Would you change your serve to change racquets?

OK, first off, I'm no great tennis player. I'm 50, been playing a few years. But I do love the game and sometimes play 4-5 times per week.

I have just one racquet that I regularly use - one of those "recreational" racquets from a sporting goods store. Nothing great, but better than my previous department store racquet. I've used this racquet for 2 years, it's starting to look kinda worn, so I though maybe I should look into getting a new racquet, and maybe a decent one this time. So far, so good.

I should also mention that I cannot find any specs for my current racquet, being a cheapo model and out of production. I know head size (110). I don't know stiffness, balance, power, weight etc. I do know that it is *very* light, via a comparative "heft" test.

So, I decide to take advantage of the demo program at TW. I read everything I can find about selecting a racquet. I got 4 demo racquets this week, and have been out with those, my racquet, and my son's bag of racquets. I looked up all the specs of the ones I could identify. Most were light, and most were oversized head, but I have a mix of flexible vs stiff, head heavy vs head light, etc.

I played one day just rallying with my son, swapping racquets. Today I played some singles matches with friends. For most strokes, I could identify racquets I liked better than other. But ... I cannot serve with any of them.

My serve is much better than the rest of my game. I don't know why because nobody taught me. But I serve harder than others at my level, with substantial spin, and decent placement. I've never made a video of myself but I know I rely on substantial elbow snap. With ALL of the demos, and others I tried, my normal serve motion gives me serious elbow pain (which I never have). If I took out the snap, I found perhaps I still had some pop on the serve, but none of the spin I can usually apply.

So it made me wonder what characteristic of my current racquet this is due to, and all I can guess is that it must be ultra-ultra-lightweight. Though the three lightest racquets I used (that I knew the weight of) were less than 10 ounces - quite light.

I'm at a loss. Should I:

a) just forget it, continue using this racquet until it breaks then worry about it
b) find a racquet which otherwise works, and rebuild my serve
c) go see what my local pro thinks
d) demo a bunch more racquets

??
 
We need to talk about your technique 1st. If you never recieved formal training, chances are you don't use continental grip, you don't relax, and you muscle the ball instead. You need to work on your technique 1st. Get a coach or join a group.

Otherwise, I would suggest you either stick with the racquet since it works for you or demo flexible racquets, maybe like a nblade oversize or a liquidmetal oversize.

What racquets did you demo?
 
We need to talk about your technique 1st. If you never recieved formal training, chances are you don't use continental grip, you don't relax, and you muscle the ball instead. You need to work on your technique 1st. Get a coach or join a group.

Otherwise, I would suggest you either stick with the racquet since it works for you or demo flexible racquets, maybe like a nblade oversize or a liquidmetal oversize.

What racquets did you demo?

I do use continental grip to serve. I don't know if I relax or not.

Demo racquets:
  • Babolat Aero Blast
  • Babolat Pure Drive 107
  • Prince O3 Hybrid Hornet
  • Prince O3 Speedport Red

Along with these I used my son's:
  • Wilson nCode 6
  • Wilson Hammer 6

I totally hated the Aero Blast. Way to head heavy, felt like I'd hit myself on my groundstroke follow-thru.
For groundstrokes both the Pure Drive and Hybrid Hornet I like, and they were the least flexible of the group.
 
I don't have "trouble" serving with other peoples' rackets. I tryout my friends' rackets all the time and gimme a few serves and I'll be good to go.
 
I don't know if I'd want all of YouTubeVille laughing at me ...
BP, this is wise.:)
I think I know what you are going through. Cheaper sticks tend to be very powerful and the one thing they can do is serve well even if they lack control and otherwise suck at everything else. I don't think you are going to have to change your serve, you will eventually get used to serving with whatever you choose. Hard to really recomend a particular model without knowing more about your game-a good pro can help you out I'm sure.
 
you have to choose a racquet that encourages your strengths not benefits your weaknesses because if you dont have a strength you have not much at all.
 
Posting a video for us would help, but of course the local pro could help you right then and there by observing you in person and checking things out from all angles and assessing on the fly.

I've found that whenever I change racquets, my service motion changes very slightly to adjust for the differences in specs. Between my ProStaff Classic 6.1, Wilson Tour 90, and Yonex RDS 001 mid, each has slightly different characteristics when I serve. I seem to have the hardest serve with my Tour 90, but I can't apply the kind of spins I get with my RDS with the Tour 90 or the 6.1. Changes in weight, balance, flex, etc. can all play into making your strokes feel pretty foreign on some racquets.

I'm taking this sort of from the standpoint of being a trumpet player. There are literally hundreds of mouthpieces out there, each with varying specs (rim contour, cup depth, etc.), and changes that are measured in .0001" can be the difference between a mouthpiece being great and totally unplayable. I'm sure that tennis racquets are subject to a similar situation due to the multitude of factors that come into play.

Technique comes first, and since you mentioned elbow pain, there may be a technique problem. Iron that out first, then hopefully your demo experience will be more productive and less painful. From how it sounds now, you should find some kind of racquet in the middle (medium powered, not too stiff, not too powerful, etc.), and develop your game from there. Hopefully that should help you assess better, but as I mentioned earlier a couple times, iron out the technique and form first.
 
if you're not ready to clean up your technique, try a prince graphite original--oversize version. Granted, its not a light racket, however it is an oversize racket that is universally considered one of the racket greats and it was rated by racketresearch.com the #1 most arm friendly racket. hope this helps
 
Back
Top