Sampras has had the best offensive game so far. Nadal, arguably, has the best defensive game ever. But Fed has the best combo offensive/defenisve game, which makes him potent on any surface against any opponent on any continent.
fastdunn said:
I know what you're saying. He does magical shots time and time again.
His defense is so good. However, IMHO, his net game is sub-par compared to
top players of past and his offense game does not have explosiveness
like some of past greats. His game is perefct for current ATP condition
since courts are slow and it's mostly baseline tennis. But I'm not
so sure if he can dominate like this if tour condition changes...
fastdunn, you keep saying this but the record doesn't bear this out. Look at Fed's record at Wimbledon compared to other slams. He is much more dominant there - lost only 4 sets in 21 matches (Sampras lost many more in his first 3 W's) whereas he's already lost 6 and 7 sets respectively in 8 fewer matches at USO & AO. He gets broken far less on grass than on other surfaces.
I think this is because grass covers up his (relative) weaknesses. It helps his serve enormously; his backhand - which can be timid & short on hard courts - actually is a huge weapon on grass because the ball never gets up high. His slice has more bite. Grass also helps his incredible variety of shotmaking and footwork. This is why he has delivered three of his finest performances - SF & F in 2003 & 2005 final - on grass. Furthermore, even the opponents on grass ususally have big serves and a big game and can end points quickly (Roddick, Flipper, Karlovic etc) - so what I think his biggest weakness - lack of fitness - never comes into play even if the match goes 4 or 5 sets. He is also better returner of big serves than medium paced, spinny serves.
Historically, he has dealt with players with big, aggressive games very well. He has a lopsided H-H record against basically all the big hitters - Roddick, Philippussis, Karlovic, Safin, Ljubicic, Mirnyi, Blake, Fernando Gonzalez and even old-timers like Sampras, Ivanisevic, Krajicek, Rusedski etc. And since these are the guys he would likely meet on faster surfaces, I don't think he would do as poorly as you make it out to be.