Its overrated when it's compared to 2011-2012 imo. It's a weird year because Nadal never played Murray who despite the ranking was obviously #3 that year. I think Djokovic had fierce competition that year but from Nadal's perspective? It was good but not sensational.How would you compare 2008 and 2013 these years? Think you told me elsewhere you felt 2013 was overrated.
I'd put 2008 at number one and 2013 in the with 2004/2005/2014 probably.