The gap between Djokovic and Murray prior to 2011...

clout

Hall of Fame
....was actually not that big. Djokovic was still the better player up until 2011 as he won a major and was almost always #3 while Murray was #4 (although I believe Murray actually got to #2 before Nole did as crazy as that sounds), but overall the difference between Djokurray wasn't miles and miles apart like it has been since '11.

Majors:
Djokovic: 1
Murray: 0
Major Finals:
Djokovic: 3
Murray: 2
Titles:
Djokovic: 18
Murray: 16
Masters:
Djokovic: 5
Murray: 6
WTF:
Djokovic: 1
Murray: 0
Olympics:
Djokovic: Bronze
Murray: Round 1 (pretty crazy how Murray ended up winning the next two golds while Nole has yet to better his Bronze in Beijing)
H2H:
Djokovic: 4
Murray: 3 (Murray led 2-0 in finals; never played at major)
Wins over top 10 players:
Djokovic: 39
Murray: 42
Career record:
Djokovic: 324-105 (75.5%)
Murray: 267-94 (74%)
Record vs Fedal:
Djokovic: 6-13 vs Federer (2-4 at majors); 7-16 vs Nadal (0-5 at majors) = 13-29 in total (30.9% - 2-9 at majors)
Murray: 8-6 vs Federer (0-2 at majors); 4-9 vs Nadal (2-3 at majors) = 12-15 in total (44.4% - 2-5 at majors)
 
Last edited:
....was actually not that big. Djokovic was clearly still the better player up until 2011 as he won a major and was almost always #3 while Murray was #4 (although I believe Murray actually got to #2 before Nole did as crazy as that sounds), but overall the difference between Djokurray wasn't miles and miles apart like it has been since '11.

Majors:
Djokovic: 1
Murray: 0
Major Finals:
Djokovic: 3
Murray: 2
Titles:
Djokovic: 18
Murray: 16
Masters:
Djokovic: 4
Murray: 5
WTF:
Djokovic: 1
Murray: 0
H2H:
Djokovic: 4
Murray: 3 (Murray led 2-0 in finals; never played at major)
Wins over top 10 players:
Djokovic: 39
Murray: 42
Career record:
Djokovic: 324-105 (75.5%)
Murray: 267-94 (74%)
Record vs Fedal:
Djokovic: 6-13 vs Federer (2-4 at majors); 7-16 vs Nadal (0-5 at majors) = 13-29 in total (30.9% - 2-9 at majors)
Murray: 8-6 vs Federer (0-2 at majors); 4-9 vs Nadal (2-3 at majors) - 12-15 in total (44.4% - 2-5 at majors)
Murray statistically was far superior to Djokovic for a good bit of 2008 and 2009 (when he got to #2). July 2008 to June 2009 Muzziah 9-4 versus Big 3.o_O
 
Plenty of people thought he’d have the greater career back in 09 and 10. No one saw 2011 coming.

Also, I think Murray was more varied in his tactics in those early years. Some matches he came out swinging like he was nothing but a power player, particularly when he played Nadal. Once he hooked up with Lendl, he stayed focused on a somewhat smaller set of tactics, it seems to me, which obviously won him a couple majors but wasn’t as fun to watch in my opinion.
 
Masters:
Djokovic: 4
Murray: 5
Actually, Djokovic had won 5 (2007: Miami, Montreal, 2008: IW, Rome, 2009: Paris) and Murray had won 6 (2008: Cincinnati, Madrid, 2009: Miami, Montreal, 2010: Montreal, Shanghai). But yeah, Murray had won one more than Djokovic

But you're right, in that Murray was considered by some to be a better prospect and by many to be a similar prospect. This is largely due to Djokovic stagnating in 2009 and especially 2010, after a strong 2007/8. I still think Djokovic has the clear edge, due to his slam and WTF win but I agree it was close.
 
Remember Murray going on a run of straight set wins against the Serb circa 2008-09. He said he began to notice patterns in Djokovic's play and it looked like he had his number. Until 2014 their rivalry was competitive. Wonder what happened.
 
Remember Murray going on a run of straight set wins against the Serb circa 2008-09. He said he began to notice patterns in Djokovic's play and it looked like he had his number. Until 2014 their rivalry was competitive. Wonder what happened.
Murray dipped after early 13. That was the early signs of his back/hip issues. It got worse in the 2nd half of 2013 to 2014. He came back in 2015 but he was not the same in slams as 2012-early 13.
Seemed to take a hit to his endurance and seemed to lose confidence after Lendl. Did not get it back again until 2016 or so.
Djokovic also got back to his 2011 level in late 2014-mid 2016 so that did not help as well.
 
Plenty of people thought he’d have the greater career back in 09 and 10. No one saw 2011 coming.

Also, I think Murray was more varied in his tactics in those early years. Some matches he came out swinging like he was nothing but a power player, particularly when he played Nadal. Once he hooked up with Lendl, he stayed focused on a somewhat smaller set of tactics, it seems to me, which obviously won him a couple majors but wasn’t as fun to watch in my opinion.
He used to destroy all 3 in BO3 matches. Had some epics in 2008-10 vs them.
 
Actually, Djokovic had won 5 (2007: Miami, Montreal, 2008: IW, Rome, 2009: Paris) and Murray had won 6 (2008: Cincinnati, Madrid, 2009: Miami, Montreal, 2010: Montreal, Shanghai). But yeah, Murray had won one more than Djokovic

But you're right, in that Murray was considered by some to be a better prospect and by many to be a similar prospect. This is largely due to Djokovic stagnating in 2009 and especially 2010, after a strong 2007/8. I still think Djokovic has the clear edge, due to his slam and WTF win but I agree it was close.
Oops my bad, thanks for the correction. But yeah pretty much, Novak was in very good form from like IW 2007-2009 Madrid, then after that he really stagnated for the next year and a half. It wasn’t until he ended Federer’s USO finals streak in epic fashion then pushed peak Rafa to 4 sets in the finals where people began to realize this dude may actually be the real deal after all. For much of 2009/10, Murray was in better form.
 
Remember Murray going on a run of straight set wins against the Serb circa 2008-09. He said he began to notice patterns in Djokovic's play and it looked like he had his number. Until 2014 their rivalry was competitive. Wonder what happened.

What happened was that Murray went on to take Djokovic's #1 ranking away from him. :cool:
 
What happened was that Murray went on to take Djokovic's #1 ranking away from him. :cool:
2016 may have been his best season statistically, but as a player, he was much better between 2008-2013. He was sadly never really the same player after that hip injury in late 2013/early 2014.
 
Murray briefly reached the #2 spot for the first time in August 2009. It was only for a couple of weeks but he beat Djokovic to that goal by 6 months. He finished the 2010 season with more Masters 1000 titles (6 > 5) too. By that stage Djokovic had made 3 Slam finals (winning his 2nd at 2008 AO) whilst Murray had made 2. Otherwise they were incredibly close.

Then at the beginning of 2011 Djokovic 2.0 made his appearance and the rest is history.
 
Last edited:
....was actually not that big. Djokovic was still the better player up until 2011 as he won a major and was almost always #3 while Murray was #4 (although I believe Murray actually got to #2 before Nole did as crazy as that sounds), but overall the difference between Djokurray wasn't miles and miles apart like it has been since '11.

Murray was actually ranked #2 for the first time briefly in August 2009. Djokovic did not first attain that ranking until February 2010.

Masters:
Djokovic: 4
Murray: 5

At the end of 2010 Murray actually held 6 Masters titles whilst Djokovic held 5.
 
2016 may have been his best season statistically, but as a player, he was much better between 2008-2013. He was sadly never really the same player after that hip injury in late 2013/early 2014.
Murray's peak was 2008/2009 or 2016. 2013 weakerer by the numbers. Hip/back started by 2009.;)
 
Djokovic was always the better player, but a lot of people back in the day were blind to this fact. Thought he was going to win 6-8 slams, and Murray 0 slams. Obviously I underestimated both.
 
Back
Top