Pickleball industry needs to take sound issue seriously

ByeByePoly

G.O.A.T.
I have no idea where paddles and balls will end up … I still think replaceable paddle surface skins (rubber?) might work similar to restringing tennis racquets. It might also be a solution for those that have spent significant $ on existing paddles.

I would also throw in perhaps a billion carbon faced paddles in landfill might not be a good thing. :p

Where will paddles end up … some are at least thinking about it

 

ByeByePoly

G.O.A.T.
lol … just watching that video … McEnroe was right … ball hit right on line.

Jeeze this thread is more likely to get derailed than a Norfolk Southern train (too soon? :unsure: )
 
Last edited:

travlerajm

Talk Tennis Guru
lol … just watching that video … McEnroe was right … ball hit right on line.

Jeeze this thread is more likely to get derailed than a Norfolk Southern train (too soon? :unsure: )
In my tournament match last night, opposing gal hit a first serve, that ticked the net, causing it to shoot from a would-be short serve to deep in the box. I called a let serve as I was swinging at it.

But opposing gal’s partner said it was 2 feet over the net. Said I was crazy. Am I?
 

1HBHfanatic

Legend
-btw the PENN (outdoor) pickleball ball is quieter
-its got a good bounce!, not the best, but not the worst either
-its a softer slower ball!, so it is a good winter time ball IMO
-i bought a 3pk to test and bring them out on cold nights
-we crack too many frank.X balls in sub 40 temps
-i have some other cheaper balls also, but the PENN balls have a nicer bounce

-did i mention it is notably QUIETER!! (y) (y)
-but be ready to have to defend its "virtues" from all the ball snubs who only like high bounce balls!
 

mcs1970

Hall of Fame
This is a serious thread. :cool:


That gave me this gem as a recommendation. I had not seen it all these years

Coming to the not so serious topic of pickleball the best solution is make no changes to the gear but to keep it indoors only at rec centers. Win / Win for all.
 

ByeByePoly

G.O.A.T.
That gave me this gem as a recommendation. I had not seen it all these years

Coming to the not so serious topic of pickleball the best solution is make no changes to the gear but to keep it indoors only at rec centers. Win / Win for all.

nope … I am playing indoors … can’t even hear opponent call score. This is for them and us. 8-B

one small step for man ….
 

albertf

New User
Indoors is the worst for pickleball with all the echoing. I'm wondering if the easiest way to reduce sound is to experiment with different ball constructions. It let's people keep using the fancy paddles that were approved and purchased by everyone.
Most people haven't committed hundred of dollars towards balls and it's pretty easy to for a tournament/league to just say xxx brand is the official ball we'll be using.
 

ByeByePoly

G.O.A.T.
Indoors is the worst for pickleball with all the echoing. I'm wondering if the easiest way to reduce sound is to experiment with different ball constructions. It let's people keep using the fancy paddles that were approved and purchased by everyone.
Most people haven't committed hundred of dollars towards balls and it's pretty easy to for a tournament/league to just say xxx brand is the official ball we'll be using.

I wonder if it’s too late … like quiet slot machines. :-D

I know one thing … don’t think any ball will stop my paddle buying problem. :cry:$$$

Paddle companies should sell yearly memberships … you get new yearly releases like an iPhone.
 

bigserving

Hall of Fame
I saw on the news earlier today that quieter equipment is on the way. Quieter paddles as well as quieter balls.
 

Westerwick

Rookie
I saw on the news earlier today that quieter equipment is on the way. Quieter paddles as well as quieter balls.
Yes, in spite of near total mismanagement by USA Pickleball. Both their ball and paddle specifications are reactive, not proactive specs. They took some very primitive equipment, measured and described it, and left those as specifications. The ball is little more than the whiffle balls we used to bat around with broomsticks. The paddle isn't much more than a board with a non-slip surface. They could have required manufacturers to solve the problem by including noise specifications in their specs for both the ball and the paddles. They even went out of their way to specifically prohibit the one quick fix that would drop the noise by several dB on most paddles, which is drilling a hole pattern that would break up the resonance you get from the paddle as a sounding board for ball impacts.

Compare this to tennis racquets, which have a wide variety of shapes, strings, tensions and sizes, and the wide range of tennis balls being used. I think it speaks to the immaturity of the game and its governing authority.
 
In the winter I play in an indoor facility with all cinder block walls. Nine indoor courts are so noisy it's tough to hear the score.
They really could hang some sound baffles from (the very high) ceiling.

I'm really eager for spring ... when my own court on my own property is free of snow. If the municipalities were less idiotic about putting pickleball courts so close to residences, it wouldn't be a problem.

I posted about this on another thread, but one residence (I don't recall where.) complained about a trail head which was about 40 feet from their house being turned into 4 pickleball courts by the HOA. That's not the fault of pickleball; that's the fault of the planners.

- Dink
 
I remember when ping-pong paddles were made with the "new" foam surfaces. It was really strange to me ... a sandpaper surface purist. And when I tried the foam ... what an adjustment!

Now nobody believes me when I tell them I played with sandpaper surfaced paddles.

Personally, I'd welcome a move to some sort of rubber or foam surface. I could probably put even better topspin on the pickleball!

- Dink
 

sureshs

Bionic Poster
I remember when ping-pong paddles were made with the "new" foam surfaces. It was really strange to me ... a sandpaper surface purist. And when I tried the foam ... what an adjustment!

Now nobody believes me when I tell them I played with sandpaper surfaced paddles.

Personally, I'd welcome a move to some sort of rubber or foam surface. I could probably put even better topspin on the pickleball!

- Dink
Foam? TT paddles have rubber over sponge.
 
Top