Top 14 win-loss records (percentage) vs Big 3 with at least 8 matches

[PleaseBeNicer]

If we exclude those with less than 20 matches the top 10 are:

Rafa 53-46, 54%
Novak 57-52, 52%
Thiem 16-18, 47%
Roger 39-51 43%
Zverev 11-17 39%
Nalbandian 11-20 36%
Murray 29-56 34%
Hewitt 14-31 31%
Tsonga 16-39 29%
DelPo 17-45 27%

If we include those with at least 8 matches the top 15 are:

Hrbaty 5-3, 63%
Rafa 53-46, 54%
Novak 57-52, 52%
Thiem 16-18, 47%
Roger 39-51 43%
Zverev 11-17 39%
Rublev 3-5 38%
Nalbandian 11-20 36%
Murray 29-56 34%
Coric 5-10 33%
Kyrgios 6-13 32%
Hewitt 14-31 31%
Tsonga 16-39 29%
DelPo 17-45 27%
Daniil 6-17, 26%

Most calculations from TheBigThree here: https://****************.com/threads/who-has-a-good-winning-percentage-against-big-3.1017760/#post-42657820

Other calculations by me.

Alcaraz is 2-2, 50%, and 2-0 100% in the last two matches. If he has at least another 4 matches against them, and wins more than 75% of those matches, he'll surpass everyone on that list. If he wins at least 60%, he will surpass everyone except Hrbaty.

Let me know if I missed someone (with at least 8 matches against them) or did a miscalculation.

 

[mahesh69a]

What it tell us?

 

[PleaseBeNicer]

What it tell us?

For those that only have 8 matches against them, perhaps not much, but for those with more than 15 matches against them, I think it's a pretty good measure of their peak level, since the top players in this list either had a very high level in general or were able to raise their level when playing against the Big Three. Obviously distorted a bit by those who only played them only early or late in their careers, but not meaningless.

Also, the Hrbaty part is just funny, mostly a statistical anomaly as he never made top 10, but he did make it to no. 12.

 

[Chanwan]

What it tell us?

That Hrbaty is the true goat (or goat-killer), no?

 

[Chanwan]

Very impressive from Thiem, he's 5-2 vs. Fed (there are some caveats to some of those matches, but still)

 

[mahatma]

What it tell us?

Nothing.

 

[SonnyT]

Andy Roddick??