When I went over how the 10 of you who made lists, excluding myself, ranked Federer this is what I came across with:
Forehand-8 1sts, 1 2nd, 1 7th, an average ranking of 1.7 per person
Backhand-2 1sts, 4 2nds, a 3rd, a 4th, a 6th, a 7th, an average ranking of 3.0 per person
Serve-6 2nds, a 3rd, a 5th, a 7th, an average ranking of 3.0 per person
Return-1 1st, a 2-way tie 2nd(2.5), 6 3rds, a 2 way tie 5th(5.5), a 7th, an average ranking of 3.4per person
Movement-5 1sts, 3 2nds, a 2-way tie 4th(4.5), a 7th, an average ranking of 2.25 per person
Mental-1 1st, 4 2nds, a 5-way tie 2nd(4), a 3rd, a 4th, a 7th, avg. of ranking of 3.0 per person
Net play-8 3rds, a 2-way tie 5th(5.5), a 7th, an average ranking of 3.65 per person
Out of 7 people the middle ranking per category is 4th so I was pretty happy to see that Federer was below the average ranking of 4.0 in every category, 1.7 in one which is the highest, 2.3 in another which might be highest or second highest, 3.0 in 3 categories which could be the second or third highest, and 3.4 and 3.65 in the other 2 categores which is still below the 4.0 middle ranking.
However then I realized I was discounting my own because of possable extreme bias yet I was counting the category rankings of the two anti-Federer trolls on here-The Gorrilla and the Anointed One. So I decided to redo Federer's ranking average without those two.
Forehand-8 1sts, an average ranking of 1.0 per person(as opposed to 1.7 with the 2 anti Fed trolls)
Backhand-2 1sts, 4 2nds, a 3rd, a 4th, an average ranking of 2.1 per person(as opposed to 3.0 per person with the 2 anti Fed trolls)
Serve-6 2nds, a 3rd, an average ranking of 2.1 per person(as opposed to 3.0 per person with the 2 anti Fed trolls)
Return-1 1st, a 2-way tie 2nd(2.5), 6 3rds, an average ranking of 2.75 per person(as opposed to the average ranking of 3.4 per person with the 2 anti Fed trolls)
Movement-5 1sts, 3 2nds, an average ranking of 1.4 per person(as opposed to an average ranking of 2.25 per person with the 2 anti Fed trolls)
Mental-1 1st, 4 2nds, a 3rd, a 4th, an average ranking of 2.3 per person(as opposed to an average ranking of 3.0 per person with the 2 anti Fed trolls)
Net play-8 3rds, an average ranking of 3.0 per person(as opposed to an average ranking of 3.65 per person with the 2 anti Fed trolls)
Now Fed goes to an unaminous 1st place in forehands with a 1.0, an overall first place in movement with a 1.4, an almost unaminous second place in serve with a 2.1, a close to 2nd place average of 2.1 on backhand and 2.3 on mental game which might be in the running for 1st overall ranking, and a just below 3rd place average ranking of 2.75 on return, with the worst being an unaminous 3rd on the net game.
Without the 2 Federer trolls who ruined Roger's deserved rankings I am very pleased with how you have slated him so far.