Nadal vs Davydenko (Shanghai Final 2009)

Who will hold up the trophy?

  • Nadal

    Votes: 25 40.3%
  • Davydenko

    Votes: 28 45.2%
  • Neither - both will retire and nobody wins :)

    Votes: 9 14.5%

  • Total voters
    62
  • Poll closed .

Bud

Bionic Poster
Pick the winner!

Let's lay that other thread to rest :twisted:

Poll was 28-Nadal to 27-Davydenko (9-neither) at the end of the match.
 
Last edited:

ruerooo

Legend
I would like Rafa to win. But I would like Davy to do well (although he and the Djoker played a long match today).
 

zagor

Bionic Poster
Nadal in 3 sets,hopefully nobody retires,we have seen enough of that for this tournament.
 

bolo

G.O.A.T.
Miami last year davydenko really destroyed nadal. Nadal tried to play closer to the baseline and get more aggressive with the backhand but he ended up making more errors. Overall the wall that is davydenko was too much.

But I thought by paris last year that nadal's game on hard courts had improved to the point where he could beat davy (55/45 maybe). Nadal's hard court game has taken a step back now, but davydeko has had some injury issues as well.

I think iit's 50/50 right now and it will be close, but nadal will take it.

Vamos,
 

JeMar

Legend
I just want to say that this tournament has become nothing but a horrendous joke. All these retirements are just... ugh.

Oh, and Nadal in three.
 

Bud

Bionic Poster
Good preparation for the Aussie Open for Nadal, this court is similar to Melbourne imo, maybe a tad slower.

Agreed... a tad slower and bounces a bit higher. The commentators were remarking about the rough top coat, earlier during the match Nadal/Lopez match. There must be a ton of sand in it to slow it down.

I think these extremely slow hard courts are the toughest surfaces on the body because they have great grip, no give and don't allow any sliding whatsoever.
 
Nadal needs to mess with Davydenko's rythm, he obviously needs to playing agressive, a few balls over Denko's shoulders, short slices to bring him off the baseline and maybe incorporate the drop shot aswell.
 

Bud

Bionic Poster
Nadal needs to mess with Davydenko's rythm, he obviously needs to playing agressive, a few balls over Denko's shoulders, short slices to bring him off the baseline and maybe incorporate the drop shot aswell.

Yup... Davydenko thrives on the rhythm and pace of his opponents.

He gets into a groove and is like a hitting machine!
 

namelessone

Legend
Very tough match up for Nadal considering Davydenko is one of the few guys that could hang with Nadal from the baseline even when Nadal was in form,nevermind the mediocre things we have seen from Rafa this week.

I've seen a lot of commenting done on Davy's condition and if will he be fresh for tomorrow. Apparently the russian is at a disadvantage because he played longer but I tend to disagree.Although it will be tough for him to recuperate,he at least has a rhythm and survived some tough moments against djoker,he has more match play and against tougher opponents. Nadal is better rested but has basically no rhythm. His only tough match was with blake and he benefited from 2 retirements. We can safely say that Nadal hasn't played a match since his match with robredo. He has basically played 2 sets against ljubicic and that's it,because those phony sets with one-leg Lopez don't count,it might as well have been a practice session and not a good one at that.

Nadal can beat Davydenko if he runs him around a lot and doesn't give him any rhythm. Perhaps some Davy fans will get upset at me but I felt djoker beat himself today. He lead this match most of the time but had the same brain fart as in the simon match and this time paid for it. He allowed davydenko back in the game and couldn't stay strong in the deciding moments of the match.

Nadal needs to slice a lot and try to attack davydenko.Right now the russian is playing better than Nadal from the baseline.

Rafa in three hopefully.
 

Bud

Bionic Poster
H2H Nadal vs Davydenko

Very tough match up for Nadal considering Davydenko is one of the few guys that could hang with Nadal from the baseline even when Nadal was in form,nevermind the mediocre things we have seen from Rafa this week.

I've seen a lot of commenting done on Davy's condition and if will he be fresh for tomorrow. Apparently the russian is at a disadvantage because he played longer but I tend to disagree.Although it will be tough for him to recuperate,he at least has a rhythm and survived some tough moments against djoker,he has more match play and against tougher opponents. Nadal is better rested but has basically no rhythm. His only tough match was with blake and he benefited from 2 retirements. We can safely say that Nadal hasn't played a match since his match with robredo. He has basically played 2 sets against ljubicic and that's it,because those phony sets with one-leg Lopez don't count,it might as well have been a practice session and not a good one at that.

Nadal can beat Davydenko if he runs him around a lot and doesn't give him any rhythm. Perhaps some Davy fans will get upset at me but I felt djoker beat himself today. He lead this match most of the time but had the same brain fart as in the simon match and this time paid for it. He allowed davydenko back in the game and couldn't stay strong in the deciding moments of the match.

Nadal needs to slice a lot and try to attack davydenko.Right now the russian is playing better than Nadal from the baseline.

Rafa in three hopefully.


H2H Nadal vs Davydenko

Nadal-Davydenko%20H2H.jpg



H2H Stats - Nadal vs Davydenko (their stats are very similar!)

Nadal-Davydenko%20H2H%20stats.jpg
 
Last edited:

Bud

Bionic Poster
Since this surface is playing more like clay than typical hardcourt, IMO... I'd have to give the slight advantage to Nadal... who has a 3-0 clay H2H and a 1-2 HC H2H with Davy.
 

TheTruth

G.O.A.T.
I hope Rafa wins, but Davy is tough. He's looking more confident than I've seen him in awhile. Anyway. Go Rafa!
 
I hope Davydenko wins. I am a big fan of his game and he always falls short in the big matches. When he plays his best, he can do damage to anyone. He has given Federer and Nadal some tough matches in the past.
 
Flip a coin. I think this one is a 50/50. I dont think Davydenko will be that fatigued though, and I do think if he plays very well and holds it together mentally (a big if for him) he will win.
 

Bud

Bionic Poster
Flip a coin. I think this one is a 50/50. I dont think Davydenko will be that fatigued though, and I do think if he plays very well and holds it together mentally (a big if for him) he will win.

I'm going 60/40 Nadal :oops:

If Nadal comes out playing well, which is 50% of the time lately, then I give the edge to Nadal.

If the reverse is true, Davydenko in straight sets.
 

flying24

Banned
If Davydenko plays as well as he did today he wins in straight sets. Nadal in his current form on this surface will not even be able to keep up with him nearly as much as Djokovic did today unless Davydenko hits the self panic button.
 
S

SerbWhoLovesDelPo

Guest
Davydenko is 2-1 with Nadal on hardcourts. Last year he crushed Rafa in Miami, and won in Paris by retirement.

He has a chance if he's not too tired. He definitely deserves it more than Rafa.

Still, I expect Nadal to win somehow.
 
If Davydenko plays as well as he did today he wins in straight sets. Nadal in his current form on this surface will not even be able to keep up with him nearly as much as Djokovic did today unless Davydenko hits the self panic button.

Djokovic played like trash today and nearly beat Davydenko, geesh Davydenko is being overrated. I say Nadal in 2.
 

flying24

Banned
Djokovic played like trash today and nearly beat Davydenko, geesh Davydenko is being overrated. I say Nadal in 2.

Everytime Nadal has come up against a true quality opponent on hard courts since his return to the tour (I am not talking Monfils caliber) he has looked like thrash and struggled to even win games, never mind a set. I dont see anything about his play this weak that suggests he has suddenly got alot better, struggling past a past his prime Blake and old geezer Ljubicic.
 
Everytime Nadal has come up against a true quality opponent on hard courts since his return to the tour (I am not talking Monfils caliber) he has looked like thrash and struggled to even win games, never mind a set. I dont see anything about his play this weak that suggests he has suddenly got alot better, struggling past a past his prime Blake and old geezer Ljubicic.

Ok lets have a bet. If Davydenko wins I put 'Im a clown, Federer >>>> Sampras flying24' is king on my signature, if Nadal wins you do the same but with Sampras >>>> Federer and Cesc is king, deal? This applys to anyone else if Flying24 rejects my proposal.
 

Breaker

Legend
Weak era Davydenko will roll over strong era Rafa.

Outside of his retirement at the US Open he has been untouchable.
 

statto

Professional
Everytime Nadal has come up against a true quality opponent on hard courts since his return to the tour (I am not talking Monfils caliber) he has looked like thrash and struggled to even win games, never mind a set. I dont see anything about his play this weak that suggests he has suddenly got alot better, struggling past a past his prime Blake and old geezer Ljubicic.

Who are you talking about if Monfils calibre players don't count? Djokovic struggled past Simon, yet most people would rate him as the best HC player in the tournament (most people thought he was going to win it).

You're disrespecting Blake, who played pretty well, I thought.

The sad thing is that Nadal is in a lose/lose position on these forums because if he wins tomorrow everyone will say it's because Davydenko is tired (even if he runs around like a man possessed), and if he loses people will say how he's useless on HC, even though he's won a slam and a masters on HC this season.
 
Davydenko is 2-1 with Nadal on hardcourts. Last year he crushed Rafa in Miami, and won in Paris by retirement.

He has a chance if he's not too tired. He definitely deserves it more than Rafa.

Still, I expect Nadal to win somehow.

2008 - Nadal playing some of his best tennis on HC. Better than right now. Davy was playing better in Miami too, though.
 

statto

Professional
Weak era Davydenko will roll over strong era Rafa.

Outside of his retirement at the US Open he has been untouchable.

:confused:

Up until this week he hadn't made it past the quarters at a single HC slam, masters or ATP500 event this season. How has he been untouchable?
 
Last edited:

cuddles26

Banned
Who are you talking about if Monfils calibre players don't count? Djokovic struggled past Simon, yet most people would rate him as the best HC player in the tournament (most people thought he was going to win it).

You're disrespecting Blake, who played pretty well, I thought.

The sad thing is that Nadal is in a lose/lose position on these forums because if he wins tomorrow everyone will say it's because Davydenko is tired (even if he runs around like a man possessed), and if he loses people will say how he's useless on HC, even though he's won a slam and a masters on HC this season.

He probably means players that are better than Monfils on a hard court which would be atleast 15 or 20 probably. After all Monfils is a clay courter who isnt really top 10 calibre yet (though he has been there for blips) who once in a blue moon makes the round of 16 in a hard court slam. Anyway arent you the one who made that crazy predition of Nadal winning 14 slams and 4 Wimbledons. You must be seriously in love with Nadal so of course you will defend him in every thread like he is your own son.
 

cuddles26

Banned
Ok lets have a bet. If Davydenko wins I put 'Im a clown, Federer >>>> Sampras flying24' is king on my signature, if Nadal wins you do the same but with Sampras >>>> Federer and Cesc is king, deal? This applys to anyone else if Flying24 rejects my proposal.

I will take that bet. I dont like either Federer or Sampras so most of that sig isnt even a big deal for me anyway. Just replace the flying24 with cuddles26 part of it. I will see you tommorow.

Actually since I am a huge Serena fan and hate Henin I have an idea if you are interested. Lets make it for me if I lose "I'm a clown, Henin >>>> Serena and Cesc is king" if Nadal wins, and you have to have a "I'm a clown, Federer >>>> Sampras and cuddles26 is king" if Davydenko wins. Make my punishment worse if I lose since I dont really care about either Sampras or Federer enough on a support level to give a damn but having a Henin >>>> Serena sig for me would be torture.
 
Last edited:

bolo

G.O.A.T.
Are we forgetting the victory against gonzo? Gonzo is a top 10 player and his best surface is hard courts.
 

cuddles26

Banned
Are we forgetting the victory against gonzo?

Davydenko is a much better player than Gonzalez. Just looking at their rankings, titles, and head to head. The played here this week and Davydenko pissed all over Gonzalez as usual. Gonzalez even lost to a soon to retire Safin last week, LOL! I dont get all the love for that mediocre one shot wonder on this forum.
 
I will take that bet. I dont like either Federer or Sampras so most of that sig isnt even a big deal for me anyway. Just replace the flying24 with cuddles26 part of it. I will see you tommorow.

Actually since I am a huge Serena fan and hate Henin I have an idea if you are interested. Lets make it for me if I lose "I'm a clown, Henin >>>> Serena and Cesc is king" if Nadal wins, and you have to have a "I'm a clown, Federer >>>> Sampras and cuddles26 is king" if Davydenko wins. Make my punishment worse if I lose since I dont really care about either Sampras or Federer enough on a support level to give a damn but having a Henin >>>> Serena sig for me would be torture.

Ok, your on.
 

clayman2000

Hall of Fame
Rafa in 3.

He knows if he wins this that he has a legit chance of ending 2009 no 1. To know that he has a chance of ending no 1, despite only gaining 180 pts from his two best slams must give him confidence
 

bolo

G.O.A.T.
Davydenko is a much better player than Gonzalez. Just looking at their rankings, titles, and head to head. The played here this week and Davydenko pissed all over Gonzalez as usual. Gonzalez even lost to a soon to retire Safin last week, LOL! I dont get all the love for that mediocre one shot wonder on this forum.

Nevertheless gonzo counts as a "true quality opponent" who is more or less a top ten player and nadal has faced him since his return to the tour.
 

cuddles26

Banned
Nevertheless gonzo counts as a "true quality player"

Sure if your minimum standard of true quality player is a past his prime clown who hasnt even won a Masters title, been ranked in the top 5 for even a single week in his 10 year career, and can only hit one shot well, then maybe.
 
S

SerbWhoLovesDelPo

Guest
2008 - Nadal playing some of his best tennis on HC. Better than right now. Davy was playing better in Miami too, though.

Yeah, Nadal was better then. So Davydenko should probably win if he can repeat his form. But there are so many questions about Davy: is he tired? physically, mentally? will he choke?
 

bolo

G.O.A.T.
Sure if your minimum standard of true quality player is a past his prime clown who hasnt even won a Masters title or even been ranked in the top 5 for even a single week in his 10 year career maybe.

that's fine but gonzo has actually made a final in a hc major. has davydenko ever done that?
 
Top