Following turned into TLDR … short version is I hated feel of CRBN Truefoam coming from gen 3, and like feel Vatic V Sol Pro “good enough”. I have played my best ever with it … those tend to end up feeling good to you.
All foam paddles are not equal … but feel preferences will always vary. I find JOOLA Pro IV very stiff, my V Sol Pro less stiff or equal.
TLDR:
No paddle feels good (big part of that is the wiffle) to this retired tennis player … and I have a bag full of them. So for me … I am picking preferences within rudimentary equipment, and feel isn’t at top of my list except for grip.
This is my current preference order in importance (more explanation follows the list)
1) spin
2) grip
3) paddle shape
4) static weight and balance
5) swing weight and twist weight
6) feel
7) power/pop
If I could buy legal non-grit 3000 RPM (and grab) today I would. I don’t do DUPR or play tournaments … only reason I say legal is many of the guys I play round robin leagues with do. I’m just avoiding any whining.

I want the 3000 RPM for baseline lobs in doubles. I am very close to low error rate … give me 3000 RPM and good to go. After saying all that … more grab regardless of spin would make the game more enjoyable to me. Grit is sh.!.t … I’m hearing rumors non-grit spin may not be that far off. Much of it comes down to if the rules continue to restrict evolution.
I bolded first two because they are significantly more important to me than the rest. If I don’t like how the grip feels in my hand it doesn’t matter how good the paddle plays. I love Vatic grips, don’t like JOOLA grips. Tennis grips did not need to be reinvented (did I mention rudimentary equipment).
The rest of the list is more of a “I know what I prefer now after way too many paddles $$$”
I like a long handled extended paddle (played every shape), start at 8.0 oz so I can customize with tungsten, final swing weight 120 or less is good to go (now I choke up when I move to kitchen). I can generate my own power but now wouldn’t want to play with less than the V Sol Pro power … I am not having any trouble controlling it (wiffle control will never equal tennis ball/strings control). I used to prefer lower pop at the kitchen, but 3 years later that has changed. You win a lot of points at kitchen with the extra pop firepower … playing against Boomstiks with my old Vatic Prism would be taking a knife to a gun fight.
Other than that I have no opinions on paddles.