I don't understand how you can go from no kick serve to a good serve instantaneously. If someone wants to develop a kick serve, it is going to suck for a while until it develops into a good one. Everyone's kick serve is going to get put away during this stage.
Nah, you do go through the stage of weak to strong over some development time sure. The OP asked if it was
'worth the effort' to develop a kick serve at 3.5. And my position is, that most 4.0-4.5's who have a good kicker, started developing that serve at 3.5.
I say it's worth the effort if improving one's game is a consideration.
So whats all the criticism about 3.5s hitting sucky kick serves when obviously they are developing players since they are only 3.5s. I'd say its better to have a terrible kick serve than the best pancake serve because at least a kick serve can become a real weapon later on.
True. There should be no criticism of sucky 3.5 kickers, or backhands, or whatever else at 3.5.
Right? It's just a single stroke and nothing more. I have played 3.5's here in TX, with strong kick serves, but had inconsistent games to go with it, and thats why they are 3.5's. But yeah, I mostly see duck second serves at 3.5.
I say just the opposite of the OP's question. One should most definately work to develop that kicker, so when you play 4.0+ players, who have even MORE ability to put away sucky serves, you have once less weakness for players to pick on.
Fedace said:
As you progress with your kick serve, you will learn to toss the ball little more in front of you to get more forward movement on the ball with twist spin.
Right on Fedace. That is a big key to the puzzle of making that second serve hard to attack. It is simple, and so obvious, most players just don't do it. A good knee bend, smooth motion, and forward leaning into the court, really add a ton of spin to that ball using basically the same exact service motion.
And funny you mention that, most 3.5's problems with the serves are not their racket path, but rather, not using the body's kinetic chain effectively. And on second serve, most guys are scared to use that whole body for fear of hitting a double fault.