dr325i
G.O.A.T.
That is very true. For example, the ON RF shoes that everyone was talking about being wide, killed my pinky and I could not play more than 30 min in them. The Club version, on the other hand, felt like a boat on my foot, but still useable when tied tightly.They could work for you/others. The midfoot was nicely accommodating. Just that forefoot inflare got me.
I’ve given up trying to figure out what will work/not work based on others. For example the foot doc says he has a wide foot but then claims in almost every review that “actually even a 2E you can go true” for almost everything. When I tried YYs recently I found the supposedly wider Eclipsion to be too narrow on my midfoot, while the supposedly narrow Ad Accel (according to TW) to be actually fine, I think because it’s a more straight last and more gentle toe inflare.
All depends on the quirks of your own foot. I have a very high arch and a wide forefoot. GR9 is a bit tighter on my foot than I would like but good enough to play in in exchange for how good it performs (once I cut out the straps and once the shoe breaks in/molds to the foot more).
The RS shoes feel very roomy but very much playable when tightened a little bit. And I had absolutely no rubbing.