Who has had the better career out of Tsonga Gasquet Simon and Monfils

[TsitsiBH]

Slam final : Tsonga 1 - Others 0
Slam semis : Tsonga 6 - Gasquet 3 - Monfils 2 - Simon 0
Slam quarters : Tsonga 15 - Monfils 10 - Gasquet 5 - Simon 2

YEC finals : Tsonga 1 - Others 0
Masters titles : Tsonga 2 - Others 0
Masters finals : Tsonga 4 - Monfils 3 - Gasquet 3 - Simon 2


Career high ranking : Tsonga top 5 - Monfils top 6 - Simon top 6 - Gasquet top 7

Record against Big 3 : Tsonga 29% (16W-55L) - Simon 13% (4W-26L) - Monfils 12% (6W-42L) - Gasquet 6% (3W-50L)

Results seem to give the edge to Tsonga but curious what you think ?

 

[chjtennis]

I don't think it's even close. Tsonga, by far, was the biggest French player of his generation. He was always in the top 10 and threaten to beat Big 4 in slams and other tournaments.

 

[Kralingen]

Tsonga is one of the best players I’ve ever seen.

Can’t say that about the rest.

 

[TheNachoMan]

Tsonga by far. He could’ve and actually should’ve won a slam. The others don’t have the sauce.

 

[TsitsiBH]

Tsonga is one of the best players I’ve ever seen.

Can’t say that about the rest.

Yes I voted for Tsonga as well but game wise I think Gasquet and Monfils has less flaws. From what I remember Tsonga was injured every 3 tournaments and couldn't string 3 backhands in a row. His return game was often bad as well. He achieved more than Simon Gasquet and Monfils because he was mentally stronger but was he really better at tennis ?