What a pain! One handed backhand

10sbeast888

Hall of Fame
Pete’s bh vs yours? :-D

go thru all his archive, you wont' fine 1 ball at nose level... it's not a limitation per se if you consider the equipment, tour playing style everything, not many situations call for nose level bhs.

you have a pirate copy of me hitting, see any problem there if I have to hit 1?
I find it irritating that you keep using these two words, ‘teach, student’.
Is showing stuff to friends considered teaching and they’re now your students?

I work with a D1 coach and do teach his students how to hit this shot.
 

ballmachineguy

Hall of Fame
I agree that’s more important than anything else.
It’s also why this thread has nearly 4500 posts.
In addition, if you are trying to control RF angle on any type of shot that doesn’t have the word “volley” in it, you are clueless, as the person you are agreeing with must be.
 

10sbeast888

Hall of Fame
Half of the time when I'm "forced" to hit a 1HBH I am hopping off the outside/back foot anyway

I'd really prefer you focused on swingpath and RF angle, then you can adjust the feet as needed

this is the better approach, which is what my thumb drill teaches as well... player needs to learn hand independence.

'half' is actually quite accurate if you count the shots in pro matches, very close to only 50% you get to step in and hit textbook, the other 50% is scramble... open stance, half volley bunts etc...

people actually take this shot to battle would know this.
 

Rosstour

G.O.A.T.
this is the better approach, which is what my thumb drill teaches as well... player needs to learn hand independence.

'half' is actually quite accurate if you count the shots in pro matches, very close to only 50% you get to step in and hit textbook, the other 50% is scramble... open stance, half volley bunts etc...

people actually take this shot to battle would know this.

Thank you. I think

lol

I'm not a 1H-only player but I use it a lot, more and more as I explore it. It's really a great timesaver out there
 

Curious

G.O.A.T.
Of course that is the way it works optimally, but like I said it has to be down before no matter when you can do it.
I have two more ideas to try today. Delay the racket take back, let the ball come closer to avoid that big forward lunging on most of my backhands.
 

ballmachineguy

Hall of Fame
I have two more ideas to try today. Delay the racket take back, let the ball come closer to avoid that big forward lunging on most of my backhands.
You know what I think. I will try to not post in this thread ever again.

When something is wrong for this long, a detail will never fix it. It has to be a fundamental thing.
 

Jono123

Professional
Yes, he's generating all the power in a small compact swing. Although it looks easy , its anything but.

Go for a higher starting position and let the racquet do the work.

Edit : and by work, I mean not only generating power but executing the correct swing path.
 
Last edited:

Curious

G.O.A.T.
I simply don’t feel comfortable turning as much as Sampras (or Fed) does, and this thing never works if you don’t turn enough. You can get away with less turn on fh but feels very weird and weak on bh. Maybe it’s a neck flexibility or visual issue that makes it feel very unnatural.

 

10sbeast888

Hall of Fame
I simply don’t feel comfortable turning as much as Sampras (or Fed) does, and this thing never works if you don’t turn enough. You can get away with less turn on fh but feels very weird and weak on bh. Maybe it’s a neck flexibility or visual issue that makes it feel very unnatural.


donkeys are known to have stiff necks so that might just be the reason.

your mistake is very common among my students (lol)... at the transition from the back swing to the forward swing you are attacking the ball with the sweet spot, causing the pressure point to be the thumb pad on bevel 7. that is typical amateur open face attack, then during the forward swing you have to flip it shut. even though the follow thru looks like a windshield wipe it's actually a open-to-close flip.

the correct mindset is to attack the ball on edge with the inside of the thumb knuckle put pressure on bevel 6. check my video... you can't see but my thumb pad barely touches the handle.

you can learn all this with the thumb drill. maybe make another video... just attack the ball with bevel 6... it would be like the thumb drill without doing the thumb drill. should fix the shyt bh. lol.

add - the mindside is not to hit the ball. but give it a rolling massage, up and across. and bevel 6 is the perfect place to apply pressure.

people use to say that Sabatini doesn't hit the ball, she massages it.... that's exactly what the shot feels like.
 

Curious

G.O.A.T.
donkeys are known to have stiff necks so that might just be the reason.

your mistake is very common among my students (lol)... at the transition from the back swing to the forward swing you are attacking the ball with the sweet spot, causing the pressure point to be the thumb pad on bevel 7. that is typical amateur open face attack, then during the forward swing you have to flip it shut. even though the follow thru looks like a windshield wipe it's actually a open-to-close flip.

the correct mindset is to attack the ball on edge with the inside of the thumb knuckle put pressure on bevel 6. check my video... you can't see but my thumb pad barely touches the handle.

you can learn all this with the thumb drill. maybe make another video... just attack the ball with bevel 6... it would be like the thumb drill without doing the thumb drill. should fix the shyt bh. lol.

add - the mindside is not to hit the ball. but give it a rolling massage, up and across. and bevel 6 is the perfect place to apply pressure.

people use to say that Sabatini doesn't hit the ball, she massages it.... that's exactly what the shot feels like.
Maybe this pushing with the thumb stuff is the reason why your bh is just a powder puff, listless, lethargic stroke.
 

Curious

G.O.A.T.
If I was able to turn like this and still see the ball, my bh would improve overnight. Unfortunately I can track the ball with the corner of my right eye only when I turn that much hitting a live ball.


 

10sbeast888

Hall of Fame
If I was able to turn like this and still see the ball, my bh would improve overnight. Unfortunately I can track the ball with the corner of my right eye only when I turn that much hitting a live ball.



my 1 thumb flat footed open stance bh will out rally yours all day... your vision is fine... but the shadow swing is still an open face attack.
 

nyta2

Hall of Fame
If I was able to turn like this and still see the ball, my bh would improve overnight. Unfortunately I can track the ball with the corner of my right eye only when I turn that much hitting a live ball.


i don't normally hit a 1hhbh.. . but when i'm goofing around, channeling my innner wawarinka... i keep my elbow straight when i exec the external shoulder rotation (eg. windshield wipe) through contact...
if i bent my elbow on the follow through, like you appear to do in your shadow swing, when i swing fast it feels like i'm putting myself into a americanaLock (from bjj, et al)... does it feel that way to you when you swing fast?
 
Last edited:

Rosstour

G.O.A.T.
Go ahead. I’m curious to see your 1hbh.

@Curious @10sbeast888 it's the last video in this thread


I mostly use a 2H but there are different kinds of 1H in that video that will illustrate the point I made earlier. I listed out a few timestamps in that thread but basically for the purposes of seeing me hit 1Hs the first 2 minutes are all you need to look at, most of them are concentrated there
 
Last edited:

10sbeast888

Hall of Fame
I see @ballmachineguy 's point about the foot work sync...

although at this point even if @Curious does the sync the shot will still be garbage.... he's got an open face!.. the more power generated from the footwork and uncoiling will just make the face even more open.

no wonder his friend had to go outside to fetch that wild ball he hit lol.

the hand needs to be trained to maintain a closed face first.
 
Last edited:

10sbeast888

Hall of Fame
btw, in battle only 50% is hit in a sync'ed way anyway... I just finised 1.5 hours.. transition to all out attacking the front court, 70% of the bh drives today were hit off the backfoot as approach shots.. the footwork pattern is about a mirror image of the outside-out pattern on the fh approach (which is hit on the outside/back foot).
 

tendency

Semi-Pro
@Curious can't remember this, but are you sure you don't have a grip issue w/ your backhand? for me, the only way my racquet face would open at the end of the backswing if if i contorted my wrist/forearm in a funky unnatural position.
 

Rosstour

G.O.A.T.
@Curious can't remember this, but are you sure you don't have a grip issue w/ your backhand? for me, the only way my racquet face would open at the end of the backswing if if i contorted my wrist/forearm in a funky unnatural position.

He's doing that little flap on follow through deliberately, I think. One of his many innovations
 

Curious

G.O.A.T.
i don't normally hit a 1hhbh.. . but when i'm goofing around, channeling my innner wawarinka... i keep my elbow straight when i exec the external shoulder rotation (eg. windshield wipe) through contact...
if i bent my elbow on the follow through, like you appear to do in your shadow swing, when i swing fast it feels like i'm putting myself into a americanaLock (from bjj, et al)... does it feel that way to you when you swing fast?
My elbow is more straight on follow through when I’m hitting balls. Does it really matter anyway as long as it’s straight at contact?


 

Curious

G.O.A.T.
@Curious can't remember this, but are you sure you don't have a grip issue w/ your backhand? for me, the only way my racquet face would open at the end of the backswing if if i contorted my wrist/forearm in a funky unnatural position.
The only grip issue maybe is that I don’t get into a full eastern grip. Fed has a weak eastern grip, too.
 

Curious

G.O.A.T.
How well he explains the naturalness of a bent arm ohbh (take back and follow through). That’s why Fed and Sampras bh look so smooth and natural but those like Thiem and Kohlschreiber look so robotic.


 
Last edited:

tendency

Semi-Pro
The only grip issue maybe is that I don’t get into a full eastern grip. Fed has a weak eastern grip, too.

that's something to think about (im sure you've tinkered w/ your grip..). i do full eastern definitely helps with getting the racquet face correct and generating spin. if you drive your weight correctly through the ball (which, as we know, you dont .. :) ) lots of power.
 
Top