Peak (Pre-injury) Juan Martin Del Potro vs Peak Stanimal (Stanislas Wawrinka) who is better?

[Ganstaz003]

1) Who is the better player / more dangerous player?

2) Who is the more entertaining player?

I'm referring to peak versions of both. So something like Juan Martin Del Potro from US Open 2009 final and Stanimal from 2015 Roland Garros final.

 

[Nolkobolko]

Stan
Stan

 

[ibbi]

It's an interesting question, ain't it? I think it should be noted that Stanimal's 3 appearances came against defensive players, and it wouldn't be so easy to go into beast mode against a guy who hits the ball harder, deeper and more aggressively than god.

In terms of pure entertainment I probably prefer to watch Stan play, but I don't think there's a player that's ever lived that would have it easy against top tier Delpo.

 

[NatF]

AO: Stan by far
FO: I think Del Potro's 2009 FO level is there with Stan's 2015, but have to give Stan the edge for FO
Wim: Del Potro is better on grass, 2012 OLY and 2013 Wim
USO: Slight edge to Del Potro

Probably going with Stan. I think if Del Potro was able to develop past 2009 he would have been superior.

 

[Sport]

.

 

[H_Richardson]

Stan has the edge but maybe Delpo would've become the stronger player had he not been injured.

 

[vive le beau jeu !]

entertaining match... decided on a couple of points

 

[MasturB]

Healthy Peak Del Po and I love Stan but that Del Po forehand is just...