Should Federer play Shanghai?

  • Thread starter Thread starter monfed
  • Start date Start date

Should Federer play Shanghai


  • Total voters
    33
  • Poll closed .
M

monfed

Guest
Let's suppose Djokovic wins the USO then I think the year end #1 is pretty much gone. But if he plays Shanghai then he can atleast get to 300 weeks at #1 isn't it? What do you make of it,should SMCRogi partake?
 
He will get to 300 irregardless (of when), don't have to do anything out of the ordinary. I mean he would not gladly exchange his Wimby for the number 1 ranking for sure.
 
I think so if he wants to end the year as world number 1 hoping that Novac doesn't win the US open

by doing so he'll be more motivated for next year
 
I think so if he wants to end the year as world number 1 hoping that Novac doesn't win the US open

by doing so he'll be more motivated for next year

It was already pointed out in another post that, even if Novak wins the USO, Fed will still be #1 by a small margin.
 
Nope. He won Paris last year so if he were to win Shanghai and skip Paris, he gains zero point.

But that's the point. He needs to win Shangai to skip Paris, so he won't lose any points. Otherwise mr. Federer will reach the Master's Cup very tired (performances like '09).
 
Depends on his plans. I think he feels guilty about not playing last year and wants to give his Chinese fans a treat so he will do. Personally I think if Djokovic wins the US Open then he should gracefully accept Djokovic as the best player this year and try and save his body as much as possible for next year.
 
Depends on his plans. I think he feels guilty about not playing last year and wants to give his Chinese fans a treat so he will do. Personally I think if Djokovic wins the US Open then he should gracefully accept Djokovic as the best player this year and try and save his body as much as possible for next year.

Why,what's he gonna do next year? He ain't winning AO, aint winning RG,has probably reached his quota of Wimbys, USO he's just flat out WEIRD.
Look Roger is done. Stick a fork in him. The man's FH has absolutely no sting in it.
 
Why,what's he gonna do next year? He ain't winning AO, aint winning RG,has probably reached his quota of Wimbys, USO he's just flat out WEIRD.
Look Roger is done. Stick a fork in him. The man's FH has absolutely no sting in it.

Federer with luck had a great shot at winning the US Open this year. I said several times there are a few players he needed to avoid: Berdych, Del Potro and Soderling(if he ever comes back). I think he had a very good chance against Murray and even Djokivic had he made it.

Next year will be harder, but there is still a shot at Wimbledon and an outside shot at the US Open. Those are his last shots at a slam for me, but he needs a lot of luck.

It's ironic that Federer has actually been very unlucky with draws in his time, but was so good it did not even matter. Now is the time where he needs fortunate draws.
 
Absolutely. He NEED to play and win shanghai, then he can withdraw from Paris.

Why? I thought Paris was his best tournament last year slightly ahead of WTF. That court just looked like it was made for him. The Berdych match there vs. at the Open is especially insightful. Berdych was playing just as well in Paris but he didn't stand a chance. I'm shocked Fed hadn't won that before. In my thinking, he should go for every indoor tournament available; it's the truest tennis possible and quite magical.
 
Why? I thought Paris was his best tournament last year slightly ahead of WTF. That court just looked like it was made for him. The Berdych match there vs. at the Open is especially insightful. Berdych was playing just as well in Paris but he didn't stand a chance. I'm shocked Fed hadn't won that before. In my thinking, he should go for every indoor tournament available; it's the truest tennis possible and quite magical.

Great post! I agree wholeheartedly; Federer's forte lies with indoor tournaments, so he should just concentate on those.
 
Why,what's he gonna do next year? He ain't winning AO, aint winning RG,has probably reached his quota of Wimbys, USO he's just flat out WEIRD.
Look Roger is done. Stick a fork in him. The man's FH has absolutely no sting in it.

It's sad to hear this from you.

Roger will win at least one slam more
 
If he cares at all about finishing the year as number 1, then yes. If he's not bothered about that, then no, take some time off.
 
If Fed wants Sampras to keep his record of 6 years ending #1, then he shouldn't play. At least let Sampras have this record.
 
Federer with luck had a great shot at winning the US Open this year. I said several times there are a few players he needed to avoid: Berdych, Del Potro and Soderling(if he ever comes back). I think he had a very good chance against Murray and even Djokivic had he made it.

Next year will be harder, but there is still a shot at Wimbledon and an outside shot at the US Open. Those are his last shots at a slam for me, but he needs a lot of luck.

It's ironic that Federer has actually been very unlucky with draws in his time, but was so good it did not even matter. Now is the time where he needs fortunate draws.

WTF? Soderling is Federer's little man-slave.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kPugnLvDgn4

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p_Excg8Ss3g

A bagel and straights at the USO from post-prime ******* to go along with their 16-1 head-to-head. Yeah, avoid at all costs.
 
Last edited:
Samp would still have them consecutively though.

True, but if you look further(if Fed does end the year #1), Fed won more slams in those 6 years, or 14 slams to Pete 11. He accumulate more weeks at number 1. He also won more titles, has higher atp points.

Anyway, I don't want to discuss this further because Fed/Nole is still in the race.
 
I think that three weeks of back-to-back tennis are too much for anyone. Fed should save himself of defending the points of paris and focus on the WTF.
 
Why,what's he gonna do next year? He ain't winning AO, aint winning RG,has probably reached his quota of Wimbys, USO he's just flat out WEIRD.
Look Roger is done. Stick a fork in him. The man's FH has absolutely no sting in it.

We should stick a fork on you, troll. :twisted:
 
Back
Top