XBox 360 or PS3 - what is the best tennis game?

[TripleB]

Looking at getting either the XBox with Kinect or PS3 with Move (probably leaning towards the XBox right now...you should have seen my 4 year old son playing Kinect Sports tennis and Puss in Boots).

What is the best tennis game on either (or each) system?

TripleB

 

[tenn23]

For PS3 it is Top Spin 4 (if it's for you, otherwise Virtua Tennis 4 for a more arcadey tennis, which may be better suited for a 4 year old). I don't own a 360.

 

[MichaelNadal]

PS3- TS4

10char

 

[Doubles]

XBox 360, Topspin 4. As of now no other game really compares. I liked TS2, but 4 is just better. I never played TS3 on the XBox, so no comment on that.

 

[DRII]

I must disagree, TS4 is horrible! Best of the most recent tennis games is Top Spin 3 for the PS3. But, don't expect much online play...

If I were buying a system today, I would get the Xbox w/ Kinect. There's so much potential there...

 

[BigServer1]

I've got a Kinect, and it's awesome. No controller, which is great, and the games are getting really cool. You do need a lot of space to play, so keep that in mind if you've got a tight living room.

TS4 is alright, I liked TS3 a bit better I think, but I'm hoping that Grand Slam 2 from EA is the answer for me. I'm waiting for a deep career mode and more realistic gameplay...Here's hoping.

 

[Yourtenniscoach]

TopSpin 4. Its far from great but its the best of what's out there right now.

 

[The_Question]

XBox 360, Topspin 4. As of now no other game really compares.

Until Grand Slam Tennis 2 come out...

 

[MichaelNadal]

Until Grand Slam Tennis 2 come out...

Not for realism, maybe for commentary and graphics.