Return of serve - my weakest shot

JonC

Banned
Got killed last night by a lefty slice serve to my backhand. I'd bet that most of my points are lost by not being able to return a serve. How do other people practice the return of serve?
 

LHM

Rookie
personally depending on what the serve is like, I tend to stand back an extra yard or so, it gives me that little extra time to deal with the ball. Its always best to move into the ball than moving back.
 

LeeD

Bionic Poster
Against a lefty, stand IN, take an aggressive cut at the ball, either topspin, sidespin, or slice, never back off, never lean back.
If you stand back, most lefty's swing you wider and wider.
 

jhick

Hall of Fame
If he's slicing out wide, step in, start way out wide, and dare him to hit the serve down the T. If he's good at mixing up serves and can bomb it with consistency down the T, or hits a good kicker, you might have your work cut out for you. At that point, you'll probably just need to guess and commit early.
 

samarai

Semi-Pro
on the ad side of a lefty serve, i am set continental and always slice it back. I dare him to go up the middle by standing more to the sideline. On the duce side i can usually take a good two handed backhand to it.
 
Position yourself properly for the lefty serve. When I play a lefty, my both feet are behind the singles court on the deuce-court, and on the ad-court both of my feet are behind the doubles alley! This takes the angle of the lefty slice away, forces them to hit perfectly placed serves.
 

JonC

Banned
personally depending on what the serve is like, I tend to stand back an extra yard or so, it gives me that little extra time to deal with the ball. Its always best to move into the ball than moving back.

Wouldn't have helped - I was ending up in the net that seperates the courts but standing back. The only think that worked was taking it real early which I'm not too good at. If I could just know that he's going to hit a slice - some people can read serves.
 

JonC

Banned
Against a lefty, stand IN, take an aggressive cut at the ball, either topspin, sidespin, or slice, never back off, never lean back.
If you stand back, most lefty's swing you wider and wider.

Yeah - I did that towards the end and it was the only way to get my racquet on the ball but it's like I'm floundering around out there. It's the one stroke I can't practice on my own.
 

JonC

Banned
do you have problem receiving overall or just against lefty slice?

Anything to my backhand (1h) and problems with a good slice on both sides (lefty serve to ad and righty to deuce). I can chip it back on the backhand side which is ok in singles but not doubles. I just don't have that quick-draw backhand drive.
 

JonC

Banned
Great advice btw. I should have thought about positioning to force him to go up the middle - knowing how hard it is for me to place a serve up the middle.
 
Optimum solution is to return the ball early with a slice before it bounces too high or wide.

A SLICE hit early off the bounce, how's it even possible to hit slice into a rising ball? :confused:

I'd rather go for topspin. Focus on transfering body weight forward through the ball, so start the preparation as early as possible, and use very short backswing.
 

jhick

Hall of Fame
A SLICE hit early off the bounce, how's it even possible to hit slice into a rising ball? :confused:

Not sure why it would be difficult to hit a slice early off the bounce, I do this all the time. In my experience, it's actually easier than hitting topspin because you have more time to react as your point of contact isn't out in front of your body.
 
Not sure why it would be difficult to hit a slice early off the bounce, I do this all the time. In my experience, it's actually easier than hitting topspin because you have more time to react as your point of contact isn't out in front of your body.

Are you sure that the ball is still rising when you make contact with the ball? Can you hit a slice into a rising ball within a rally.
 

LeeD

Bionic Poster
Slicing the return works fine in doubles up to 5.0.
The slice stroke is just like a backhand volley. Simple, keep it low.
 

donquijote

G.O.A.T.
A SLICE hit early off the bounce, how's it even possible to hit slice into a rising ball? :confused:

I'd rather go for topspin. Focus on transfering body weight forward through the ball, so start the preparation as early as possible, and use very short backswing.

Federer has been doing it for years to start a rally with a slice backhand return. Same can be done with the forehand. I've been doing it for years :)

Early hitting doesn't necessarily mean very low to the ground. It's just about timing before ball goes higher than your waist. It is 'early' compared to a topspin return which is much harder to master and also can be inconsistent. You have to be a few steps back for the topspin and have much wider area to cover and reach.
 

jhick

Hall of Fame
Are you sure that the ball is still rising when you make contact with the ball? Can you hit a slice into a rising ball within a rally.

Yep. In fact when I am not in a great position on the backhand and get a ball that bounces close to me, I find this is the easier shot to hit.
 

LeeD

Bionic Poster
You gotta think a little....
Ball is rising.
Slice is hit downwards swing.
Topspin shots are swung upwards, creating a tougher angle for meeting the ball square on.
 

jhick

Hall of Fame
WTH, fewer mishits? :confused:

If ball is moving up, and racquet down, you need peRFect timing to succeed!

If you are hitting the ball on the rise, I would argue that you need good timing to hit any shot, whether it be a slice, topspin, or flat. That said, slice gives you a little more time to react, since you can hit the ball further back in your stance.
 

Fintft

G.O.A.T.
Against a lefty, stand IN, take an aggressive cut at the ball, either topspin, sidespin, or slice, never back off, never lean back.
If you stand back, most lefty's swing you wider and wider.

Good advise, but what if said lefty can also hit a flat bomb down the T? One that's hard to read from the toss etc?

I've also:

- Started to take two steps (one step then the split one) on the return.
- Do what Djoker does and try to focus my eyes (I also make the returner wait at least 2-3 seconds after I got in position to return, in order to get my bearings)
- Focus on breathing while waiting for the serve.
 

jhick

Hall of Fame
Good advise, but what if said lefty can also hit a flat bomb down the T? One that's hard to read from the toss etc?

I've also:

- Started to take two steps (one step then the split one) on the return.
- Do what Djoker does and try to focus my eyes (I also make the returner wait at least 2-3 seconds after I got in position to return, in order to get my bearings)
- Focus on breathing while waiting for the serve.

In this case, I would still generally cheat a bit to the alley and make him serve the bomb down the T, since bombs down the T are a much lower percentage serve for a lefty. But like I said earlier, that makes it much tougher. OP didn't mention anything about opponents flat serve, only that he was having trouble with the slice out wide on the ad side.
 

LeeD

Bionic Poster
Slice stroke is quicker to swing forwards, since gravity is helping some.
Slice stroke meets the ball more square then a rising topspin stroke.
 
Slice stroke is quicker to swing forwards, since gravity is helping some.
Slice stroke meets the ball more square then a rising topspin stroke.

That's true. I once took a video where I hit multiple on-the-rise topspin rally strokes, and the video revealed that the racquet was at a VERY CLOSED angle when making contact with the ball! I didn't even know that I was closing the racquethead so much, it all happened unconsciously.

I'm still a bit confused on how it's possible to avoid floating the ball up when hitting a slice onto a rising ball, with a square racquethead. Should I close the racquethead also on the slice? :eek:
 

boramiNYC

Hall of Fame
OP, probably your bh cc is not very solid yet. Also, if you want to stay close to BL, learn to hit flat shot in a compact stroke, and if you don't mind stepping back you can use full stroke with lots of topspin.
 

LeeD

Bionic Poster
There are different slice strokes.
Some are almost vert face and flattish downward swingpath.
Other's are much more open faced and more downward swingpath.
Also, backswing length varies by need.
 

donquijote

G.O.A.T.
(I also make the returner wait at least 2-3 seconds after I got in position to return, in order to get my bearings)
This is not good sportmanship and will make less friends nor it will do any contribution to one's skills. A returner should be ready BEFORE the server.
 

Shroud

G.O.A.T.
OP you need a larger racket! :)

Slice is possible on a rising ball and Leed is right. You have to move in and not let the bounce get too high, though on a lefty kicker I find that some height is great in dubs. You can drive the ball down at their feet at or before the service line.
 

LeeD

Bionic Poster
Listen to Shroud.
He's one of the guys who can really return my wide serve really well, usually going for short sharp angle, making me run and fetch for him.
 

v-verb

Hall of Fame
I switch to my left hand and hit a forehand. Gotten quite a few winning returns that way.

If it's a rocket serve, a right-hand backhand slice
 

LeeD

Bionic Poster
If I see a returner using the switch hand, or using 2hbh, a few serves sliced into the body does wonders to cure that.
 

v-verb

Hall of Fame
If I see a returner using the switch hand, or using 2hbh, a few serves sliced into the body does wonders to cure that.

Good strategy! I wouldn't switch if it was coming into the body or coming in too fast
 

Fintft

G.O.A.T.
Good strategy! I wouldn't switch if it was coming into the body or coming in too fast

Myself, I wouldn't be able to move out of way: i.e. I got jammed last night by one or two flat serves into the body (no slices, luckily), although it was the first time in years when I've won more points from returns and serves (first strikes), rather then from my ground game....

I was also a bit beat, from having played 10 days in a row (switching from har tru to hard courts for lessons + some basketball), when 2-3 weeks ago I couldn't even jog. But returns have always been a strong point for me +I've working on the serve a bit (with those drills from feeltennis and lessons/practices).
 
Top