Which is the real 'Other Andy'? Roddick or Murray

[tvp900]

Here's their recent grand slam results

Andy Roddick - Australian Open - Semifinals
French Open - Round of 16
Wimbledon - Final
US Open - Third Round

Andy Murray - Australian Open - Round of 16
French Open - Quarterfinals
Wimbledon - Semifinals
US Open - Round of 16

I think people were expecting great things from both Andys at the US Open and they both had letdowns. Let's hear what the masses say.

 

[Fiunck(click)]

Murray for sure

 

[clayman2000]

Andy gets the nod in the slams. Murray had no top 10 wins in slams, Roddick had 2. Roddick came withing inches of winning a slam, Murray never came within a set of the finals. 3 of Roddicks losses were to top 10 players, 2 of them to the world no 1. 1 of Murrays losses was to a top 10 player.

 

[roddickfan1000]

seeing as roddick beat murray in his own backyard at the wimbledon semis i would say roddick in the slams.

murray in the 1000 series