Beacon Hill
Hall of Fame
You have to admit Roddick was a very weak player so it was not much of an accomplishment for Federer to beat him. He didn't have a single weapon of any kind. Look, for instance, when a strong-era player like Djokovic played Roddick: he schooled him every time, practically toyed with him like an exhibition hit with a ball kid.Look which tired, fallacious old argument is being trundled out again...
Baghdatis, Gonzalez, Roddick all made GS finals (won 6 matches), and got beaten by Roger there, just the same as Novak, Rafa, Andy.
Weak era is utter c**p purely designed to denigrate Federer's achievements so that Djokovic and Rafa don't look so inferior to him, and you know it.