Who wins more Slams - Sinner or Alcaraz?

Who wins more Slams - Jannik or Carlos?

  • Total voters
    127
dking68 said:
Also pushed the three time defending Wimbledon champion to the limit, he will do better next year. Potro wasn’t good on 3 surfaces like Sinner was so I still see him as a better prospect
Click to expand...
Wouldn't say pushed him to the limit. Guy didn't put up any resistance in the final 3 sets.
 
mike danny said:
Wouldn't say pushed him to the limit. Guy didn't put up any resistance in the final 3 sets.
Click to expand...
So what did you expect from a guy who hasn’t played 10 grass matches in his career? He did damn good for his inexperience. Think it’s easy to take out a six time Wimbledon champion (now 7) without playing 10 matches on a surface?
 
dking68 said:
So what did you expect from a guy who hasn’t played 10 grass matches in his career? He did damn good for his inexperience. Think it’s easy to take out a six time Wimbledon champion without playing 10 matches on a surface?
Click to expand...
To put up better resistance. So what? After winning the first 2 sets, he suddenly forgot how to play on grass?
 
mike danny said:
To put up better resistance. So what? After winning the first 2 sets, he suddenly forgot how to play on grass?
Click to expand...
Why don’t you go out on Wimbledon center court and take out Djokovic? Someone who played hundreds of matches, been in high pressure situations, nobody expected Sinner to gon5 with him
 
mike danny said:
No, but just saying that it is possible to beat a multiple Wimb champion while being very inexperienced. Federer did in 2001.
Click to expand...
Federer was experienced on grass. He had a level of pedigree as he was the Junior WB champ in 98. Sinner didn’t play Juniors, had no grass level, he came into Wimbledon without winning a single match on grass. Stop the comparisons and enjoy tennis. What you achieve at 19/20/21 doesn’t matter, it’s how you finish.
 
dking68 said:
Also pushed the three time defending Wimbledon champion to the limit, he will do better next year. Potro wasn’t good on 3 surfaces like Sinner was so I still see him as a better prospect
Click to expand...
I'd say the way Delpo played at the French and USO in 2009 easily overrides Sinner's more completeness on all 3 surfaces.
 
mike danny said:
I'd say the way Delpo played at the French and USO in 2009 easily overrides Sinner's more completeness on all 3 surfaces.
Click to expand...
Man you’re such an idiot it’s laughable. It took delpo 25 years to get to a SF at WB, while it took Sinner 20 years to get to a WB QF. I’m sure by time Sinner gets to 25, he’ll be near complete the 4 slams if not all 4
 
mike danny said:
Sinner performed decently this year, but Delpo was better at his age. It's not rocket science.
Click to expand...
On all surfaces? I don’t think so. Sinner is the youngest player since big 3 to make second week at all slams. Delpo never achieved that until 24
 
Slicehand said:
Just the fact you call a player "midget" makes me want to stop discusssing
Click to expand...

Also, the fact that it's absolutely not true. I don't know what's this weird obsession with Alcaraz's height as if he was Schwartzmann. He is not "short" in any way, shape or form, let alone a "midget".
 
dking68 said:
On all surfaces? I don’t think so. Sinner is the youngest player since big 3 to make second week at all slams. Delpo never achieved that until 24
Click to expand...
I know and that's a point for Sinner. But he wasn't as close to a slam title as Delpo, which is what matters more.
 
mike danny said:
I know and that's a point for Sinner. But he wasn't as close to a slam title as Delpo, which is what matters more.
Click to expand...
Anyways I’m not arguing anymore. When sinner hangs up the rackets when it’s all said and done, Sinner will laugh at delpos career
 
Fact is theres not a single thing that sugests that sinner will have a better career, he is definetly not more talented and has achieved a lot less being a year older, plus alcaraz is more complete, he has many ways to win matches, the moment sinner is not working from the baseline he doesnt have much more, he is improving tough, but alcaraz is not gonna get any worse either, first full year on tour and 5 titles and a slam (he can win more titles yet) also he is number one and will have easier draws now, we hadnt seen that in a lot of time
 
Slicehand said:
Fact is theres not a single thing that sugests that sinner will have a better career, he is definetly not more talented and has achieved a lot less being a year older, plus alcaraz is more complete, he has many ways to win matches, the moment sinner is not working from the baseline he doesnt have much more, he is improving tough, but alcaraz is not gonna get any worse either, first full year on tour and 5 titles and a slam (he can win more titles yet) also he is number one and will have easier draws now, we hadnt seen that in a lot of time
Click to expand...
The dude started playing competitive tennis only 8 years ago, how long has Alcaraz been playing? Who is more physically developed out of the two? Name two things apart from the serve and focus that Alcaraz can improve?
 
dking68 said:
The dude started playing competitive tennis only 8 years ago, how long has Alcaraz been playing? Who is more physically developed out of the two? Name two things apart from the serve and focus that Alcaraz can improve?
Click to expand...
Alcaraz can improve everything, its nosense to think otherwise, also, you say sinner has been playing since not long ago, ok, what makes you think he can catch up for the time he wasnt playing? He is not gonna train more ghan alcaraz, and alcaraz is almost two years younger, look, its okey that you preffer sinner, but you argjments are weak, ive been watching A LOT of matches from both in the last years, i know where their games stand, sinner is great, great groundstrokes and big potential, but alcaraz is something i hadnt seen since nadal, and more complete, not such surface oriented since the begining, the sky is the limit for alcaraz, the fact that he is so complete doesnt mean he cant improve, doesnt work that way, the guy hasnt really even put his game together and is youngest number one with 2 masters and slam in first season, sinner hasnt proved really anything, he is improving steady but doesnt put great performances together day in day out, thats why he barely has titles, alcaraz has been able to do that from the get go, to think that he is not gonna get better having such an arsenal is really a misjudgement
 
Slicehand said:
Alcaraz can improve everything, its nosense to think otherwise, also, you say sinner has been playing since not long ago, ok, what makes you think he can catch up for the time he wasnt playing? He is not gonna train more ghan alcaraz, and alcaraz is almost two years younger, look, its okey that you preffer sinner, but you argjments are weak, ive been watching A LOT of matches from both in the last years, i know where their games stand, sinner is great, great groundstrokes and big potential, but alcaraz is something i hadnt seen since nadal, and more complete, not such surface oriented since the begining, the sky is the limit for alcaraz, the fact that he is so complete doesnt mean he cant improve, doesnt work that way, the guy hasnt really even put his game together and is youngest number one with 2 masters and slam in first season, sinner hasnt proved really anything, he is improving steady but doesnt put great performances together day in day out, thats why he barely has titles, alcaraz has been able to do that from the get go, to think that he is not gonna get better having such an arsenal is really a misjudgement
Click to expand...
Alright imma come back to this when he blows this midget off the court in 23’. Being 5’4, he will lift many runner up dishes on a fast surface
 
dking68 said:
Alright imma come back to this when he blows this midget off the court in 23’
Click to expand...
Ok, at the moment is him who has been blown out the court from a slam quarter and been surpased months ago in titles and in ranking by a younger guy, now alcaraz is number one, you can even come back when he wins his first masters 1000, that would be an improvement, until then, im gonna enjoy a lot watching carlos play, i hope you enjoy your baseline rallies and mental blowouts
 
Slicehand said:
Ok, at the moment is him who has been blown out the court from a slam quarter and been surpased months ago in titles and in ranking by a younger guy, now alcaraz is number one, you can even come back when he wins his first masters 1000, that would be an improvement, until then, im gonna enjoy a lot watching carlos play, i hope you enjoy your baseline rallies and mental blowouts
Click to expand...
What happened to the three delicious breadsticks at Umag And Wimbledon? Sinner had a match point on him at USO, he barely won his match while Sinner beat him twice and beat him convincingly on his best surface too! The midget didn’t have a chance against him those two times and he played Sinner being tired after 2 5 setters and still struggled to win
 
dking68 said:
What happened to the three delicious breadsticks at Umag And Wimbledon? Sinner had a match point on him at USO, he barely won his match while Sinner beat him twice and beat him convincingly on his best surface too! The midget didn’t have a chance against him those two times and he played Sinner being tired after 2 5 setters and still struggled to win
Click to expand...
"Barely beat" haha, yeah man, alcaraz also had match point, only that he made it, thats how it works, he had to serve for the match and had the balls to do it like a champ, sinners game to close the match was lame at best, also, you remember sinners first wimbledon? Compare it to alcaraz... exactly, he went into wimbledon having played 2 pro matches on grass ever, clay isnt alcaraz best surface, but what would you know, 1 uso, 2 masters, 5 titles, number 1, thats how it is, and its like that for a reason, bye
 
Slicehand said:
"Barely beat" haha, yeah man, alcaraz also had match point, only that he made it, thats how it works, he had to serve for the match and had the balls to do it like a champ, sinners game to close the match was lame at best, also, you remember sinners first wimbledon? Compare it to alcaraz... exactly, he went into wimbledon having played 2 pro matches on grass ever, clay isnt alcaraz best surface, but what would you know, 1 uso, 2 masters, 5 titles, number 1, thats how it is, and its like that for a reason, bye
Click to expand...
Alcaraz actually played Wimbledon Juniors while sinner didn’t so I don’t get your point
 
Slicehand said:
"Barely beat" haha, yeah man, alcaraz also had match point, only that he made it, thats how it works, he had to serve for the match and had the balls to do it like a champ, sinners game to close the match was lame at best, also, you remember sinners first wimbledon? Compare it to alcaraz... exactly, he went into wimbledon having played 2 pro matches on grass ever, clay isnt alcaraz best surface, but what would you know, 1 uso, 2 masters, 5 titles, number 1, thats how it is, and its like that for a reason, bye
Click to expand...
I can’t wait for Sinner to come into his own and blow this deluded clown off the court
 
dking68 said:
I can’t wait for Sinner to come into his own and blow this deluded clown off the court
Click to expand...
Imagine in a few years from now, when the Alcaraz-Sinner gap increases to 6-0 (don’t forget that Alcaraz is 2 years younger) and the fanboys still say this.

I would say that we can already conclude if Alcaraz successfully defend his USO title.
 
I think the argument of Alcaraz not being able to improve is dumb, but do people not understand that the onus is on Sinner to improve and not the other way around? Alcaraz could retire right now and there is no guarantee Sinner will ever reach even current Alcaraz level.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

weakera
  • Poll Poll
Who will win more slams, Jannik Sinner or Carlos Alcaraz?
3 4 5
Replies
215
Views
7K
Lleytonstation
Lleytonstation
M
Alcaraz will win more slams than Sinner
Replies
16
Views
875
ChaelAZ
ChaelAZ
zakopinjo
  • Poll Poll
2024 Alcaraz vs Sinner
Replies
3
Views
301
Aabye5
Aabye5
NeutralFan
  • Poll Poll
Who can stop Sinner this year at slams?
2 3 4
Replies
168
Views
4K
NeutralFan
NeutralFan
GRASScaraz
I think it's safe to say by the end of 2024, Sinner is better than Alcaraz. Say if the world just ended tomorrow (or start of 2025).. I think sinner
2 3
Replies
116
Views
2K
MichaelNadal
MichaelNadal
Back
Top