What happened to German tennis? A devolution with no end. ATP thread.

Listen, I personally has nothing against saying Zverev is German. He legally is. But the nuance is he’s also Russian.
Actually if you read the OPS original post he is arguing that Zev isn't a real German because he was born to Russian parents.
 
Thats not true. My wife as born in Germany. Her Father was Austrian. She had to take the nationality of her Father. Her mother was German.

That's because Austria doesn't recognize dual citizenship. Although I feel your wife could get German citizenship simply without notifying Austrian authorities.

I know with Ukraine a lot of citizens got 2nd passports without notifying Ukrainian government.
 
It’s true now. Not sure how it was when your wife was born. Laws change.
Its not easy. She has wanted to get her EU citizenship for awhile now. Lots of red tape. She gave it up to vote in America. Now its possible to get dual citizenship. But its a major pain.
 
That's because Austria doesn't recognize dual citizenship. Although I feel your wife could get German citizenship simply without notifying Austrian authorities.

I know with Ukraine a lot of citizens got 2nd passports without notifying Ukrainian government.
It aint simple. Lots of delays. Not logical ones but it is what it is. Her mother still lives in Germany. Her brother does as well. But he is still Austrian by passport. Now what does he feel he is? German. Because thats where he spent his whole life.
 
Well, my position is what I said in the post you replied to. Life is never black and white.
And my position is a guy who was born in Germany, is a German citizen, plays for Germany, represents Germany, and says he identifies as a German is German.
 
It aint simple. Lots of delays. Not logical ones but it is what it is. Her mother still lives in Germany. Her brother does as well. But he is still Austrian by passport. Now what does he feel he is? German. Because thats where he spent his whole life.

Well with an EU passport it's a bit redundant. The Austrian-German dynamic is also historically more blurred than Russia-Germany.

Anyway I concur with the sentiment Zverev is a Russian who is a German citizen and represents German nationalism. I don't see that statement as disingenuous. With regards to German tennis, there still needs to be a push for ethnic Germans to represent NOT because it's somehow negative for a Russian to represent Germany but because it's also good to have generational foundation.
 
Well with an EU passport it's a bit redundant. The Austrian-German dynamic is also historically more blurred than Russia-Germany.

Anyway I concur with the sentiment Zverev is a Russian who is a German citizen and represents German nationalism. I don't see that statement as disingenuous. With regards to German tennis, there still needs to be a push for ethnic Germans to represent NOT because it's somehow negative for a Russian to represent Germany but because it's also good to have generational foundation.
I disagree. And if Germans feel that a guy with Russian parents doesnt inspire them then I can't help them. I don't think thats the issue with German tennis and we have gone over that already. Tennis goes in cycles in countries. All you need is one guy. But even that doesnt mean it gets a bunch of people out on a court to from a future champion. It doesn't work like that. I think for some sports that barely anyone plays like say Luge it means something. But tennis is played everywhere. Special talents are not grown in a factory.
 
I disagree. And if Germans feel that a guy with Russian parents doesnt inspire them then I can't help them. I don't think thats the issue with German tennis and we have gone over that already. Tennis goes in cycles in countries. All you need is one guy. But even that doesnt mean it gets a bunch of people out on a court to from a future champion. It doesn't work like that. I think for some sports that barely anyone plays like say Luge it means something. But tennis is played everywhere. Special talents are not grown in a factory.
I don’t understand why you can’t accept that Zverev is Russian German, and Anisimova is Russian American?
 
I don’t understand why you can’t accept that Zverev is Russian German, and Anisimova is Russian American?
Because both are products of the country they were born in and identify as German and American respectfully. Sampras was born to an American who's background was from Greece and a mom who actually was from Greece. He said he was American. And he played for America. Could he have played for Greece? Sure. Why would he do that. He was born in the states, he lived in the states, he played his tennis in the states.
 
Don't think anyone ever foresaw Agassi and Steffi hooking up him being such a flashy extrovert and she being quite shy and private. Guess it must have been the attraction of opposites and, give them their due, they've been a solid item now for almost a quarter of a century.
I guess even more than attraction of the opposite it is that they share the same childhood history of being raised by crazy tennis fathers. Agassi explained it in his book that he felt that Steffi was the first one who understood him immediately when he told her he hated tennis (assuming that was true as we know that Agassi’s book has to be taken with a grain of salt). Back in 1995 I read an interview with Agassi where he was praising Steffi as the greatest of them all and how amazing she is etc. which really sounded already that he had a crush on her.
 
America being a melting pot of ethnicities, Americans have trouble understanding how it is in the old world. A Russian in America will become American. A Russian in Germany will be Russian.
Your “logic” is GRU-some. Is your real name Vladimir and are you currently active trying to save free people from their Na-zi oppressors that are led by a Jew?
 
Graf. Becker. Those are the only two that really make German tennis materially different from *insert any random European country here*. Seriously the only two.

I hardly think it’s a decline as much as a regression to the mean. Individual sport favors wildly outlier individual talents, trends are very difficult to find.
This. ATGs let alone GOAT candidates cannot really be planned, regardless of how good training facilities or support in the individual country might be. The most important thing here is Talent as well as dedication and luck and a potential GOAT level talent maybe comes along every few decades or so. Graf/Becker/Stich was simply an anomaly, Germany never before or after had players on that level, not even on the level of Stich. Same as with Switzerland where we had Hingis, Federer, Wawrinka within a very short time span. I am next to 100% sure though, that there will be nobody comparable to them from Switzerland in the upcoming years.
 
Stop embarrassing yourself man. You have too much anger, and that makes you irrational.
Pot calling kettle black. You just made up a lie that Auger Aliassime was born in Africa, you bigoted flaming hater and you call me “irrational”???
 
Pot calling kettle black. You just made up a lie that Auger Aliassime was born in Africa, you bigoted flaming hater and you call me “irrational”???
I already apologised for my mistake. I confused his story with another Canadian athlete. What’s with the hate speech? Anger management. Take a deep breath.
 
Four players in the top 100 but only one genuine star in Zverev is probably underachieving but as in U.K. football is what attracts the best young athletes.
 
I already apologised for my mistake. I confused his story with another Canadian athlete. What’s with the hate speech? Anger management. Take a deep breath.
Your credibility is zero. Did you respond to my counterpointbti your blatant lie? No. Even if you had, you are carrying a water bucket for despots full of holes from the rotting wood of being a birther liar.

How dare you offer me anger management advice when you started the row with your blatant twisting of facts? You’re a totally misguided hypocrite.
 
Your credibility is zero. Did you respond to my counterpointbti your blatant lie? No. Even if you had, you are carrying a water bucket for despots full of holes from the rotting wood of being a birther liar.

How dare you offer me anger management advice when you started the row with your blatant twisting of facts? You’re a totally misguided hypocrite.
Did you forget to take your medicine today?
 
How old are you? Seriously.
Are you going to add in a hollow form of ageism like countless other clowns on the forum?

I am offended by your statement that Americans don’t understand how it is in the old world. Millions of immigrants gather in ethnic enclaves all over the country and cling to the cultures they left. Have you not heard of Little Russia in the Brighton Beach section of Brooklyn?

The only difference between Little Russia and Little Germany in the same city, for example, is when they coalesced into their own neighborhoods and how able they have been to establish their neighborhoods as property owners and business people. Little Germany on the upper east side of Manhattan got pricey so most found new living arrangements and assimilated in the last century. Two world wars with their home country didn’t help. There are a lot of Millers and Smiths who started as Mullers and Schmidts to escaoe

Your opinion of German personality is also offensive. They don’t all act temperamentally like your feeble attempt at stereotyping them as a country of angry folk. How do I know this as fact? I lived there for two years and they are pretty much like most people worldwide. Some can be thoughtful and kind, some are more like you, willing to walk around with a burning fuse and waiting to explode.

To say Zverev remains Russian despite his story (born in Germany, always representing his birth nation) and that it is different than any other son/daughter of immigrant children is the type of mindset that allows deadly divisions. You enable despots like a Putin or Xi to exist. If you’re not in Russia already, please move there so you won’t be the square peg in a round hole.
 
Did you forget to take your medicine today?
LOL! Another clown response. Seriously, seek some help. Get out and see how the world really is instead of your fantasy about Russians being Russian even when born a thousand miles away.
 
Well with an EU passport it's a bit redundant. The Austrian-German dynamic is also historically more blurred than Russia-Germany.

Anyway I concur with the sentiment Zverev is a Russian who is a German citizen and represents German nationalism. I don't see that statement as disingenuous. With regards to German tennis, there still needs to be a push for ethnic Germans to represent NOT because it's somehow negative for a Russian to represent Germany but because it's also good to have generational foundation.

Completely a**e about face. Zverev is a German who represents Germany in international sport and who has Russian parents.
 
Just Googled Zverev, says he was born in Germany and I assume was supported by German Tennis in Germany. Therefore follows he is German and his tennis is too.
Which is why he has more Russian tennis fans on the internet than German ones...

Many Russians consider him as their own. Surely, this isn't random.
 
Last edited:
Not a German but I know. Boris did his thing in the broom cupboard and Steffi fell for that American heartthrob. German tennis went down the pooper.
Graf's father did hard prison time for corruption-related dealings, in the 90s.

This seems to be completely erased from history. Have never read it anywhere on TTW.
 
This. ATGs let alone GOAT candidates cannot really be planned, regardless of how good training facilities or support in the individual country might be. The most important thing here is Talent as well as dedication and luck and a potential GOAT level talent maybe comes along every few decades or so. Graf/Becker/Stich was simply an anomaly, Germany never before or after had players on that level, not even on the level of Stich. Same as with Switzerland where we had Hingis, Federer, Wawrinka within a very short time span. I am next to 100% sure though, that there will be nobody comparable to them from Switzerland in the upcoming years.
The thing is, tennis is a highly elitist sport, and Germany is not only one of the wealthiest nations, it has a VERY large population. By far the largest in Europe. (I had to laugh when a German newsreader the other day said that "Poland is a small country." Poland has 40 million people.) It is just very strange that some very small countries (not Poland) produce champs or top 10 players almost regularly while Germany can have very long stretches without top male players.

The talent pool in Germany must be enormous. Despite the "Nowitzki effect", there should be enough talent "left over" for tennis and other smaller sports.
 
True, although mysteriously in the qualies, one of the wildcards went to Marko Topo, a young Serbian player around the same age as those young German players.

It's good to look at talent and not just nationality when awarding wildcards, but if any of any of the German players can pick one up elsewhere.

@UnderratedSlam - we now have the answer as to why Marko Topo was given a wildcard at the BMW Open:

 
Sinner and Federer are basically German, so it's not like Germans have had no talent. (Understatement.)

So why are there no top German talents playing for Germany?

Zverev is Russian... just to reiterate.

Russian.

He has a German passport but his parents came from Russia. He has a Russian first name and surname.
So then Agassi is Armenian, Sampras is Greek, Courier, McEnroe, Connors are Irish, Chang is Chinese, Hewitt is English, etc. Or does that only apply to non-Anglo speaking tennis countries?
 
Which is why he has more Russian tennis fans on the internet than German ones...

Many Russians consider him as their own. Surely, this isn't random.
Russians consider anyone remotely connected to Russia living in other countries or regions as one of their own to start a proxy or direct war for annexation.

Oops sorry could not resist!

I consider Zverev German where ever his allegiances may lie. Same for Tsitsipas - he's Greek of Russian descent.
 
Hey buddy I’m actually married to a German who is a us citizen. Her mom lives in Germany so does her brother. So don’t lecture me on what I understand or not
I'm an American who married an Austrian and who has lived in both Austria and Germany for years. But we're the anomaly and you have to admit the majority of Americans are stupid as hell about other countries. The only European country most Americans could name is England and that's utterly pathetic.
 
I'm an American who married an Austrian and who has lived in both Austria and Germany for years. But we're the anomaly and you have to admit the majority of Americans are stupid as hell about other countries. The only European country most Americans could name is England and that's utterly pathetic.
I use to think that. But then I thought really it doesnt matter. As someone once said ignorance is bliss. Knowing stuff about Europe isn't important to most US citizens thats really all there is to it. And I can sit up on my high horse and say boy I have been all over Europe and know lots of stuff. But I know very little about Africa for example. And not much about East Asia.
 
Back
Top