It can work. Many things can work from close up unless you face some Alcarazes or De Minaurs to get to anything you hit and pass you. The question is, why it’s supposed to be better than typical high level topspin drive? Net clearance is totally a controlled feature with any technique, you want - you hit a net skimmer, you wish - you send it higher.
I see how more or less what you suggest may work as faster-prep options, I see it when people just step up to the ball straight and short-swing it. No stepping around in prep, coiling, initiating the swing, using appropriate footwork.. just step up and punch. And this has advantages for rec players.
The biggest issue to me is that tight posture of the swing may lead to injuries, like shoulder impingement and tennis elbow. The biggest red flag to using such technique, especially with power.
PS:
@nyta2 is a seasoned martial artist, so I bet his punches are not weak.