Agree with uremate. I prefer matte or glossy (didn't vote because I can't vote for both), but not to the extent that it influences my decision. Only if all else being equal.
BTW, even within each category there are variatoins. For example, between two glossy racquets LM Prestige and POG, LM Prestige has a fairly substantial layer of clear coating over the red pj, while POG's pj doesn't have that (or it's minimal). Likewise, I thought the rubbery pj of PK Laver S is soft and agreeable, but Volkl Tour 10 Gen 1 seems to be more tacky.