Looking back, my favorites are:
4th set, 1981 Wimby Championship- What a present surprise. The great Borg has finally been taken down
5th set, 1980 USO championship- Could Mac be for real?
4th set, 1981 USO championship- Good bye, Borg. Mac is now the King Pin.
3rd set, 1984 USO championship- Mac crushed his nemesis. This felt great
5th set 2017 AO championship- This is the most unexpected result of them all.
Of course, I've had far more heartbreak sets being a McEnroe and Federer fan.
Here are my worst sets:
They include:
4th set, 1984 FO final- Mac was serving up 4-2. This year to me was still the greatest ever. My heart sank when Lendl pushed this to 5
5th set, 1984 FO final- worst loss I've ever witnessed, given that I was a teenager that had tons of time to follow my favorite players. These losses hurt far more then
5th set, 1980 Wimby final- Mac couldn't quite take down the mighty Borg.
3rd set, 1985 USO final- My American hero got blown out by his #1 nemesis, Ivan Lendl
5th set, 2009 AO final- I thought that this officially ended Fed's dominance.
5th set, 2008 Wimby final- Fed's Wimby streak is over
5th set, 2009 USO final- I figured that Fed might not win another slam after this.
5th set, 2014 Wimby final-I felt that this was Fed's last chance for a slam
5th set, year-end championship final vs Nadalbandian. Had Federer won this match, he gets the title and also ties Mac's record of 82-3.
5th set, 2005 AO semi- Safin was incredible in this match. Fed was great, but not great enough
5th set, 2016 Wimby semi- This was Fed's best chance to win a slam. But his knee buckled and he was doomed afterwards
5th set, 2013 AO semi-- I figured Federer was finished when lowly Andy Murray could now beat Federer in a slam.