westirvine
New User
I'm currently in the market for a ball machine as my 3rd grade daughter is picking up tennis quickly and I'd like to use it as cardio exercise. I was originally considering the Slingerbag, but the price increased several times the past few months and now at $800 I don't feel its worth it for a machine that only throws heavy topspin at a limited pace. I'd rather spend more and get a better machine if the Slingerbag isn't around 500-600.
For people that have tried or owned both, would you recommend the Spinfire Pro v2 or the Hydrogen Proton? And why?
From what I read, here are the biggest pros and cons of each:
Spinfire Pro v2
Pros:
Pros:
I'm not sure if this should be a deal breaker. For those that own Spinfire or any other ball machine, is throwing up lobs useful? Does it consistently throw the lobs in the same spot for young kids to practice? Do you regularly use it practice overheads?
One of the hardest things to learn is serving and overheads for kids. And its very hard for me to consistently feed a lob exactly at the right spot for her to hit. It would be nice if the machine could throw it in the same predictable spot everytime.
Concern #2: Spinfire heavy weight and size
I've owned a ball machine in the past but rarely ever used it because it was too heavy and cumbersome to set up. And although lifting 40 pounds is not a problem for me, my kids or wife wouldn't be able to set it up themselves. I'm not sure if Spinfire owners ever had that experience of not using the ball machine so often because its too cumbersome. Please let me know.
Thanks so much in advance,
For people that have tried or owned both, would you recommend the Spinfire Pro v2 or the Hydrogen Proton? And why?
From what I read, here are the biggest pros and cons of each:
Spinfire Pro v2
Pros:
- Proven brand and reliability
- Internal oscillator (No telegraphing of where the ball will go)
- 2 year warranty
- Ability to hit lobs (up to 60 degree angle)
- Larger bucket size (140+ ball capacity)
- Cost is expensive $2399 and charges for shipping and extra accessories
- Weight (weighs 40 pounds, although has wheels not fun carrying in and out of the car)
- Size (much larger than Proton will only fit in our minivan)
- Not programmable
Pros:
- Weight (weighs only 20 pounds so easily portable, we put everything in a wagon to the court anyways)
- Cost (not cheap $1695, but several hundred to a thousand cheaper than Spinfire v2)
- Size (fits easily in any car)
- Programmable drills
- Drift (machine drifts requiring recentering every so often)
- 1 year warranty only
- New brand, unknown reliability
- No lobs (only up to 26 degree angle)
- Smaller bucket size (80+ ball capacity)
I'm not sure if this should be a deal breaker. For those that own Spinfire or any other ball machine, is throwing up lobs useful? Does it consistently throw the lobs in the same spot for young kids to practice? Do you regularly use it practice overheads?
One of the hardest things to learn is serving and overheads for kids. And its very hard for me to consistently feed a lob exactly at the right spot for her to hit. It would be nice if the machine could throw it in the same predictable spot everytime.
Concern #2: Spinfire heavy weight and size
I've owned a ball machine in the past but rarely ever used it because it was too heavy and cumbersome to set up. And although lifting 40 pounds is not a problem for me, my kids or wife wouldn't be able to set it up themselves. I'm not sure if Spinfire owners ever had that experience of not using the ball machine so often because its too cumbersome. Please let me know.
Thanks so much in advance,
Last edited: