LOL if you look at how Federer was playing at RG from 2012-2015 (aged 30-33) you are kidding yourself to think that 34 year old Federer would have ever beaten this years Nadal at RG, as subpar as he was. No freaking way.Djokovic beat the worse version of Nadal in 2015 whom Federer never had the luck to play and beat a Nadal literally playing on one foot aged 35 this year whome 34 year old Federer would not have needed 4hours to beat.
if in any doubt who is the better clay court player between Federer and Djokovic watch their SF in 2011 at Rg. The best ever version of Djokovic vs 30 year old past prime Federer and Federer routined him.
Obviously dealing with someone completely delusional here.Federer would.have won that in still conditions.
I do agree Djokovic's win over Nadal in 2015 means squat all mind you. You are right on that much. Djokovic's match with Nadal at RG 2013 is the one that marks him the clearly tougher opponent compared to Federer at RG, despite losing. That and all his wins over Nadal in clay Masters from 2011-2014.