Time travel matchups?

How many times does the lesser player win

  • Total voters
    6
RS

RS

Bionic Poster
15 matches and put the winner in bolded and if you want number of sets.

1. Hewitt Wim 02 final vs Murray Wim 12 final
2. Roddick Wim 04 final vs Federer Wim 19 final
3. Gonzo AO 07 final vs Nadal AO 12 final
4. Safin AO 05 SF vs Djokovic AO 13 SF
5. Agassi USO 04 vs Djokovic USO 15
6. Del Potro Wim 13 vs Djokovic Wim 19
7. Roddick Wim 03 SF vs Djokovic Wim 11 final
8. Nadal USO 10 final vs Cllic USO 14 final
9. Scud Wim 03 final vs Murray Wim 16 final
10. Soderling RG 09 final vs Murray RG 16 final
11. Agassi USO 05 final vs Nadal USO 11 final
12. Roddick Wim 09 final vs Djokovic Wim 14 final
13. Nadal Wim 08 final vs Murray Wim 13 final
14. Baggy AO 06 final vs Murray AO 15 final
15. Del Potro RG 09 vs Djokovic RG 11
16. Sampras USO 02 final vs Murray USO 12 final
 
Last edited:
1. Hewitt in 5
2. Roddick in 3
3. Gonzalez in 5
4. Safin in 5
5. Agassi in 4
6. Delpo in 4
7. Roddick in 4
8. Nadal in 4
9. Scud in 5
10. Soderling in 3
11. Agassi in 5
12. Roddick in 4
13. Nadal in 4
14. Baggy in 5
15. Delpo in 4
16. Sampras in 3
 
Turing said:
1. Hewitt in 5
2. Roddick in 3
3. Gonzalez in 5
4. Safin in 5
5. Agassi in 4
6. Delpo in 4
7. Roddick in 4
8. Nadal in 4
9. Scud in 5
10. Soderling in 3
11. Agassi in 5
12. Roddick in 4
13. Nadal in 4
14. Baggy in 5
15. Delpo in 4
16. Sampras in 3
Click to expand...
Thanks vote in the poll.
 
Turing said:
1. Hewitt in 5
2. Roddick in 3
3. Gonzalez in 5
4. Safin in 5
5. Agassi in 4
6. Delpo in 4
7. Roddick in 4
8. Nadal in 4
9. Scud in 5
10. Soderling in 3
11. Agassi in 5
12. Roddick in 4
13. Nadal in 4
14. Baggy in 5
15. Delpo in 4
16. Sampras in 3
Click to expand...
:-D
 
Safin AO 05 SF vs Djokovic AO 13 SF

Djokovic beats Safin in 5 sets and ends the myth for good.
 
RS said:
Agassi USO 04 vs Djokovic USO 15
Click to expand...
Why do you compared old Andre to the best version of Djokovic there ever was? Why not take 1995 Agassi against 2015 Djokovic? That's a fair match up and Agassi would take that in four sets.
 
BeatlesFan said:
Why do you compared old Andre to the best version of Djokovic there ever was? Why not take 1995 Agassi against 2015 Djokovic? That's a fair match up and Agassi would take that in four sets.
Click to expand...
Many people say USO 2015 Djokovic was beatable. Agassi of USO 04 was rated highly on other threads even by Djokovic fans.
 
RS said:
Agassi of USO 04 was rated highly on other threads even by Djokovic fans.
Click to expand...
As if any Djokovic fan on here (besides one) ever saw Andre play? Don't quote them for anything that happened prior to 3-4 years ago, come on. Their collective ignorance of past greats is staggering.
 
2. Roddick Wim 04 final vs Federer Wim 19 final
3. Gonzo AO 07 final vs Nadal AO 12 final
4. Safin AO 05 SF vs Djokovic AO 13 SF
5. Agassi USO 04 vs Djokovic USO 15
6. Del Potro Wim 13 vs Djokovic Wim 19
7. Roddick Wim 03 SF vs Djokovic Wim 11 final
9. Scud Wim 03 final vs Murray Wim 16 final
11. Agassi USO 05 final vs Nadal USO 11 final
12. Roddick Wim 09 final vs Djokovic Wim 14 final
13. Nadal Wim 08 final vs Murray Wim 13 final
14. Baggy AO 06 final vs Murray AO 15 final
15. Del Potro RG 09 vs Djokovic RG 11

1. Hewitt Wim 02 final vs Murray Wim 12 final
8. Nadal USO 10 final vs Cllic USO 14 final
10. Soderling RG 09 final vs Murray RG 16 final
16. Sampras USO 02 final vs Murray USO 12 final

The last 4 are too close to call for me.
 
1. Hewitt Wim 02 final vs Murray Wim 12 final - 50-50
2. Roddick Wim 04 final vs Federer Wim 19 final -
4. Safin AO 05 SF vs Djokovic AO 13 SF - (very close)
5. Agassi USO 04 vs Djokovic USO 15 - (very close)
6. Del Potro Wim 13 vs Djokovic Wim 19 (very close)
7. Roddick Wim 03 SF vs Djokovic Wim 11 final
8. Nadal USO 10 final vs Cllic USO 14 final
9. Scud Wim 03 final vs Murray Wim 16 final
10. Soderling RG 09 final vs Murray RG 16 final (close)
11. Agassi USO 05 final vs Nadal USO 11 final (close)
12. Roddick Wim 09 final vs Djokovic Wim 14 final - 50-50
13. Nadal Wim 08 final vs Murray Wim 13 final
14. Baggy AO 06 final vs Murray AO 15 final ( close)
15. Del Potro RG 09 vs Djokovic RG 11 ( close)
16. Sampras USO 02 final vs Murray USO 12 final

Something like this.
 
1. Hewitt Wim 02 final vs Murray Wim 12 final
2. Roddick Wim 04 final vs Federer Wim 19 final
3. Gonzo AO 07 final vs Nadal AO 12 final
4. Safin AO 05 SF vs Djokovic AO 13 SF
5. Agassi USO 04 vs Djokovic USO 15
6. Del Potro Wim 13 vs Djokovic Wim 19
7. Roddick Wim 03 SF vs Djokovic Wim 11 final
8. Nadal USO 10 final vs Cllic USO 14 final
9. Scud Wim 03 final vs Murray Wim 16 final
10. Soderling RG 09 final vs Murray RG 16 final
11. Agassi USO 05 final vs Nadal USO 11 final
12. Roddick Wim 09 final vs Djokovic Wim 14 final
13. Nadal Wim 08 final vs Murray Wim 13 final
14. Baggy AO 06 final vs Murray AO 15 final
15. Del Potro RG 09 vs Djokovic RG 11
16. Sampras USO 02 final vs Murray USO 12 final
 
  • Like
Reactions: RS
Lot of really neat match-ups here. Nice job finding hypotheticals that haven't been talked about to death.

I'll play:

1. Hewitt Wim 02 final vs Murray Wim 12 final (no idea, never actually seen the 02 final, though Murray was damn good in 2012)
2. Roddick Wim 04 final vs Federer Wim 19 final (I could see a Roddick win here, but Fed wouldn't have the same mental woes as against Novak and has such an insane match-up advantage against Andy)
3. Gonzo AO 07 final vs Nadal AO 12 final (Nadal would probably have to do a lot of running, but ultimately it wouldn't be all that close)
4. Safin AO 05 SF vs Djokovic AO 13 SF (probably Novak, but Safin would make things interesting)
5. Agassi USO 04 vs Djokovic USO 15 (probably Novak, but Agassi has a real chance of pulling off the upset)
6. Del Potro Wim 13 vs Djokovic Wim 19 (provided he holds up mentally, unlike Roger, he has the level to put the out-of-form Serbian to bed)
7. Roddick Wim 03 SF vs Djokovic Wim 11 final (fun one, and probably close, but Djokovic is just more well-rounded)
8. Nadal USO 10 final vs Cllic USO 14 final (one-way traffic)
9. Scud Wim 03 final vs Murray Wim 16 final (this is basically the actual Wimbledon 2016 final)
10. Soderling RG 09 final vs Murray RG 16 final (too close to call; I think both would perform better if they didn't have Fed and Novak respectively standing in their way; could be an epic)
11. Agassi USO 05 final vs Nadal USO 11 final (Agassi would run Nadal ragged for a couple sets, but I think the Spaniard would ultimately outlast him)
12. Roddick Wim 09 final vs Djokovic Wim 14 final (Novak the favorite, for sure, but that serve... I don't know)
13. Nadal Wim 08 final vs Murray Wim 13 final (not that close)
14. Baggy AO 06 final vs Murray AO 15 final (first couple sets would probably be fun, but in the end not that close)
15. Del Potro RG 09 vs Djokovic RG 11 (probably Novak, but damn was Delpo good here; wish we could've seen this match-up)
16. Sampras USO 02 final vs Murray USO 12 final (probably Sampras, though it's possible Murray wears the old man down)
 
giphy.gif
 
  • Like
Reactions: RS
Poisoned Slice said:
1. Hewitt Wim 02 final vs Murray Wim 12 final
2. Roddick Wim 04 final vs Federer Wim 19 final
3. Gonzo AO 07 final vs Nadal AO 12 final
4. Safin AO 05 SF vs Djokovic AO 13 SF
5. Agassi USO 04 vs Djokovic USO 15
6. Del Potro Wim 13 vs Djokovic Wim 19
7. Roddick Wim 03 SF vs Djokovic Wim 11 final
8. Nadal USO 10 final vs Cllic USO 14 final
9. Scud Wim 03 final vs Murray Wim 16 final
10. Soderling RG 09 final vs Murray RG 16 final
11. Agassi USO 05 final vs Nadal USO 11 final
12. Roddick Wim 09 final vs Djokovic Wim 14 final
13. Nadal Wim 08 final vs Murray Wim 13 final
14. Baggy AO 06 final vs Murray AO 15 final
15. Del Potro RG 09 vs Djokovic RG 11
16. Sampras USO 02 final vs Murray USO 12 final
Click to expand...
Solid.
 
tudwell said:
Lot of really neat match-ups here. Nice job finding hypotheticals that haven't been talked about to death.

I'll play:

1. Hewitt Wim 02 final vs Murray Wim 12 final (no idea, never actually seen the 02 final, though Murray was damn good in 2012)
2. Roddick Wim 04 final vs Federer Wim 19 final (I could see a Roddick win here, but Fed wouldn't have the same mental woes as against Novak and has such an insane match-up advantage against Andy)
3. Gonzo AO 07 final vs Nadal AO 12 final (Nadal would probably have to do a lot of running, but ultimately it wouldn't be all that close)
4. Safin AO 05 SF vs Djokovic AO 13 SF (probably Novak, but Safin would make things interesting)
5. Agassi USO 04 vs Djokovic USO 15 (probably Novak, but Agassi has a real chance of pulling off the upset)
6. Del Potro Wim 13 vs Djokovic Wim 19 (provided he holds up mentally, unlike Roger, he has the level to put the out-of-form Serbian to bed)
7. Roddick Wim 03 SF vs Djokovic Wim 11 final (fun one, and probably close, but Djokovic is just more well-rounded)
8. Nadal USO 10 final vs Cllic USO 14 final (one-way traffic)
9. Scud Wim 03 final vs Murray Wim 16 final (this is basically the actual Wimbledon 2016 final)
10. Soderling RG 09 final vs Murray RG 16 final (too close to call; I think both would perform better if they didn't have Fed and Novak respectively standing in their way; could be an epic)
11. Agassi USO 05 final vs Nadal USO 11 final (Agassi would run Nadal ragged for a couple sets, but I think the Spaniard would ultimately outlast him)
12. Roddick Wim 09 final vs Djokovic Wim 14 final (Novak the favorite, for sure, but that serve... I don't know)
13. Nadal Wim 08 final vs Murray Wim 13 final (not that close)
14. Baggy AO 06 final vs Murray AO 15 final (first couple sets would probably be fun, but in the end not that close)
15. Del Potro RG 09 vs Djokovic RG 11 (probably Novak, but damn was Delpo good here; wish we could've seen this match-up)
16. Sampras USO 02 final vs Murray USO 12 final (probably Sampras, though it's possible Murray wears the old man down)
Click to expand...
Not convinced Federer of the Wim 2019 final could pull it off with 2004 Roddick on grass. 2004 Federer struggled quite a bit and he was better than 2019 Federer.
 
1. Hewitt Wim 02 final vs Murray Wim 12 final
2. Roddick Wim 04 final vs Federer Wim 19 final
3. Gonzo AO 07 final vs Nadal AO 12 final
4. Safin AO 05 SF vs Djokovic AO 13 SF
5. Agassi USO 04 vs Djokovic USO 15
6. Del Potro Wim 13 vs Djokovic Wim 19
7. Roddick Wim 03 SF vs Djokovic Wim 11 final
8. Nadal USO 10 final vs Cllic USO 14 final
9. Scud Wim 03 final vs Murray Wim 16 final
10. Soderling RG 09 final vs Murray RG 16 final
11. Agassi USO 05 final vs Nadal USO 11 final
12. Roddick Wim 09 final vs Djokovic Wim 14 final
13. Nadal Wim 08 final vs Murray Wim 13 final
14. Baggy AO 06 final vs Murray AO 15 final
15. Del Potro RG 09 vs Djokovic RG 11
16. Sampras USO 02 final vs Murray USO 12 final

dfmp5d9-2d8af3a9-70c5-4bfc-8194-d0c2fdebc8a6.gif
 
vive le beau jeu ! said:
1. Hewitt Wim 02 final vs Murray Wim 12 final
2. Roddick Wim 04 final vs Federer Wim 19 final
3. Gonzo AO 07 final vs Nadal AO 12 final
4. Safin AO 05 SF vs Djokovic AO 13 SF
5. Agassi USO 04 vs Djokovic USO 15
6. Del Potro Wim 13 vs Djokovic Wim 19
7. Roddick Wim 03 SF vs Djokovic Wim 11 final
8. Nadal USO 10 final vs Cllic USO 14 final
9. Scud Wim 03 final vs Murray Wim 16 final
10. Soderling RG 09 final vs Murray RG 16 final
11. Agassi USO 05 final vs Nadal USO 11 final
12. Roddick Wim 09 final vs Djokovic Wim 14 final
13. Nadal Wim 08 final vs Murray Wim 13 final
14. Baggy AO 06 final vs Murray AO 15 final
15. Del Potro RG 09 vs Djokovic RG 11
16. Sampras USO 02 final vs Murray USO 12 final

dfmp5d9-2d8af3a9-70c5-4bfc-8194-d0c2fdebc8a6.gif
Click to expand...
That must have been hard for you.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

lud
Ranking all 20 FIN opponents of Big 3
Replies
2
Views
755
TheSlicer
T
The_Order
Favorite Matches from your favorite players
Replies
4
Views
1K
FedererWinsWimbledon2014
F
Towny
Sets dropped in Big 3 slam wins
Replies
43
Views
3K
NoleFam
NoleFam
AnOctorokForDinner
  • Poll Poll
Tougher competition: prime Federer at Wimbledon or prime Djokovic at the AO?
Replies
30
Views
3K
DSH
DSH
lud
Ok. IF Matches, who would win?
Replies
6
Views
588
Towser83
Towser83
Back
Top