Rank the 3 slam seasons by the big three

[RS]

Yove to bait. I rated Murray 2012 AO SF over Federer 2006 AO final performance, not over 2006 AO Federer as a whole. You left that part out.

That's what I was saying. Murray AO 12 SF out of 10 but you claim you never saw it?

When I said AO 12 I meant the Djokovic match more than any others.

 

[NoleFam]

That's what I was saying. Murray AO 12 SF out of 10 but you claim you never saw it?

When I said AO 12 I meant the Djokovic match more than any others.

I know what you meant. I said in the other thread I read it as Wim 2012 SF for some reason. But no, I wouldn't rate Murray's 2012 AO tournament over Federer's 2006 AO as a whole. Only 2012 SF performance over 2006 final performance.

 

[RS]

I know what you meant. I said in the other thread I read it as Wim 2012 SF for some reason. But no, I wouldn't rate Murray's 2012 AO tournament over Federer's 2006 AO as a whole. Only 2012 SF performance over 2006 final performance.

Out of 10 tho?

 

[Biotic]

I think AO '04 Fed was his 2nd best level there by far, and similar to the likes of '13 Djokovic or '09 Nadal

Like many others nowdays, this analysis rests on what Djokovic/Nadal actually did and what Federer would've done.