The saddest (insert your favorite player) loss and why...

Charlemagne

Hall of Fame
I love the emotions that being a tennis fan brings! It can be exciting and downright disappointing following your favorite player. Which brings me to my question: which loss from your favorite player stung you the most, and why?

For me, Federer's loss to Djokovic in the 2014 Wimbledon final stung the most- because I feel that he may have missed his last chance for a major...

All in good commiserating fun, share! ;)
 
Wimbledon 2008 - Fed should have won the 2nd set, got broken twice from 4-1 up to lose 4-6. Insane for Fed to lose 5 games in a row on grass, even against Nadal. Then had a break point in the 5th set at 4-3 which could have easily allowed him to complete the most incredible comeback in a Wimbledon final ever. But he didn't take that one point and then lost when playing in the dark (yes, it was dark, I live in London). Watching a guy with long hair dressed in three-quarter length trousers and a cut off sleeve top lift the Wimbledon trophy was emetic.

Closely followed by Tim Henman's loss to Ivanisevic on 2001. So many rain delays caused him to lose to a serve bot.
 
Australian open 2012 Nadal losing the final
Miami 2013 Ferrer losing the final (had a championship point, would have been the champion if not for that ball that touched the line for 1cm)
US open 2014 Monfils losing in the QF despite 2 match points
Benneteau losing at Wimbledon to Federer despite leading 2 sets to love
 
Agassi '05 US Open Final. He was supposed to go out like Sampras in style at NY. Didn't happen, despite his form being ridiculous up until he ran into the brick wall that was Federer.
 
Federer - Australian Open 2009, terrible 5th set by Fed, 3rd Grand Slam final in 4 Grand Slams lost (All to Nadal).
Simon - Madrid 08 final, epic match with Rafa, close match with Murray.
Del Potro - 2013 Wimbledon against Djokovic. Loses epic 5 setter. Closely followed by Shanghai final against Djokovic.
 
In hindsight it were W2008, AO2009 and W2014. Also, RG 2011 was annoying because he was 5-2 up in the first and lost that set 7-5. If he won that set 6-2 or 6-3 it would've been a great start. And he was playing pretty well that year and Nadal was low on confidence because of his losses to Djokovic.

The one that hurt me the most (together with W2013) was USO2011. In retrospect, it wasn't that bad. But I was sad for days after that match.. still feel a bit sad when thinking back about the MP moment when the match turned around.
 
1984 French Open Final. I was an eleven year old Mac fanboy and dad was all Ivan. And being a cocky kid, I was sure Mac had it. That was truly painful.

1989 French Open Final. Edberg against a 17 year old Chang. Would have given SE the career slam. 5 setter. Really wanted that one.

Half the matches Agassi played lol

2008 Wimby. Nuf said.
 
1996 French Open Round of 16 - Thomas Muster vs. Michael Stich

Thomas Muster went into this match with a 34-1 record on clay in 1996, and a 99-3 record on clay since the start of 1995. The 1996 French Open had already seen attacking players thrive a lot more than before at the French Open, with the hot weather having baked out the clay and made it harder. The usual clay-court players had not done as well at the tournament.

Michael Stich had had a really poor 1996 up to this point. He hadn't played many matches, had a horrible ankle injury and surgery in March. He even talked about not playing at the 1996 French Open, because he said that he didn't want to embarrass himself on clay anymore. Thomas Muster had an ankle injury of his own, just days before the 1996 French Open was due to start, while he practicing in Austria with Javier Sanchez. This had forced Muster to pull out of his scheduled quarter final match against Andrea Gaudenzi at the Sankt Pölten tournament.

The Muster vs. Stich match was surprisingly played on Suzanne Lenglen court rather than Philippe Chatrier court, with the latter court showing the Karbacher vs. Ivanisevic match, on a day when Ivanisevic completely imploded mentally and put in an awful performance, to the boos of the crowd.

In the early stages of the Muster vs. Stich match, both players were trying to settle in, while Stich mixed things up. Muster seemed to have too much for Stich, and won the first set, 6-4. Muster also went up a break in the second set at 3-2, and seemed to have all the momentum. Then, in the middle of the next game, Muster played 3 bad points in a row and got broken. The latter part of the second set then became very scrappy, but it was Stich who eventually broke through to win the second set, 6-4.

Stich now had the momentum early in the third set, with his serve on fire in the sunny weather, and he raced into a 3-0 lead. Muster held in the next game, and had break points in the game after that to get back on serve. Unfortunately for Muster, he failed to take his break chances, and Stich held on, going on to win the third set, 6-1, and take a 2-1 lead in sets.

Now Muster was in real trouble and had to deliver. Muster had leads of 3-0, 4-1 and 5-2 in the fourth set, and a fifth set looked a certainty. Instead, Stich got it back to 5-5, and 6-6. Muster then played an awful tiebreak, and Stich won it 7-1.

Two things stood out about the match, Stich's serve was a big weapon under the conditions (23 aces to Muster's 0 - almost 6 games worth of aces), and Muster seemed strangely flat throughout most of the match.
 
1984 French Open Final. I was an eleven year old Mac fanboy and dad was all Ivan. And being a cocky kid, I was sure Mac had it. That was truly painful.

1989 French Open Final. Edberg against a 17 year old Chang. Would have given SE the career slam. 5 setter. Really wanted that one.

Half the matches Agassi played lol

2008 Wimby. Nuf said.
God that brings up awful memories
 
The 1998 Wimbledon final was another sickener. Goran Ivanisevic had played so well for 2 sets, and had set points for a 2 set lead. Goran played even better in an awesome fourth set, but ran out of steam in the fifth set and lost in 5 sets to Pete Sampras.

It was Sampras' 5th Wimbledon title, and Ivanisevic was a Wimbledon runner-up for the 3rd time without winning the title. Even Goran seemed to get more and more depressed about this loss, like he had lost hope of ever achieving his dream. That didn't change until he arrived at Wimbledon in 2001. At 2000 Wimbledon, Goran had taken part in the Champions Parade, and he was the only player who hadn't actually won a Wimbledon title of any kind at the time. That might have been a motivation to change all that.
 
Obviously Novak's 2013 RG semi final loss, as he got so close and just after his childhood coach had just passed away.
Last year's RG loss wasn't far off , and the 2013 USO also stung as it rubbed salt into the wound for 2013.
Lendl's 1987 Wimbledon loss was bittersweet as it was his last shot at a final, but Pat Cash winning it was some consolation and great for this nation.
Similarly Pat Rafter's Wimbledon loss to Goran was a tough one, but certainly could not begrudge Goran winning it after all his heartbreak.
 
Wimbledon 2008 - Fed should have won the 2nd set, got broken twice from 4-1 up to lose 4-6. Insane for Fed to lose 5 games in a row on grass, even against Nadal. Then had a break point in the 5th set at 4-3 which could have easily allowed him to complete the most incredible comeback in a Wimbledon final ever. But he didn't take that one point and then lost when playing in the dark (yes, it was dark, I live in London). Watching a guy with long hair dressed in three-quarter length trousers and a cut off sleeve top lift the Wimbledon trophy was emetic.

Closely followed by Tim Henman's loss to Ivanisevic on 2001. So many rain delays caused him to lose to a serve bot.

I'm right there with you, man. That hurt like bejeezus. It seemed like the universe forgot the script that one fateful evening.

"As flies to wanton boys are we to th' gods.
They kill us for their sport."
 
Rome 2006 Final, Federer. He was a break up in the fifth set, squandered two match points with very ugly unforced errors with his forehand, then again up in the tiebreak...after five hours.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Wimbledon 2008 - Fed should have won the 2nd set, got broken twice from 4-1 up to lose 4-6. Insane for Fed to lose 5 games in a row on grass, even against Nadal. Then had a break point in the 5th set at 4-3 which could have easily allowed him to complete the most incredible comeback in a Wimbledon final ever. But he didn't take that one point and then lost when playing in the dark (yes, it was dark, I live in London). Watching a guy with long hair dressed in three-quarter length trousers and a cut off sleeve top lift the Wimbledon trophy was emetic.

Closely followed by Tim Henman's loss to Ivanisevic on 2001. So many rain delays caused him to lose to a serve bot.

yes but federer lost first two sets in light in 2008 wimbledon final

so darkness is not an excuse

no tie break in 5th set hurt federer
 
Last edited:
2013 USO Hewitt vs Youzhny - Hewitt was up a break in the last two sets and ****ed it away.
2005 AO Hewitt vs Safin - Hewitt's only shot to win it at home.
2012 USO Djokovic vs Murray - Djokovic managed to get it to 2-2 before losing the 5th meekly.
2013 FO Djokovic vs Nadal - So close...
2009 FO Federer vs Haas - Tommy had a real chance here and was centremetres away from victory.
2014 AO Djokovic vs Wawrinka - Up a break in the fifth and gave it right back. Awful match point volley.
 
2009 French Open semifinal. Del Potro vs Federer. Because Del Potro was playing so well that tournament and it was a big chance to be the champion there. He was playing great that match, some of the best tennis he has played and he was dominating Federer. Probably he was nervous in the fourth set, then in the fifth, in a moment it seemed like he could win, he was playing great again, but then again in a key moment he made a a double fault. At least Roger won Roland Garros and I´m happy for him, but it would have been a great chance to Juan Martín, which later in that year, won the US Open.

Acasuso was also close to beat Federer in that tournament.

Also Delpo losing to Federer in the Olympics.
 
yes but federer lost first two sets in light in 2008 wimbledon final


No. No "yes but". That is irrelevant. Tennis is not supposed to be played in the dark. If it were an earlier round match they would have ended it 20 minutes earlier and come back in the morning but the organisers were desperate to avoid that for obvious reasons.
 
The saddest loss wasn't from my favorite player.

The saddest loss for me was Roddick's loss to Federer at Wimbledon in 2009…

The saddest Federer loss in the moment for me was his loss to Stakhovsky at Wimbledon in 2013, because I genuinely thought that this would be it with Roger's career (luckily I was wrong).

In hindsight the saddest loss for me was his 2009 AO loss to Nadal, because I genuinely believe that Federer would have beat Del Po at the USO if he had had the opportunity to get the Grand Slam (also that last set collapse was tough to watch)…
 
Last edited:
I have to say that Wimbledon 2009 made me feel really bad.

Here I was, for several years looking forward to Federer breaking the record, wondering how I would feel at that historic moment. I expected to be very happy, having followed him on his journey from day one. But, the only thing I felt was sadness for Roddick. If he hadn't made it so darn close, I probably wouldn't have felt that way, but for me, that should have been his moment, but it was not meant to be. Didn't stop me from feeling awful for the days following that match.
 
Nadal losing to Djokovic in AO12.
Djokovic losing to Nadal in FO13.
Del Potro losing to Federer in the Olympics.
 
AO 2004 final. Although proud of Safin's efforts, I couldn't help but think he was unlucky to have no tennis prior to AO and a difficult draw. Wimbledon 2009 final was pretty crappy, but the only reason Roddick was in his last chance Wimbledon saloon was due to him refusing to play high risk tennis from 05,06,07 and 08. Oh well.
 
Edberg FO final 1989. He was supposed to win it and it would've given him the career grand slam as the first player ever. He also is the only won who won all of the junior slams.

1989-rg-chang-edberg-38.jpg
 
Last edited:
Rafa's loss to Kyrgios at Wimbledon though it came in the 4th round.

It was so painful to watch a junior exposing such a champ and hitting so many trick shots. Would have been better if Rafa had lost in the previous round . Great champions should not suffer such defeats
 
2009 was such an ambivalent year for me being my two favorite players are Fed and Roddick.

Of course, I loved Fed being in all four finals, three of them being spectacular five-set epics and the other being the historical footnote where he won the French. The last year when all four finals were something special, I think.

On the one hand, I can lament. Roger really should have won the AO against Nadal and the UO against Del Potro, but they were damn good matches either way. On the other hand, he really should have lost Wimbledon to Roddick that time and managed to pull out his most surprising win.

In all, how can I complain about that year?
 
I have to say that Wimbledon 2009 made me feel really bad.

Here I was, for several years looking forward to Federer breaking the record, wondering how I would feel at that historic moment. I expected to be very happy, having followed him on his journey from day one. But, the only thing I felt was sadness for Roddick. If he hadn't made it so darn close, I probably wouldn't have felt that way, but for me, that should have been his moment, but it was not meant to be. Didn't stop me from feeling awful for the days following that match.

Yup yup yup...

Excuse me while I go fetch a handkerchief
 
Worst losses from the "Big 4"

Federer: Australian '09. Worse than Wimbledon '08 by a mile.

Nadal: Australian '12. The missed 2 foot putt backhand to go up 40-15 and then likely 5-2.

Djokovic: RG '13 semi. The missed overhead (and after being way ahead in the point!) to go up AD and likely 5-3. A win there wouldn't have guaranteed the tournament, but it would have been at least 99 percent (no disrespect to Ferrer.)

Murray: Wimbledon '12. Retroactively not so bad because he ended up finally winning it, but many felt he might never win it after that. So frustrating, especially after winning the 1st set.
 
I'd actually say AO 05 was Federer's worst loss tbh. He had MP on his serve in the 4th set TB in that one. Both losses to Nadal never came to that although both were finals and not semis.

However, if Federer had defeated Safin, I would've bet my house at the time that he would've defeated Hewitt.
 
A big Wilander fan here. Still wish he could have won the '83 French and the '87 WTF (as it's known today).

Not a fan but losses that upset me:

Coria at the '04 French Open final. (Just brutal)
Roddick at the '09 Wimbledon. (There is no justice in this world)
Seles at the '95 US Open. (If only that serve had been in...)
 
Stich losing RG final against Kafelnikov
Rafter losing Wimbledon final against Sampras and/or Ivanisevic
Roger losing Aus Open final against Nadal, chasing Sampras Slam record
 
Australian Open final 1990. That was Edberg's for the taking but for the injury. Ceteris paribus, he'd have ended up even in the Slam count with all of Lendl, McEnroe, and Wilander had he won. And, most importantly, ahead of Becker.
 
Roddick Wim 2009, would of been such a good moment if Arod had managed to win that match.

AO 09 and Wim 08, the AO loss was the saddest because of the way it happened and the direct aftermath - but Wimbledon 2008 was more significant being Wimbledon.
 
I miss roddick so much more now he's retired. When he was on tour I could appreciate him, but now I realize just how awesome he was.

I often go back and watch the summer of 2003 from Queens onwards. What a great run that was, and so much promise. We had Ferrero on the clay, Federer on grass, Roddick on hard, plus Nalbandian, Coria, Agassi was still in the mix...the future seemed to be safe, after Sampras had moved on.
 
I often go back and watch the summer of 2003 from Queens onwards. What a great run that was, and so much promise. We had Ferrero on the clay, Federer on grass, Roddick on hard, plus Nalbandian, Coria, Agassi was still in the mix...the future seemed to be safe, after Sampras had moved on.

Yep also at the end of 2004, there was talk of a big 4 with Federer, Roddick, Hewitt and Safin. Then one by one they dropped off with injuries.

I love the matches from that era but how much more could we have had if some of those guys stayed fit. Clay wars with Ferrero, Coria, Nadal and Federer. Ferrero, Safin, Federer, Hewitt and Roddick on hard courts....On grass Hewitt, Federer, Nadal and Roddick etc...
 
Yep also at the end of 2004, there was talk of a big 4 with Federer, Roddick, Hewitt and Safin. Then one by one they dropped off with injuries.

I love the matches from that era but how much more could we have had if some of those guys stayed fit. Clay wars with Ferrero, Coria, Nadal and Federer. Ferrero, Safin, Federer, Hewitt and Roddick on hard courts....On grass Hewitt, Federer, Nadal and Roddick etc...

The occasional bursts of Nalbandian breaking through and destroying everybody, before just floating outside the Top 8/10

If Kuerten had stayed healthy as well, Nadal would have had a lot of competition in 05/06/07
 
Back
Top