Ok here are the results of my demo -
(In Short)
Dunlop Aerogel 200
First Impressions - Nice paintwork, cool blue and white colors. The head seemed large for a 95 sq in size. Grip is comfortable, but racquet doesn't feel 8 pts headlight at all, more like 3-4 pts headlight. I confirmed it was about 6.5 pts headlight on the balance board. The demo racquet came strung with a poly string and I had a feeling I would not like it. The racquet felt solid otherwise.
Groundstrokes- It wasn't the easiest of the bunch to pickup and start playing. The feel was muted but controlled when I able to connect to the sweetspot and vague on off-center hits. I wasn't able to get consistency on the forehand side even after 5 minutes of hitting. The backhand side was even worse. I have a one-handed backhand and it felt like I was trying to play with a butterfly-net instead of a racquet. Basically I had no "feel" for the ball on that side. The Dunlop promptly went back into my bag never to return.
Serves/Volleys/Stability - Sorry racquet didn't make it past the ground strokes test. For someone familiar with the line of racquets like the Dunlop 200G Muscleweave, this racquet may be a worthy successor, but I totally did not feel this was a PS85 replacement. What's more, I felt this racquet would give me tennis elbow. I haven't had that feeling in my forearm in a long time.
Overall Score - 6/10
Tecnifibre TFight 335
First Impressions- Again, very nice, black and red paintjob. The racquet feels solid and heavy. This was the heaviest racquet of all the ones I demoed. Swinging it did not feel easy, even though it is pretty headlight. TW had a black overgrip on the red handle, so the look overall was splendid. The racquet face is big at 97 sq in and is in a tear-drop shape.
Groundstrokes- I was able to pickup this racquet and start swinging pretty easily on the court, despite the overall weight. My earlier reservations about swingweight were put to rest. I settled into a rhythm soon on the forehand side and it took a little while to adjust on the backhand side. I was able to keep the ball deep in a controlled fashion as long as I was able to keep it on the sweetspot. Off-center hits were not very jarring but enough for me to be aware of them. My biggest problem was perhaps just a perception and nothing that really mattered, but the sound from the racquet when hitting the ball was not a nice solid "thock" but more of a pingy sound. I think this is because of the large head size. (This was with dampener). The second issue was more real - on backhand slices, the ball just sat up. I'm used to slicing the ball deep floating just above the net cord, but I just wasn't able to do that with the TFight.
Serves and Overheads - I had no issues putting pace on my first serve and generating spin on the seconds. The weight of the racquet helps in generating pace, although I can see tiring one's arm over a long match due to the overall weight. On overheads, I struggled just a tad bit more to time it properly, but it wasn't too bad.
Volleys and Stability- This is a nice and heavy racquet that has plenty of room for absorbing the impact of a well-hit ball. Like on the overheads, when I was able to bring up the racquet head in time and connect with the racquet center, volleys felt solid. Backhand slice volleys were no good again because the ball sat up. I had to punch the ball in, instead of sliding into the net with a slice on the backhand side.
Overall Score - 8/10
Prince Original Graphite
First Impressions- Racquet felt much lighter than the specs suggested. I measured the weight and sure enough, strung weight was 335 gms instead of 346 gms as advertised (thats 11.8 oz instead of 12.2 oz). Even accounting for differences in string weight, I don't know how that much of a difference can creep in unless manufacturing Q.C is bad. The finish is a nice dark green with gold stenciling on the letters. The material sounded hollow and stiff on tapping. This was the most head light of all racquets and I was able to swing it through the air with little resistance. I looked forward to generating high head speeds on court.
Groundstrokes- Like I alluded, the racquet is very maneuverable on court due to the extreme head light balance. I was able to take the racquet back and really swing it forward with pace which helped me with directional control and putting some very nice topspin on the ball. Unfortunately, depth and power was a concern because there is not much weight in the head and stability in the stock form is an issue. Added to that, flexibility seems stiffer than the specs suggest (66). But the good news is that this is a racquet that begs to be customized with lead tape. There is room for weight in the head without sacrificing too much on balance, since its so head light.
Serves/Overheads- Really easy to snap wrist on serves and to bring it up on overheads. Like I said earlier, adding a little weight in the head would definitely improve power on serves. Top spin kick serves went in just about perfect.
Overall Score - 8.5/10
Head Microgel Prestige Mid
First Impressions- I had to get a 4 1/2 grip on the demo because they were out of the 4 3/8s but boy is that grip different or what. I have a Volkl and even that does not have such a pronounced, rectangular grip shape. I wasn't too taken with the color scheme or anything, but suffice to say that the racquet does not look cheap or out of place. Swinging the racquet felt maneuverable enough but not like the POG or TFight. I was pretty even-handed on expectations going onto the courts.
Groundstrokes- I will be honest and say I wasn't impressed on the very first try, but one round of trying all the racquets, when I went back to this one, the Prestige had the best feel and control of all the ones I demoed. Connecting with the racquet center produces a nice solid "thwock" sound and a very consistent, deep ball. The handle shape helped me keep the grip a full semi-western on forehands (I usually play somewhere between Eastern and Semi-Western), placing my palm on the pronounced flat side of the handle parallel to the racquet face. I had to get used to the grip on my backhand though, but after a little practice, the racquet was as sweet and consistent on that side as my forehand. Even better, slices behaved exactly the way I'm used to, going deep and keeping inches off the net. I think Head distributed weight/material pretty well in the hoop section which helps in stability and response. I did feel a little inconsistent feel on the odd off-center hit, but it was not as pronounced as the other ones.
Serves/Overheads- No problems here. Was able to ease into the service motion without hitches and generated decent spin and pace. I think just a tad bit of lead in the upper hoop might help with power, but again that's a personal call.
Volleys/Stability - Like I noted earlier, the racquet is pretty stable but I had to make sure I connected with the racquet head center to punch in my volleys. Bringing the racquet head up in time was no problem. Once you get used to it, I'm sure net play will not be a negative with this racquet
Overall Score - 9/10
All this said, you will be surprised to hear my final judgment.
I'm sticking with my PS85 and have determined that the K90 is the closest enough relative to it out there so I'm keeping that too. I liked the Head Prestige Mid very much and I'm sure if I used it regularly, I would be very happy with it given its feel and consistent response. But out of these tests, I've determined two things I like about the Wilson racquets, which I was never consciously aware of before - one, the design of the racquet head places some weight/stability in the 3oclock and 9 oclock area which I use on plow-through and which also gives me a very consistent feel across the
whole racquet face. Even when I frame balls with them, many I time I get the ball across the net. Two, despite the weight and stability of the head section, these racquets manage to remain extremely maneuverable because of their head light balance. Simply put, they designed the perfect package for my game in the PS 85. I did discover I hit my shots a little flatter with the PS85. But I'm willing to work on that just given the feel and excellence of this racquet. Never once have I had to think with this racquet.
I think that is the ultimate compliment I can pay to any racquet, in as far as equipment can help, and it is that
I don't give it a second thought
I concentrate on my game and strategy and if the PS85/K90 help me keep my focus there, then so be it!
