Or at least has the highest peak.
Sounds crazy at first, but after the evidence, things will be pretty obvious.
Ok, first Djokovic has a leading h2h vs Federer and Nadal. Well, Roddick has leading h2h vs Djokovic.
Then guys, Dominic Hrbaty has a leading h2h vs Nadal and Federer, and guess who has a leading h2h vs Dominic? Yes, Roddick.
Oh, it gets better. Safin is also the only guy who defeated peakest of Federer at AO 05, and Safin also has leading h2h vs Djokovic who has leading h2h vs Fedal. And who has leading h2h vs Safin? RODDICK!.
Davydenko is legendary for his Nadal ownage, especially on hard courts. And Roddick again has a leading h2h vs Davydenko.
Then, who had tougher competition? Let's see, Roddick had to deal with 19, 12 and 16 grand slam champions. Plus, Murray, Hewitt, old Agassi and so on. Big 3 only had to deal with 1 slam champion when they faced Roddick.
So, I don't see how this doesn't prove Roddick is the greatest or at least has the highest peak.
Sure, Federer has leading h2h vs Roddick, but that doesn't really matter, because when they faced each other, Roddick had to deal with 19 GS champion, but Fed had to deal with only 1 GS champion.
Roddick is too overrated on these boards.
Sounds crazy at first, but after the evidence, things will be pretty obvious.
Ok, first Djokovic has a leading h2h vs Federer and Nadal. Well, Roddick has leading h2h vs Djokovic.
Then guys, Dominic Hrbaty has a leading h2h vs Nadal and Federer, and guess who has a leading h2h vs Dominic? Yes, Roddick.
Oh, it gets better. Safin is also the only guy who defeated peakest of Federer at AO 05, and Safin also has leading h2h vs Djokovic who has leading h2h vs Fedal. And who has leading h2h vs Safin? RODDICK!.
Davydenko is legendary for his Nadal ownage, especially on hard courts. And Roddick again has a leading h2h vs Davydenko.
Then, who had tougher competition? Let's see, Roddick had to deal with 19, 12 and 16 grand slam champions. Plus, Murray, Hewitt, old Agassi and so on. Big 3 only had to deal with 1 slam champion when they faced Roddick.
So, I don't see how this doesn't prove Roddick is the greatest or at least has the highest peak.
Sure, Federer has leading h2h vs Roddick, but that doesn't really matter, because when they faced each other, Roddick had to deal with 19 GS champion, but Fed had to deal with only 1 GS champion.
Roddick is too overrated on these boards.