On paper, Nadal is not in the conversation. His forehand could be overpowered and his backhand mostly only went crosscourt. But watching him is a whole different matter. Like Djokovic, you couldn't hit anything past him but he was much better than Djokovic for most of their careers at playing aggressive and taking over a rally once he's given the chance. For this first half of Djokovic's career, he'd waste 1/3 of short balls by hitting them back up the middle and continuing a rally. If you hit a short ball against Nadal, it was over. He'd drag the opponent around like a rag doll