Short crap returns terrible strategy ... crush them.
Good players generally don’t return short because the idea is too keep serving team back as much as possible. But depending on server’s mobility, can cause issues.
This is what I would try. Deep serve always the answer … but as you said it was off of deep serves:
- try deep slower serve but with lots of height … it will give you a split second more time to read the planned short return
- cheat inside the baseline a little right after your serve. We don’t generally do that because you can get caught at feet forced to backup, have to weigh your options for that opponent (maybe their deep return is nonexistent)
- another option is low deep serve with pace making them move across baseline to hit ros … usually a player can’t hit as precise a drop on the run
- sidespin serves can end some of those type of players fun and games
I play tight on baseline sometimes on return of serve … totally against the standard pickleball instruction. One day our 5.0 instructor asked why I do this. I said because not many here hit a serve with enough pace to cause me to miss the return if I have to backup a little … and proficient right off bounce from tennis. But many, some by accident hit a crap serve just past kitchen line. With two hamstring injuries at the end of my tennis ... I choose backing up a little on some returns. Obviously exceptions … hard servers that never hit short … I stay further behind line with those players.