It is typically Mac and Lendl as the most successful ones
McEnroe is #1 in terms of peak or archievements either way
when i wondered if i had it right bet. The Brat and The Master, i weren't kidding or being capricious.
what secures 5th Seed to Junior is 23-1 Davis Cup singles on carpet.
Mac's tournament achievements are overrated and misunderstood i believe.
Remember that WCT Finals after 1977 was just a good tournament. it had no Slam-like aura, and no season-ending significance. Each of Mac's 5 WCT Finals titles are much lower in import/quality than the titles between 1971-77.
WCT as an independent entity and as a parallel, and at times, superior circuit ceased in 1978. After that WCT is just a little sliver of the Pro tour. It gets to hold a handful of tournaments that are one-offs. There is no WCT. The WCT Finals after 1977 is just a name for a tournament.
Now, it is a very good tournament most years. And combining the cachet of the name, a good purse and frequently strong fields, the WCT Finals 1978-89 should be seen as an M1000-approximate. But it no longer is quasi slam or even roughly equal to YEC.
Bringing me to YEC. Mac has one (1) 5-0 YEC. His other two were 3-round tournaments. The format was changed for a few years, not using the RR. Mac won two of his three YECs under this weak format.
In contrast Lendl only 1 YEC under candy-ass format, w four at undefeated 5-0 records.
Interestingly, all of Pete's five YEC and all Boris' three YEC came on 4-1 records. Neither managed to go undefeated.
the point however is Mac has 3 season-ending, not 8.
Then, counting the WCT Finals of Mac as M1000 approximates, counting other ATP- recognized carpets that deserve to be considered approximates, and adding a couple of his indy titles as equivalents, i get to 13 M1000-type carpet titles. One could argue for 2 or 3 more for sure.
So 13 + 3 YEC. = 16 BIG carpet titles.
That, as opposed to the last man any rational contender would choose to face in a major tournament? So i thought to give Rosewall the 5 spot. But the Mac DC carpet record is so impressive that it is worth at least two undefeated YEC, or two "Slams" on carpet. At least. So now Mac is back to very close w Lendl for the four seed.
But, the headline here is that most of the posters seem to assuming Mac's five WCT Finals are = 5 YEC when they definitely not.
The WCT Finals that deserve special status (quasi Slam or simply "major") are Rosewall (2); Smith, Newk, Ashe, Borg, Connors.