The older beasts.....hypothetical scenario

[HetTheGreaterer]

Well, its a shame that top3 guys from 2007 are still top3 in 2019 and contesting for big titles...So let it be...and consider their best old versions to play against each other

After all, its a fedalovic thread again....
Let's consider their reincarnated or rejuvenated versions and put them to play against each other... Who wins??
Considering the best and most beastly versions of big3 2.0 or 3.0(in Fed's case)...

So it gives us :-

Federer Indian wells/Wimbledon 2017
Nadal Roland Garros/Monte Carlo 2017
Djokovic USO/Shanghai 2018

These imho are the best versions of older beasts

Who beats whom at the following given BO3 scenarios??


1) Indian Wells
2) Rome
3) Shanghai
4) Canada
5) Miami
6) Madrid

Who beats whom at following BO5 scenarios??

1) Australian Open
2) Roland Garros
3) Wimbledon
4) US Open...


Let's have a good time and discussion friends....
Hope all of us will put our fan bias aside and give as much honest opinion as we all can...
Happy makar sankranti / Uttarayan in advance to all kite lovers in the world

Honorable mentions of @Hitman @BeatlesFan @Sport @Ann @True Fanerer @Fedforever @Federer and Del Potro @Federev @King No1e @ak24alive @KINGROGER @Jackuar @TheMaestro1990
@Mainad

 

[HetTheGreaterer]

" If above all collides with each other,

I'll go with "

You may consider it for starting your post.
Thanks and Regards

 

[Lew II]

Most dominant male athletes of 2018, from ESPN:

1) Eliud Kipchoge 34
2) Daniel Cormier 39
3) Luka Modric 33
4) Novak Djokovic 31
5) Yuzuru Hanyue 24
6) Lewis Hamilton 34
7) Lebron James 34
8) Mookie Betts 26
9) Drew Brees 39
10) Alex Ovechkin 33

average age: 32.7

http://www.espn.com/espn/feature/st...-kim-lebron-james-most-dominant-athletes-2018

Obviously Federer, Djokovic and Nadal peaked at 22-23 and would destroy their more recent versions

 

[Druss]

Most dominant male athletes of 2018, from ESPN:

1) Eliud Kipchoge 34
2) Daniel Cormier 39
3) Luka Modric 33
4) Novak Djokovic 31
5) Yuzuru Hanyue 24
6) Lewis Hamilton 34
7) Lebron James 34
8) Mookie Betts 26
9) Drew Brees 39
10) Alex Ovechkin 33

average age: 32.7

http://www.espn.com/espn/feature/st...-kim-lebron-james-most-dominant-athletes-2018

Obviously Federer, Djokovic and Nadal peaked at 22-23 and would destroy their more recent versions

Some of those names I’ve never heard of. Would that be in chess, darts, billiards?

 

[Lew II]

Some of those names I’ve never heard of. Would that be in chess, darts, billiards?

They're actually the most popular sports.

Athletics, MMA, Football, Tennis, Figure Skating, Driving, Basketball, Baseball, American Football, Hockey.

 

[Druss]

They're actually the most popular sports.

Athletics, MMA, Football, Tennis, Figure Skating, Driving, Basketball, Baseball, American Football, Hockey.

GOATs in their respective discipline and age when at their absolute best:

- Miguel Induráin, 28
- Usain Bolt, 23
- Michael Phelps, 23
- Ashton Eaton, 27



-

 

[OldschoolKIaus]

Murray, would you kindly win AO19 to end all this Fedalkovic threads and save tennis?

 

[Deleted member 742196]

Most dominant male athletes of 2018, from ESPN:

1) Eliud Kipchoge 34
2) Daniel Cormier 39
3) Luka Modric 33
4) Novak Djokovic 31
5) Yuzuru Hanyue 24
6) Lewis Hamilton 34
7) Lebron James 34
8) Mookie Betts 26
9) Drew Brees 39
10) Alex Ovechkin 33

average age: 32.7

http://www.espn.com/espn/feature/st...-kim-lebron-james-most-dominant-athletes-2018

Obviously Federer, Djokovic and Nadal peaked at 22-23 and would destroy their more recent versions

@Sport - above post is tailor made for your further use.

 

[King No1e]

AO- Djokovic
IW- Nadal
Miami- Djokovic
MC- Nadal
Madrid- Nadal
Rome- Nadal
RG- Nadal
Wimbledon- Federer
Canada- Nadal
Cincy- Federer
USO- Djokovic
Shanghai- Djokovic
Paris- Federer
WTF- Federer

 

[Backspin1183]

Most dominant male athletes of 2018, from ESPN:

1) Eliud Kipchoge 34
2) Daniel Cormier 39
3) Luka Modric 33
4) Novak Djokovic 31
5) Yuzuru Hanyue 24
6) Lewis Hamilton 34
7) Lebron James 34
8) Mookie Betts 26
9) Drew Brees 39
10) Alex Ovechkin 33

average age: 32.7

http://www.espn.com/espn/feature/st...-kim-lebron-james-most-dominant-athletes-2018

Obviously Federer, Djokovic and Nadal peaked at 22-23 and would destroy their more recent versions

Have to disagree about Federer's peak. He played better in 2015 than he did at 22-23.

 

[Deleted member 742196]

Most dominant male athletes of 2018, from ESPN:

1) Eliud Kipchoge 34
2) Daniel Cormier 39
3) Luka Modric 33
4) Novak Djokovic 31
5) Yuzuru Hanyue 24
6) Lewis Hamilton 34
7) Lebron James 34
8) Mookie Betts 26
9) Drew Brees 39
10) Alex Ovechkin 33

average age: 32.7

http://www.espn.com/espn/feature/st...-kim-lebron-james-most-dominant-athletes-2018

Obviously Federer, Djokovic and Nadal peaked at 22-23 and would destroy their more recent versions

I’m an 80’s and 90’s person. In addition to above list of athletes that do pretty damn well in their thirties, there’s been loads of athletes in history that did well in their late careers:

Wayne Gretzky
Michael Jordan
Kobe Bryant
Tim Duncan
Jerry Rice
John Stockton
Geordie Howe
Randy Couture
George Forman
Martina Navratilova

All the above are legends of the game, team and single sports, including Martina from our tennis universe. It may have been a trend for tennis players to retire early, one that perhaps changes in coming decades.

 

[True Fanerer]

Fedal:

AO: Fed
FO: Nadal
W: Fed
UO: Fed
IW: Fed
Rome: Nadal
Shangai: Fed
Canada: Fed
Miami: Fed
Madrid: Nadal

Not giving Nadal anything on HC. Why would I?

Fedovic:

AO: Fed
FO: Djokovic
W: Fed
UO: Djokovic
IW: Federer
Rome: Djokovic
Shanghai: Federer
Canada: Federer
Miami: Djokovic
Madrid: Djokovic

Djokodal:

AO: Djokovic
FO: Nadal
W: Djokovic
UO: Djokovic
IW: Djokovic
Rome: Nadal
Shanghai: Djokovic
Canada: Djokovic
Miami: Djokovic
Madrid: Nadal

 

[HetTheGreaterer]

Most dominant male athletes of 2018, from ESPN:

1) Eliud Kipchoge 34
2) Daniel Cormier 39
3) Luka Modric 33
4) Novak Djokovic 31
5) Yuzuru Hanyue 24
6) Lewis Hamilton 34
7) Lebron James 34
8) Mookie Betts 26
9) Drew Brees 39
10) Alex Ovechkin 33

average age: 32.7

http://www.espn.com/espn/feature/st...-kim-lebron-james-most-dominant-athletes-2018

Obviously Federer, Djokovic and Nadal peaked at 22-23 and would destroy their more recent versions

Irrelevant answer to my question...
And yes... 2004 /05 fed, 2008/09 nadal would give breadsticks and bagels to their older versions...
Not sure about djok as he was a late bloomer

 

[BeatlesFan]

These imho are the best versions of older beasts

The only problem is that Djokovic is not anywhere near as old of a beast as Federer is. Even when you look at Roger’s old peak as you refer to it (Indian wells 2017), he was 35.5 years old. That’s four years older than Djoker is now. I refused to compare 31-year-old player to a 37-year-old player in anything.

Sure, Djokovic is old for a tennis player and Nadal at 32 is even older. But Federer is geriatric and ions older in athletic teens. He’s also a different generation entirely from them both.

 

[BGod]

Fed at Wimbledon. Novak at AO & USO.

But Federer is still 5 & 6 years older than them. 2015 Federer wins on AO-WMB-USO.

 

[Ann]

Irrelevant answer to my question...
And yes... 2004 /05 fed, 2008/09 nadal would give breadsticks and bagels to their older versions...
Not sure about djok as he was a late bloomer

You mean he's once had a relevant answer to a question?

 

[HetTheGreaterer]

You mean he's once had a relevant answer to a question?

Never ever...
He's the most lieing poster under the mask of analyst

 

[HetTheGreaterer]

The only problem is that Djokovic is not anywhere near as old of a beast as Federer is. Even when you look at Roger’s old peak as you refer to it (Indian wells 2017), he was 35.5 years old. That’s four years older than Djoker is now. I refused to compare 31-year-old player to a 37-year-old player in anything.

Sure, Djokovic is old for a tennis player and Nadal at 32 is even older. But Federer is geriatric and ions older in athletic teens. He’s also a different generation entirely from them both.

But what else versions can we compare???
I mean 31 year old (2012) fed would win almost in all scenarios except for RG...
So I had to take fed 3.0 beast

 

[Ann]

But what else versions can we compare???
I mean 31 year old (2012) fed would win almost in all scenarios except for RG...
So I had to take fed 3.0 beast

And that's the rub isn't it. All of these GOAT and or comparison threads refuse to acknowledge that prime ******* did and would consistently hand any player (of that same age) their arse tied up with a pretty pink bow, something all the stat faker fiends consistently ignore. Roger is GOAT.