It's no secret the combination of a consistent game with no flare, and odd courtside, on court, and off court behaviour makes him what he is.
Is he one of the greatest? Of course. The consistency pays off big time. I am always amazed at his service return game. I love Agassi, and I can admit the Joker is a better returner.
Is he well loved? Not really. Is it popular to love a ruminant?
I mean, a journalist actually asked him how comfortable he was being the 'bad guy'. Was it rude? Oh, yeah. But class looks like it was thrown out the window when Connors and McEnroe became stars.
Was it true? No. But, was it a question that someone would ever ask Rafa or Fed? Never.
When you have two disco stars that are as well-loved as Rafa and Federer are, any usurper without similar levels of charm that comes along and disrupts that party is going to draw some exasperation from fans.
Captivating an audience is one thing. Beguiling an audience is another thing altogether.