Peak Federer...Give me a break

[TMF]

You almost got it right

Ban OP. End thread.

Delete thread.

Ban OP.

 

[hawk eye]

It is relevant to peak level of play where it matters the most, slam finals.

14-4 in slam finals, wow impressive that Pete.

17-8 in slam finals, wow amazing that Roger.

14-6 in slam finals, good, no?

11-5 in slam finals, Borg was a beast.

You don't get do you? Maybe Novak had the highest peak level in the finals he won, higher than anyone else on the list. I'm not saying that he definitily had, but these numbers don't add anything to this topic.
More so, if he messed up 4 more semi's he'd be 7-3 on the list. Would that automatically increase his peak level?..

 

[RF20Lennon]

I must have missed that meeting where it was decided the peak of a player is weighed based on his H2H with another player and not what he was able to accomplish.

 

[augustobt]

Peak Nadal... Give me a break

Peak Nadal is overrated, never had a dominant h2h against Davydenko at his best seasons. How some can say that peak Nadal is better than peak anyone is ridiculous.

Nadal's h2h against Davydenko:
2008: 1-2
2009: 1-2
2010: 0-1
2011: 0-1

 

[ScottleeSV]

Peak Federer is overrated, never had a dominant h2h against Nadal at his best seasons unlike Djokovic who dominated Rafa 6-0 and Federer 4-1 in 2011. How some can say that peak Federer is better than peak Djokovic is just ridiculous.

Federer's h2h against Nadal:
2004: 0-1
2005: 1-1
2006: 2-4
2007: 3-2

The stat that truly counts from that same period (slams)...

2004 : 3-0
2005 : 2-1
2006 : 3-1
2007 : 3-1
(11-3)

 

[Carsomyr]

The stat that truly counts from that same period (slams)...

2004 : 3-0
2005 : 2-1
2006 : 3-1
2007 : 3-1
(11-3)

He didn't lose a final in 2005 if that's what you're getting at.

 

[Dharmaboy]

Love little boys like the OP posting stuff cuz they never watched any real tennis. Get a life you idiot.

 

[tennisaddict]

Delete thread.

Ban OP.

For a moment i read End OP, End thread.

 

[Failed overrule]

Federer is overrated player in general but he was very good against the field in 2004-2007. His serve and fh were clicking. That serve-fh combo and amazing fitness were a basis of his domination
But BH was even more pathetic than these days tbh. Love how some of his fanatics claim that his bh was a beautiful shot at his peak. Nadal and Nalby exposed that joke of bh like there is no tomorrow.

 

[Charlemagne]

Peak Federer is overrated, never had a dominant h2h against Nadal at his best seasons unlike Djokovic who dominated Rafa 6-0 and Federer 4-1 in 2011. How some can say that peak Federer is better than peak Djokovic is just ridiculous.

You're an assclown just like Chico. No sense of irony or moderation in any of your posts.

 

[uncle pollo]

Another stupid thread by a fat little girl.

 

[sliceroni]

Because Djokovic has been beating up late 20s Nadal, Federer had to deal with young fresh Nadal who didn't take off half the season. Stop overrating Djokovic, he isn't that good.

Djokovic's record in slam finals in his prime age exposes him. ******* 7 years past his prime with no forehand with his serve alone took him to 5 at Wimbledon.

 

[AssaultJoker]

Another stupid thread by a fat little girl.

Aren't you able to distinguish me with your sister?

 

[AssaultJoker]

Djokovic's record in slam finals in his prime age exposes him. ******* 7 years past his prime with no forehand with his serve alone took him to 5 at Wimbledon.

Federer lost, end of story.