zvelf
Hall of Fame
The hypocrisy here is that it was meaningful enough for you to cite that she beat no top 20 players in her USO win, but when you find out that she really did beat some top 20 players, then you suddenly dismiss that and say it's not meaningful. It's common when one is losing the argument to move the goal post you yourself initially set, which is exactly what you did here.Yeah, see above and learn to read. No, really, go back and read my post (which isn't edited, BTW). There is a big caveat in there because, yeah, I really don't care enough about Raducanu's fluke run to remember all the details.
As @ScottleeSV noted, Raducanu dropped out of the 200 because of injury, not level of play. You know she was off the tour for 8 months while recovering from 3 different surgeries and that's the main reason why she is currently #303, not because she performed like #303. But your goal post-moving already showed you are being disingenuous and not making statements in good faith.And yes, she obviously played pretty well (despite the super easy draw), as it was some fluke run of form. A bigger fluke than Ostapenko, because at least she didn't drop like a complete stone out of the top 200...
Reality is exactly as I stated it. Raducanu seemingly made a poor decision to let Iga serve first as she went up 40-0, but then Emma rattled off 5 straight points, mostly winners. I stated no more and no less. If you take that as hype, then that's on you. I'm not making any great claims for Raducanu. I think if she can remain healthy, she can settle into being a player regularly in the top 30. I don't think she will ever be a stable top 5 player.Yes, hype her up after a single game. And you wonder why people like me need to bring people like you back to reality.
So taking the best clay-courter currently playing into a tiebreak is getting steamrolled? Did you even watch the match? It was mostly a close affair with many games going to multiple deuces in both the first and second set. Only near the end did Iga raise her game to another level and take the win from there.Ha, what? So it's all "solid" and positive for Emma, but ugly for everyone else? Please, Emma got steamrolled. If Iga had played just slightly less sloppy, it would have been even more one-sided.
Last edited: