suggestions re youtek prestige mp vs. youtek rad mp

EKnee08

Professional
As a followup:
I am a 4.0-4.5 all courter. Years ago I was a 5.0 aggressive baseline. I switched to the youtek rad mp w/ babolat tonic 16 strung at 56 in mid september from the aerogel 300. I was playing fine with it and felt it had better touch/feel but had trouble against players at my level or above who hit a heavy ball. I particularly have had issues with the return of serve but was serving well with it.

As a result, I experimented with lead and settled on 3 grams of lead at 3 and 9 and another 3 under the top of the handle. However, I was not entirely happy with it. Resulting in total weight of 11.7 ounces.

Last night, I was the only guy at my drill and play lesson so I hit with the pro one on one. I was a little slow getting around on the ball and still got pushed around a bit. The pro was demoing the Youtek Prestige MP.
He let me hit with it and I was much more consistent on my groundies against him. My balls didn't land short and I was able to maintain sustained rallies although I had to work a bit harder to generate pace. It felt more natural.

My volleys were also very consistent, still had putaway power and I reacted faster at net. It also felt more natural.

On serves, I did not generate as much pop but again was more consistent.

Overheads were easier to get in position and were also more consistent but din't have the same oomph.

I asked him to give me some very soft balls because that is where I sometimes have trouble and I couldn't hit them out but had enough pace.

The pro's comments to me were that it was by far the most consistent and best I had ever hit. He felt that the stick was more suited to me than the RAD because I was extremely consistent and he felt the loss of power was negligible although I had to work hard to generate pace and keep up with him. Of course, I was using cheap demo synthetic string. The pro said that I should keep in mind that the difference in string is why the stick felt stiffer and the Prestige would have more pop and be much easier on my arm if I was using my Tonic.
He stated that although I am in my late 40s, I have a long swing and so the Prestige MP would still be better for me.

I should point out when I went back to hitting w/ the Rad during the same session, although I generated more pop, I felt less in control

After playing last night, my shoulder was sore as well as my forearm. My shoulder has been sore all day. Can this be attributed to a) I was hitting against a pro for an hour and a half and I am not used to this (It has been years) and/or the b)the demo string was stiff or is it the frame being too heavy and having to do the work?

What are your thoughts regarding making the switch?
 
i think it's very possible that the string in the demo racquet made your arm sore...especially if you're used to gut -- plus if you had some pretty intense points, and you were using a heavier than normal racquet, being sore is not that uncommon...i think with your normal string, plus getting used to heavier weight, you might be able to get used to it just fine...this is why i "buy" racquets when i demo -- it's probably not as cost effective, but i at least get to use my own strings, add weight when needed, etc...

but yeah, i was actually just hitting with both of those frames tonight...i thought the YT Radical had a tad too much power, and slightly less feel the YT Prestige MP -- although I probably need to hit a few more balls and add a little weight to the YT Prestige before i make any final conclusions...i also had a PT57A that i could not put down :) soo much feel with that stick!
 
strings/tension and bump in tennis activity can contribute to soreness. switching racquets that differ in specs can also contribute.
 
strings/tension and bump in tennis activity can contribute to soreness. switching racquets that differ in specs can also contribute.

However, but based on the foregoing, if you were I, would you consider switching to the prestige?
Please keep in mind that after adding lead tape to the rad , the rad mp was very close in weight to the prestige mp. Still not near as head light as the prestige, if anything the rad balance remained approx 2 pts hl as opposed to the prestige which is listed as 7 pts headlight.
 
i think it's very possible that the string in the demo racquet made your arm sore...especially if you're used to gut -- plus if you had some pretty intense points, and you were using a heavier than normal racquet, being sore is not that uncommon...i think with your normal string, plus getting used to heavier weight, you might be able to get used to it just fine...this is why i "buy" racquets when i demo -- it's probably not as cost effective, but i at least get to use my own strings, add weight when needed, etc...

but yeah, i was actually just hitting with both of those frames tonight...i thought the YT Radical had a tad too much power, and slightly less feel the YT Prestige MP -- although I probably need to hit a few more balls and add a little weight to the YT Prestige before i make any final conclusions...i also had a PT57A that i could not put down :) soo much feel with that stick!

I see many posters referring to the PT57A- which frame is this?
By the way, of the rad and prestige, which do you like better and which do you think sounds better for me? and would you listen to the pro?
 
However, but based on the foregoing, if you were I, would you consider switching to the prestige?
Please keep in mind that after adding lead tape to the rad , the rad mp was very close in weight to the prestige mp. Still not near as head light as the prestige, if anything the rad balance remained approx 2 pts hl as opposed to the prestige which is listed as 7 pts headlight.

if you were I - not easy to answer but do you have a hot wife or g/f? :) just kidding.

being an older (than you) player with similiar self ratings (HAHA) i would go for the YT Prestige MP. recently tried the MP and liked the results tho didn't serve with it. i tend to like the 7 pts HL vs 2. btw - my current stick is the MG Prestige Pro. so if i was in the market for a replacement, the YT Pres MP would be in my stringing machine.
 
if you were I - not easy to answer but do you have a hot wife or g/f? :) just kidding.

being an older (than you) player with similiar self ratings (HAHA) i would go for the YT Prestige MP. recently tried the MP and liked the results tho didn't serve with it. i tend to like the 7 pts HL vs 2. btw - my current stick is the MG Prestige Pro. so if i was in the market for a replacement, the YT Pres MP would be in my stringing machine.

Thanks, Bad Call...

I do have a hot wife.(better write that in case she is monitoring the posts, HA, HA :)

On serves, it seemed to not have generated as much pop.
 
^^ :)

a while ago, i modded an MG Rad MP for a player by putting lead inside the handle (remove buttcap, etc) and made it much more HL (around 8 pts or so). it made a huge difference for that player. if you already have the YT Rad MP then you could try the same. i think you will be pleasantly surprised.
 
I see many posters referring to the PT57A- which frame is this?
By the way, of the rad and prestige, which do you like better and which do you think sounds better for me? and would you listen to the pro?

PT57A = old pro tour 630...

hmm...i don't really know which would be better for you personally -- i haven't seen you hit...both are decent frames -- I think the YT Prestige has a bit more touch and a little bit less power...I think I'm leaning towards that frame, or even going back to my old babolat pure storm ltd gt :)
 
Back
Top