Rafael Nadal was telling fibs at the Australian Open - he is clearly a man in pain

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 3771
  • Start date Start date
D

Deleted member 3771

Guest
good article:

Rafael Nadal was telling fibs at the Australian Open - he is clearly a man in pain

By Simon Briggs, Tennis Correspondent, in Melbourne

Spaniard's determination to mask his frailties after defeat to Tomas Berdych was understandable, but he was kidding nobody

In the nicest possible way, Rafa, we have to say that you told a bunch of fibs in Melbourne after your defeat to Tomas Berdych.

You fibbed because it was expedient. And you fibbed because the etiquette of the locker-room frowns on players talking about physical aches and pains after a defeat. But there can be little doubt that you fibbed.

Asked about the pill that you swallowed early in the third set of your 6-2, 6-0, 7-6 blowout, you replied “Yeah, happened nothing. I am feeling well. That's it. That's part of the things that happen sometimes during the matches, but nothing important to say.”

Feeling well? Come off it, Rafa. It might be true that you played a respectable standard of tennis in that third set. Respectable, though nothing special. But for the first two sets you were operating at what the Australians – with their felicity for vivid language – would refer to as “half rat power”.

The most revealing thing is that – up until around the hour mark – you weren’t chasing down Berdych’s attacking shots when they went past you, but simply watching them fly by with that characteristic raised left eyebrow.

At one point, a ball bounced off the net-cord and died on your side of the court, and you didn’t even take a step towards it. You probably wouldn’t have got there anyway, but you have spent your career chasing down lost causes and achieving the apparently impossible. This morning, you were like a champion greyhound who, one strange day, failed to react when the hare was released.

Your explanation of the match – Berdych’s first win against you in 18 attempts – was gracious and detailed. “Coming back from an injuries,” the argument went, “you lose more easier the feeling than what you do when you are on rhythm, when you are with no injuries, when you are confident in yourself that you played a lot of matches.”

We aren’t disputing this point. It is true that you are coming back from a whole bunch of injuries, and illness as well. In physical terms, 2014 was a nightmare year for you. It started with the back spasms that ruined your final here against Stan Wawrinka, and then progressed through wrist trouble to appendicitis.

But to say that you lost because “I didn't play with the right confidence, with the right intensity, losing court, playing very short” can only be half the story. A lack of confidence wouldn’t normally stop you chasing the ball; if anything, it would probably make you more desperate in your defence.

The TV cameras picked up a couple of clues. A grimace while stretching out the right hamstring and back. A clutch of the right thigh when sitting down at a changeover. The right leg certainly didn’t seem to be working too well, judging by the way you struggled to push off towards your forehand side. The same forehand side, that is, that has chopped Berdych into tiny pieces of kindling in your last 17 meetings.

nadal2_3177560a.jpg

Down and out: Rafael Nadal looks disconsolate

We know that every tennis player has sore spots when he takes the court. We also know that you don’t like making excuses after a loss, feeling that it is disrespectful to your opponent. And we know that there was nothing malicious about your dissembling in the post-match press conference.

But this wasn’t the real Rafa out there against Berdych. This was a man battling his own body. And we’re worried about you, because that body doesn’t seem to be holding up too well these days.

Perhaps that was another reason why you didn’t want to talk about what you were really feeling on the court, especially during those first two sets. Perhaps you’re worried too, and just want to get back to see your medical advisors in Spain.

You did say before the tournament that “My back, I don’t have enough time having good feelings to say I am 100 per cent perfect, no? I need to take care about this for the moment.” We know that you had platelet-rich plasma injections in your spine last year, and that the trouble that afflicted you against Wawrinka never completely cleared up.

When Andy Murray had his own spinal operation 18 months ago, it was to deal with a combination of back pain and sciatica – which is defined as pain, numbness and weakness running down the legs. A similar sort of problem would be entirely consistent with your inhibited movement on the court today.

Ultimately, Rafa, we don’t know for sure. We can understand why you don’t want to talk about it, and we certainly hope you find a way to treat the issue. At the same time, though, we weren’t born yesterday.
 
Yes, I read that when it was published and agree with it.

The real question is will he ever be sufficiently recuperated this time around to reach his former level?

The answer at the moment seems no.
 
Since we all know that the only way he loses is if he is injured...... Didn't seem to bother him in the previous rounds, and nothing happened to him except a butt whipping against Berdych.
 
What a stupid article. The only purpose is to somehow malign Nadal. He did not say anything himself so journalists (like that stupid guardian one) have to make up stories themselves.
 
Yes, well, all players observe the no excuse norm, but Nadal less than others.

But his assertion is that something more is happening with Nadal than he is prepared to say.

It's hard to argue against that given that Nadal played the first two sets with a 'let's not run for the ball' policy.


The article lost me when it asserted Rafa doesn't like making injury excuses after a loss.

I mean. .really? He wrote that with a straight face???!?
 
Last edited:
An opinion is an opinion is an opinion.

But I don't find the 'lack of 'match practice' opinion convincing based on what I've seen of Nadal's play.

There's a major deterioration in his game so whether that's temporary or permanent is the question.
 
Well... Its amazing he has lasted 10 years with his style of game. I only gave him 4-5 years with that crazy physical style. Then again, I can't believe Nole has lasted as long as he has either
 
These articles are written keeping simpletons like you in mind who would buy anything because it is in the paper.
I'm quite the opposite of a simpleton, thanks.

What I do is take complex things and dumb them down for dyslexic helmet-heads who can't spell words like "pez" . . .
 
I dont know its so hard to tell with him. His back crashes out at aussie last year. Shows up in Rio 3 weeks later has some trouble but wins tournament. Loses early at Indian wells, then gets to final in Miami. Loses early in Monte Carlo, which never happens, then for some reason goes to play barcelona where again he loses, wins madrid by the skin of his teeth then gets to Italy and loses in finals. Now is he hurting that bad with these results well maybe but somehow he wins French? Then gets smoked by two big hitters on grass and thats it till fall season where he does nothing and says its his apendix. I mean something is off with the guy. But how do you win a slam if your all messed up. So on one hand I think yea hes messed up on the other maybe he just is not as good as he was. He keeps ya guessing thats for sure.
 
I don't remember where I saw it, but sport scientists determined that Nadal usually puts a force of around 5G on his knees, his hips and his back and they said that every body will break under that force at some point... Just for comparison purposes, Federer's smoother movement and better transition of weight (distribution of force throughout the body) usually puts a force of around 3G on his body. Perhaps we're finally seeing the consequences of Nadal's playstyle now?
 
I don't remember where I saw it, but sport scientists determined that Nadal usually puts a force of around 5G on his knees, his hips and his back and they said that every body will break under that force at some point... Just for comparison purposes, Federer's smoother movement and better transition of weight (distribution of force throughout the body) usually puts a force of around 3G on his body. Perhaps we're finally seeing the consequences of Nadal's playstyle now?

I'd love to see the date/special on this. Maybe it was sports science? Seems interesting though.
 
I don't remember where I saw it, but sport scientists determined that Nadal usually puts a force of around 5G on his knees, his hips and his back and they said that every body will break under that force at some point... Just for comparison purposes, Federer's smoother movement and better transition of weight (distribution of force throughout the body) usually puts a force of around 3G on his body. Perhaps we're finally seeing the consequences of Nadal's playstyle now?
I'd love to see the date/special on this. Maybe it was sports science? Seems interesting though.

I saw in some thread here yesterday.
Edit: Here you go:
http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/sports/tennis/2010-05-20-rafael-nadal-knee-injuries_N.htm
 
Last edited:
We also know that you don’t like making excuses after a loss, feeling that it is disrespectful to your opponent. And we know that there was nothing malicious about your dissembling in the post-match press conference.


Perhaps that was another reason why you didn’t want to talk about what you were really feeling on the court,

Ultimately, Rafa, we don’t know for sure. We can understand why you don’t want to talk about it,

Mum's the word.

#champagne :D :D
 
What a stupid article. The only purpose is to somehow malign Nadal. He did not say anything himself so journalists (like that stupid guardian one) have to make up stories themselves.

Yeah, I agree. I think journalist are a lot to blame for the tension between all fanbases.
 
Well... Its amazing he has lasted 10 years with his style of game. I only gave him 4-5 years with that crazy physical style. Then again, I can't believe Nole has lasted as long as he has either

I am confused.

Did you not start a thread the other day 'Nadal is injury prone.It is not his style of play'..

http://tt.tennis-warehouse.com/showthread.php?t=519695
we mere posters, limited by our narrow binary conception of the world, aren't properly equipped to understand the multidimensionnal subtility of 60's weed's intuitions...

4_greensmilies-020.gif
 
Well... Its amazing he has lasted 10 years with his style of game. I only gave him 4-5 years with that crazy physical style. Then again, I can't believe Nole has lasted as long as he has either

Why? Nole is one of (if not the most) fittest and flexible guy on tour. His body is supple and well maintained with his side practices of yoga. If anything, he may be one of the only from his current generation (murray/nadal) that will find success when in their post 30s.
 
Yes, well, all players observe the no excuse norm, but Nadal less than others.

But his assertion is that something more is happening with Nadal than he is prepared to say.

It's hard to argue against that given that Nadal played the first two sets with a 'let's not run for the ball' policy.


GTFO. If I forget any TT, please chime in.

FO 2009: ouch, my knee!(though he didn't look hampered at all)
Before IW 2012: the knee is perfect, no?
After IW 2012: I have the pain of the knee (but played doubles in Miami anyway)
Wimbledon 2012:the knee, she is bad (after grinding out another FO the week before)
AO 2014: crikey, me back!
USO 2008: I tired from Olympics and hard court no Bueno for the knee. Es too many hc, no?

AO 2011: my...knee? Thigh? Groin?
 
Yes, well, Nadal does make excuses but maybe this time it's not so much that he's injured, or purportedly injured, but rather baffled by his own drop in speed around the court and is in denial about it.
 
What a stupid article. The only purpose is to somehow malign Nadal. He did not say anything himself so journalists (like that stupid guardian one) have to make up stories themselves.

Yep, saw it yesterday & thought it was pretentious-writing it like an open letter as if Nadal is going to care what some random sports journalist is saying. Everybody knows Nadal came in off major surgery hurt, lacking in energy & rusty. If he talks about those things then he gets lambasted for making excuses & if he doesn't then he gets lambasted for not talking about his injuries.

I think it is similar to Murray at last years event-he was coming off major surgery & still made it to the last eight & took a set off Fed in that match. Nadal battled through to the last eight here & it was a bridge to far. One year on Murray is in the final, next year Nadal could easily be as well.
 
we mere posters, limited by our narrow binary conception of the world, aren't properly equipped to understand the multidimensionnal subtility of 60's weed's intuitions...

4_greensmilies-020.gif
Man, you crack me up. 60's Weed? :lol:

Need a new keyboard right now, my coffee just landed on it. :evil:
You show the true Fine Art of Trolling. Don't ever stop! :D
 
Last edited:
I don't think it's much of moving speed. The serve and forehand lost oomph (in 2014) and have not recovered, IMHO. I think his movement is fine, meaning he still moves better than others, most of time.
 
The journalist just cannot accept that Nadal might lose a match legitimately.

He is one of those people who thinks that absolutely no-one beats Nadal. When Nadal loses, Nadal def. Nadal. Whatever.
 
The journalist just cannot accept that Nadal might lose a match legitimately.

He is one of those people who thinks that absolutely no-one beats Nadal. When Nadal loses, Nadal def. Nadal. Whatever.

Thats the sad part. And almost the case verytime he looses amongst tennis people.
 
Makes you wonder if the tennis journalists fear being shut out of any future interview access if they don't float these silly injury excuses. Just ridiculous. Nadal was moving fine. Berdych played aggressively and moved Nadal around before Nadal could do the same to him.
 
Back
Top