .

I thought this would be common amongst us Federista's?
Edit & Djoker fans alike ...

Total Weeks @ #1 could be the other candidate , but i feel safe as i think it's more difficult for Djoker to upend this record as opposed to knocking out 4 more HC slams & 2+ WTFs along the way ...

Hot streak for 10 crucial weeks is far more easier @ this stage of Djoker's career (considering his age + play-style) vs sustained dominance across various tournaments throughout the year .
 
Well Federer got to 15 still in his prime so it's not like the chase fueled him up to keep going later in his career when say Sampras would retire/fall off.

And this is really no different from other records, you have to evaluate numbers based on the era they were compiled in, e.g. Wilt's 50 ppg average. I'm not saying Federer/Nadal counts are inferior than Sampras simply because they came later but they sure as hell aren't 6 and 3 slams better, and the only reason they are is because in the current era, it's easier to play longer. If the tennis talent pool keeps falling and some Murray level talent comes along and sweeps up a ton of majors by default, that has to be taken into context when ranking them.

I would say the chase is why Federer is still out here. When Federer was locked in at 17 for years and if there was no Nadal or Djokovic behind him, he would most likely have left the game. Sampras' closest rival was Agassi with 8 and he knew there was no chance in hell of him passing him so there was really nothing else left for him to play for. Sampras chased Emerson, Federer chased Sampras, Nadal chased Federer, and Djokovic chased Nadal. The big 3 basically pushed each other when Sampras had no one really pushing him in his era, and only the record holder from a previous era.
 
Last edited:
Well Federer got to 15 still in his prime so it's not like the chase fueled him up to keep going later in his career when say Sampras would retire/fall off.

And this is really no different from other records, you have to evaluate numbers based on the era they were compiled in, e.g. Wilt's 50 ppg average. I'm not saying Federer/Nadal counts are inferior than Sampras simply because they came later but they sure as hell aren't 6 and 3 slams better, and the only reason they are is because in the current era, it's easier to play longer. If the tennis talent pool keeps falling and some Murray level talent comes along and sweeps up a ton of majors by default, that has to be taken into context when ranking them.

That they are inferior because they came later as an across the board principle (unless they pass Sampras by like 10 slams) was the only position I took issue with. And it was actually first verbalized (not by you) about Federer and Nadal needing to surpass him by "many" slams to equal him because he was chasing a moving target. I can't agree with that concept.

I agree with the rest of your post.
 
Say what? Wasn't his first masters on the dirt? If not for Nadal he'd prolly be the goddam clay GOAT. 05'-09', '11 and a bunch of random masters.
Fed reached his first RG SF in 2005, after having already won the other 3 majors.

So he peaked relatively late on clay.
 
I would say the chase is why Federer is still out here. When Federer was locked in at 17 for years and if there was no Nadal or Djokovic behind him, he would most likely have left the game. Sampras' closest rival was Agassi with 8 and he knew there was no chance in hell of him passing him so there was really nothing else left for him to play for. Sampras chased Emerson, Federer chased Sampras, Nadal chased Federer, and Djokovic chased Nadal. The big 3 basically pushed each other when Sampras had no one really pushing him in his era, and only the record holder from a previous era.

Agassi was still on seven Slams when Sampras last played.
 
I would say the chase is why Federer is still out here. When Federer was locked in at 17 for years and if there was no Nadal or Djokovic behind him, he would most likely have left the game. Sampras' closest rival was Agassi with 8 and he knew there was no chance in hell of him passing him so there was really nothing else left for him to play for. Sampras chased Emerson, Federer chased Sampras, Nadal chased Federer, and Djokovic chased Nadal. The big 3 basically pushed each other when Sampras had no one really pushing him in his era, and only the record holder from a previous era.


Federer himself quashed this notion during a recent presser , when he was asked if Nadal weren't around if he'd still have the same type of career (paraphrasing) . He said that with or without Nadal it wouldn't have been different.

Now of course this could be gamesmanship on his behalf , but Federer doesn't seem like the type to outright lie & especially as he did not hesitate in his reply. It seemed to be quite a genuine & reasonable reply.

If you think about it , to have the innate drive to be the best on the planet as he was before he even knew Nadal would be a contender , as he was 4-0 up on the slam count prior to Nadal's first . Even though Nadal had beat him in '04 Miami (hardly a reason to fear off of one single loss in a M1000) I don't think any extra drive could be made for when another ATG is in his way. All this does is bring out the true monster inside the closet to prove that he is the best. Nadal often himself admits to not wanting to face the toughest competition either as he has claimed in his pressers in the past.

Which athlete would? If you take into account that winning against the toughest competition is great for short term bragging rights @ the cost of shortening ones career in order to continue to win more? @ the end of the day winning trumps everything (for the very best of the best) as that is the goal of any pro-athlete in general , but it really becomes more apparent @ the very top.
Winning against the best competition is just icing on the cake. Stating the obvious i know , but i'm just trying to back up the reasons behind this type of thought process .

Lets not forget that all too often we get sucked into the names . As in competion = beating the biggest names as opposed to looking @ the quality of the matches themselves . I go back to the Gonzo theory of '07 AO. Is Gonzo better than Nadal for straight setting him? No , but during that isolated 2 week period @ that tournament he was better than Nadal , who was himself a 2 time GS Champ @ the time , whilst Gonzo was & still is a 0 time Slam champ. Quality >>>> Name.
 
For me CGS is now a precondition for any GOAT or top of all time debate. It shows that your wins are diversified across all possible tournaments. What’s never going to be clear is how to value diferent measures of diversification. Is one CGS and another 4 Wimbledons the same as two CGS? Open for debate.
Thst question pretty much asks if you would throw away 3 additional Wimb titles for just 1 more FO title. Only a simpleton would do this.
 
Last edited:
At this moment, the most realistic records for Novak are the AO GOAThood, the WTF GOAThood and the career masters record.
 
Not even talking about career slam w.r.t Pete, just that Nadal having 17 and Pete having 14 doesn't mean Nadal is way better because Nadal had a target to chase, didn't have to adapt to technology changes, and had more homogeneous conditions. If Pete's target had been 17 you can bet your bottom dollar he wouldn't have lost motivation as early as he did. Fed is a little better than Pete, but not 6 slams better.

And homogenized surfaces don't really mean the surfaces are the same, just that you can play more or less the same style on them and top players are top players on every surface. 32 seeds also make it easier for top guys.
Lol, I thought you dropped the 90's Clay act.
 
Federer himself quashed this notion during a recent presser , when he was asked if Nadal weren't around if he'd still have the same type of career (paraphrasing) . He said that with or without Nadal it wouldn't have been different.

Now of course this could be gamesmanship on his behalf , but Federer doesn't seem like the type to outright lie & especially as he did not hesitate in his reply. It seemed to be quite a genuine & reasonable reply.
Federer is being completely open and honest here about how he feels about this, and any other feeling is just being pushed in the back of his subconscious since it isn't his reality. Of course, when the scenario is reversed your mentality is subject to change but he can only speak from where he is now. Do I believe Federer would have played this long without two challengers close to him? No I don't because it's so hard to maintain that focus and drive when you don't have a goal or target to pursue. Nadal and Djokovic have pushed him in so many ways.
Which athlete would? If you take into account that winning against the toughest competition is great for short term bragging rights @ the cost of shortening ones career in order to continue to win more? @ the end of the day winning trumps everything (for the very best of the best) as that is the goal of any pro-athlete in general , but it really becomes more apparent @ the very top.
Winning against the best competition is just icing on the cake. Stating the obvious i know , but i'm just trying to back up the reasons behind this type of thought process .
Say it loud for the people in the back. I'm amazed that some people just don't get this, especially when we are talking about the best in the sport chasing history. I could not have said it better.
 
Thst question pretty much asks if you would throw away 3 additional Wimb titles for just 1 more FO title. Only a simpleton would do this.
That’s not the question. The question is if for a given number of slams won the distribution makes a difference. Is a CGS the same as 4 USOs?
 
That’s not the question. The question is if for a given number of slams won the distribution makes a difference. Is a CGS the same as 4 USOs?
No. Winning 4 different slams is better IMO.

But from that point on, the distribution doesn't matter anymore IMO. CGS + 4 more Wimb titles isn't below 2 of each.

The DCGS is just some shtick propped by the media because that's what they do on a regular basis. They shouldn't be taken seriously every time. Brad Gilbert's "GOAT list" before the AO 2017 final is a prime example of that.
 
Federer is being completely open and honest here about how he feels about this, and any other feeling is just being pushed in the back of his subconscious since it isn't his reality. Of course, when the scenario is reversed your mentality is subject to change but he can only speak from where he is now. Do I believe Federer would have played this long without two challengers close to him? No I don't because it's so hard to maintain that focus and drive when you don't have a goal or target to pursue. Nadal and Djokovic have pushed him in so many ways.

Say it loud for the people in the back. I'm amazed that some people just don't get this, especially when we are talking about the best in the sport chasing history. I could not have said it better.

Bolded #1 Even though i disagree with this statement i can understand where you're coming from. I believe that for Federer to achieve the success that he has , he would have needed to have such an internal drive inside of him . I think Fed/Nad have this , some people question Djoker to some nth degree on this .

When it comes to going to sleep & thinking about tennis i think it's Nadal , Federer & Djoker is close behind. But we'll never truly know for sure.

Bolded #2 Coming from a Djoker fan i can respect this , as coming from myself as a Fed fan i am open for easy attacks seeing as Fed himself has a diminished H2H record @ slams vs his fellow Big-3 rivals in Nad/Djoker. But i truly think this is true.

Marit Safin once said something like *I'm not like Nadal who goes to sleep thinking about tennis" lol! Safin used to go to sleep with the opposite sex in his spare time , "Safinets" . Now he has gone the holy route :D!
 
Last edited:
Federer is being completely open and honest here about how he feels about this, and any other feeling is just being pushed in the back of his subconscious since it isn't his reality. Of course, when the scenario is reversed your mentality is subject to change but he can only speak from where he is now. Do I believe Federer would have played this long without two challengers close to him? No I don't because it's so hard to maintain that focus and drive when you don't have a goal or target to pursue. Nadal and Djokovic have pushed him in so many ways.

Say it loud for the people in the back. I'm amazed that some people just don't get this, especially when we are talking about the best in the sport chasing history. I could not have said it better.

Putting aside the fact that you are now Federer's shrink, what is the target Federer is now pursuing?

8-)
 
Putting aside the fact that you are now Federer's shrink, what is the target Federer is now pursuing?

:cool:

I'm sorry man but I'm not available for anymore clients. LOL. :D It's what "I believe" and my opinion which is what all of us on this forum have at the end of the day, opinions.
 
All opinions aside. Fact.The Big-3 now have 50 Slams combined.More opinions :D Is there any other sport where this type of domination by 3 players has reached such staggering heights?
 
I'm sorry man but I'm not available for anymore clients. LOL. :D It's what "I believe" and my opinion which is what all of us on this forum have at the end of the day, opinions.

Did I not ask clearly enough, or you don't have an answer?

What is the target Federer is now pursuing?

8-)
 
I must admit , i was so happy for Djoker to block Nadal @ Wimby , Djoker had crushed our hearts in recent years with those 3 slam finals + AO16 SF. It's about time Nadal tasted the pain once again . Funnily enough i believe this is the 1st time in a slam match that Nadal played the role of the aggressor & was ultimately out-grinded .

Quite ironic . Ultronians thoughts/views on Wimby 2018 SF?

That & Djoker is my second favorite. I love the bad blood between Djoker & Fed , it adds so much spice to an already great match-up of style/variety vs the wall that goes dtl off both wings in his sleep .
 
Did I not ask clearly enough, or you don't have an answer?

What is the target Federer is now pursuing?

:cool:

This one's easy. To play on for another 14 years to nab those 3 pesky OSG maedallions to defeat Mury Goat-Hood , plus 1 more AO & USO , to become Goat everywhere on the big 5 titles being AO/W/USO/WTF /OG :D
 
Not a headline record, perhaps, but a telling fact about Djokovic's career is this:
The average rank of the opponents he has faced in his career has been higher than what any other player has faced in tennis history. This is specifically true for slams and masters events too.
http://www.ultimatetennisstatistics.com/record?recordId=HighestOpponentRank
http://www.ultimatetennisstatistics.com/record?recordId=HighestGrandSlamOpponentRank

Not that relevant imo. Federer faced Nadal in 2017 AO final, yet Nadal (and Fed himself) was ranked pretty low at the time. So this win, in terms of ranking, was a weak win for Fed which obviously is absurd.

Federer also faced Safin in AO 04 and Safin was ranked no.84 at the time I think. He was still a far better player than his ranking suggested. So rankings can definitely tell something but not the entire story.
 
Not that relevant imo. Federer faced Nadal in 2017 AO final, yet Nadal (and Fed himself) was ranked pretty low at the time. So this win, in terms of ranking, was a weak win for Fed which obviously is absurd.

Federer also faced Safin in AO 04 and Safin was ranked no.84 at the time I think. He was still a far better player than his ranking suggested. So rankings can definitely tell something but not the entire story.
Yes but the data set for this statistic is large and encompasses matches played over many years. A couple quirks it doesn't capture shouldn't diminish the overall picture it paints.
 
Yes but the data set for this statistic is large and encompasses matches played over many years. A couple quirks it doesn't capture shouldn't diminish the overall picture it paints.

I am in doubt over the overall picture it paints tbh. In Djokovic's case I can believe that the statistics illustrate strong competition. I am not sure, however, if on average this observation still holds.

I would need to look behind the numbers, see in what form those players were, what their career phases would be, were they peak/prime or pre/post peak etc. Too much to consider and therefore I can not rely on rankings only as a proxy for how strong an opponent is.

A ranking tells us how strong an opponent is ON AVERAGE over a certain time period. It does not always tell us how good his performance was on one specific day against one opponent.
 
A ranking tells us how strong an opponent is ON AVERAGE over a certain time period. It does not always tell us how good his performance was on one specific day against one opponent.
Of course. It's not an all-knowing statistic. However imperfect, it's probably the best you'll find that speaks to overall quality of opponents a player has faced in whatever period. Mean ELO opponent rating is similarly useful; Djokovic heads that list as well.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top