Firstly, the aim is here is not take anything away from Sampras, 1993-1998 is in my book definitely his era. Undoubtedly.
The point is that Djokovic had a comparable amount of dominance from 2011-2016, in some ways it was less dominant in terms of YE1 and gap back to closest rival in majors, but in terms of the amount of majors and big titles won and 3 surface achievement, it was far more dominant in terms of the gap back to his next rival. That’s what I demonstrated with the numbers.
And yes the reason for the comparison is that Sampras Serve and USO2010 constantly try to detract from the Djokovic dominance legacy with nonsense articles like how many majors would Djokovic wouldn’t have won if he had a SHB.
To give you an even more of a like for like comparison of the dominance back to their next rival during their respective periods:-
@Hitman @Neptune @Pheasant @The Federest
you guys might also find this interesting.
This is the points comparison for both eras using the ranking points ONLY gained in the biggest titles, Majors, Masters, ATP Finals with the gap back to their closest rival.
1993 —
Pete Sampras — ~7,300 points — Michael Stich — gap +300
1994 —
Pete Sampras — ~9,300 points — Andre Agassi — gap +2,800
1995 —
Pete Sampras — ~9,800 points — Andre Agassi — gap +1,300
1996 —
Pete Sampras — ~7,900 points — Michael Chang — gap +1,900
1997 —
Pete Sampras — ~8,200 points — Patrick Rafter — gap +2,600
1998 —
Pete Sampras — ~7,100 points — Marcelo Ríos — gap +300
2011 —
Novak Djokovic — ~13,300 points — Rafael Nadal — ~7,640 — gap +5,660
2012 —
Novak Djokovic — ~10,970 points — Roger Federer — ~10,165 — gap ~+805
2013 —
Rafael Nadal — ~10,630 points — Novak Djokovic — ~10,440 — gap -190
2014 —
Novak Djokovic — ~11,410 points — Roger Federer — ~7,300 — gap +4,110
2015 —
Novak Djokovic — ~14,900 points — Andy Murray — ~6,990 — gap +7,910
2016 —
Novak Djokovic — ~11,730 points — Andy Murray — ~11,550 — gap +180
Yearly Leads: 6-4 to Sampras
Overall Points: 68410 - 48200 to Djoko
Median Points Year: 11570 - 8050 to Djoko
It’s much more important to look at the median point here so years like 2015 don’t skew the data heavily unfairly towards Djokovic. And Novak is still well clear.
Summary
Sampras has a clear greater claim to a more dominant era based on leading the points each year which we already knew. Whilst Djokovic doesn’t in 13 and 16 the gap is very narrow from him to 1st.
And what’s very noticeable in 13 and 16 the Djokovic totals in competing for the biggest titles in those two years (10630 and 11730)
are still both higher than what Pete managed in ANY of his years from 1993-1998. And that was reflected in the much higher overall points tally and median tally for Djokovic each year.
Overall Gap from 93-98 and 11-16
Sampras +9200 gap over the field
Djokovic +18115 gap over the field
Median Gap from 93-98 and 11-16
Sampras +1600
Djokovic +2456
Again it’s more important to look at Median for reasons already explained.
So again, both the overall gap and the median gap demonstrate Djokovic extra dominance over his field during their respective periods.
And finally, then we can take into account the overall points gap to their nearest overall challenger in those 6 seasons:-
Sampras - Agassi +34000 points
Djokovic - Nadal +20000 points
Sampras leads here but both massively clear to their next rival. Djokovic is in effect 10GS points wise clear to Nadal.
So using only the biggest titles competed for, again the evidence points back to them
both being massively dominant overall both over the field and their nearest rival in their respected periods.
And in their respective 6 year periods, Djokovic was clearly dominant over Pete in terms of their individual performance over those 6 seasons.