Nadalgaenger
G.O.A.T.
Federer was 8-0 vs. Roddick in GS matches. He beat him in the following GS matches:
2003 W SF
2004 W F
2005 W F
2006 USO F
2007 AO SF
2007 USO QF
2009 AO SF
2009 W F
Given this domination, it is safe to say that Roddick would have won at least one (and likely multiple) Wimbledon titles, perhaps another USO title and maybe an AO. He likely would be viewed as a worthy successor to Sampras and Agassi (not their equal, but no second tier scion either).
Djokovic is 8-2 vs. Murray in GS matches. Here are the Djokovic victories over Murray in GS matches:
2011 AO F
2012 AO SF
2013 AO F
2014 USO QF
2015 AO F
2015 FO SF
2016 AO F
2016 FO F
Murray likely would have won at least 3 AO titles and at least 1 FO. He’d have won a career slam and would be considered on par with Edberg or Becker.
So which player suffered more and why?
2003 W SF
2004 W F
2005 W F
2006 USO F
2007 AO SF
2007 USO QF
2009 AO SF
2009 W F
Given this domination, it is safe to say that Roddick would have won at least one (and likely multiple) Wimbledon titles, perhaps another USO title and maybe an AO. He likely would be viewed as a worthy successor to Sampras and Agassi (not their equal, but no second tier scion either).
Djokovic is 8-2 vs. Murray in GS matches. Here are the Djokovic victories over Murray in GS matches:
2011 AO F
2012 AO SF
2013 AO F
2014 USO QF
2015 AO F
2015 FO SF
2016 AO F
2016 FO F
Murray likely would have won at least 3 AO titles and at least 1 FO. He’d have won a career slam and would be considered on par with Edberg or Becker.
So which player suffered more and why?