Who tennis player sabotaged his game the most

Who tennis player sabotaged his game the most

  • Nick Kyrgios

    Votes: 23 35.9%
  • Martin Hingis

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Marat Safin

    Votes: 14 21.9%
  • Stefanos Tsitsipas

    Votes: 4 6.3%
  • Serena Williams

    Votes: 2 3.1%
  • Guillermo Coria

    Votes: 6 9.4%
  • Agnieszka Radwanska

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Mary Pierce

    Votes: 1 1.6%
  • Grigor Dimitrov

    Votes: 5 7.8%
  • Other

    Votes: 9 14.1%

  • Total voters
    64

Smecz

Semi-Pro
This is simple question:Which tennis player sabotaged his/her game the most?!?!

Please leave your opinions, vote and tell us why you think so
 

Federer and Del Potro

Bionic Poster
Tomas Berdych. He was so concerned with being a gracious king dropping crumbs to the peasants on tour that we never got to see his real game. His real game is well documented in practices where it was okay to embarrass his opponents without any fanfare.

As his son, he was actually furious when he found out people knew of him bageling Nadal and Federer in practice. The most humble athlete in sporting history. Not just tennis.
 

Smecz

Semi-Pro
Tomas Berdych. He was so concerned with being a gracious king dropping crumbs to the peasants on tour that we never got to see his real game. His real game is well documented in practices where it was okay to embarrass his opponents without any fanfare.

As his son, he was actually furious when he found out people knew of him bageling Nadal and Federer in practice. The most humble athlete in sporting history. Not just tennis.
I didn't know about it:oops:Shock!!
 

Rosstour

G.O.A.T.
Safin, Rios, Kyrgios. Head cases with all the talent in the world. They all made it to at least one Slam Final and could have done so much more than they did if they weren't so unstable.
 
D

Deleted member 629564

Guest
[content deleted by user]
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Coria. Say what you will about the rest’s commitment to the game or professionalism; but none of them forgot how to hit a professional tennis serve.
Wait this isn't necessarily professionalism... I mastered serving once to where I was able to hit every serve very cleanly with a lot of power on 1st serves and tons of spin on 2nds... and get almost all serves in... but then soon I became unable to do it anymore at all and serve been terrible ever since no matter how much practice. Almost all unclean mishits

This Coria probably ran into the same problem. Maybe something gets misaligned in the shoulder that forces incorrect swings idk what happened
 

Kralingen

Talk Tennis Guru
Wait this isn't necessarily professionalism... I mastered serving once to where I was able to hit every serve very cleanly with a lot of power on 1st serves and tons of spin on 2nds... and get almost all serves in... but then soon I became unable to do it anymore at all and serve been terrible ever since no matter how much practice. Almost all unclean mishits
OK I’d like to make a correction @Aestheticsaboveallelse is the biggest sabotager of his game
 

President

Legend
David Nalbandian’s lack of interest and commitment was fairly embarrassing for a top pro. The guy was exceptionally talented, absolutely amazing groundstrokes and return. In contrast, Andy Roddick was extremely professional, but his tactical choices in terms of his forehand severely handicapped him. Safin is in the same mold as Nalbandian, although in his case I think injuries were the bigger factor.


To me, Safin and Nalbandian were far more talented than Hewitt and Roddick and really should have been Federer’s main rivals before Nadal emerged. Credit to the latter two for their professionalism and work ethic.
 

President

Legend
Dean Goldfine decided to turn Roddick into a counterpuncher for... some reason I suppose?

I have read (cannot remember where) that Roddick observed that Nadal was able to trouble Federer with heavy topspin and wear him down with consistency. Roddick apparently tried to emulate Nadal’s strategy, but lacked Nadal’s explosive topspin and athleticism/footwork.
 

Third Serve

Talk Tennis Guru
I have read (cannot remember where) that Roddick observed that Nadal was able to trouble Federer with heavy topspin and wear him down with consistency. Roddick apparently tried to emulate Nadal’s strategy, but lacked Nadal’s explosive topspin and athleticism/footwork.
Yeah Roddick was pretty much the type of player who really should never try to be a counterpuncher.
 

Cabeza del Demonio

Professional
Safin, Tsonga, and now we could probably add Shapovalov to the list.

Rios and Nalbandian were amazing in their own right, but they did lack the power and the dominant serve to bail them out.
 

President

Legend
Safin's forehand was more of an occasional liability than a legit weakness. Tsonga's backhand though...

If Marat had even had Nalbandian or Davydenko’s routine stability and confidence in the forehand, he would have had far fewer random losses. He had to be really “on” for his forehand to be a great shot. His technique was a bit flawed. Legendary backhand and great in every other aspect of the game though.
 

Cabeza del Demonio

Professional
Shapo was never that good in the first place so there was nothing to sabotage.
Hard disagree. He had all the technical and physical advantages in the world. Easy serve (inconsistent but it was always a focus issue, not a technical issue). One of the best FH on tour, all the power and variety you could ask for in a 1H (and could hold its own against Rafa on clay). Exceptional feel at the net. Solid enough return that it wasn't a glaring Achilles heel (unlike Tsitsipas or Wawrinka). Athletic beast. Great court sense when his head was in the game.

Only problem, his head was rarely in the game.
 

President

Legend
Hard disagree. He had all the technical and physical advantages in the world. Easy serve (inconsistent but it was always a focus issue, not a technical issue). One of the best FH on tour, all the power and variety you could ask for in a 1H (and could hold its own against Rafa on clay). Exceptional feel at the net. Solid enough return that it wasn't a glaring Achilles heel (unlike Tsitsipas or Wawrinka). Athletic beast. Great court sense when his head was in the game.

Only problem, his head was rarely in the game.

What is his best match against a well playing top level opponent? Genuine question, it is possible I’ve somehow missed some amazing performances from Denis over the last 5 years or so.
 

Cabeza del Demonio

Professional
What is his best match against a well playing top level opponent? Genuine question, it is possible I’ve somehow missed some amazing performances from Denis over the last 5 years or so.
The one that comes to mind was him crushing Zverev at AO22. That was a masterclass if I've ever seen one. His Rome matches vs Nadal were up there for shotmaking too.
I'm going off eye tests more than results here, though. I've rarely seen him actually get outgunned (Alcaraz at RG23 might've been the first time he genuinely looked like he didn't have the weapons to compete.)
 

President

Legend
The one that comes to mind was him crushing Zverev at AO22. That was a masterclass if I've ever seen one. His Rome matches vs Nadal were up there for shotmaking too.
I'm going off eye tests more than results here, though. I've rarely seen him actually get outgunned (Alcaraz at RG23 might've been the first time he genuinely looked like he didn't have the weapons to compete.)

Key word in my post was “well playing”
 

Cabeza del Demonio

Professional
Key word in my post was “well playing”
See his match vs Zverev at Paris 2019, both guys were knocking the cover off the ball. Not sure if the court level highlights are still up on YT, but those really give you a better idea of how hard and heavy he could hit. And how effortlessly he could redirect pace and run Zverev around the court.

EDIT: I also recall a great 5-set match he played vs Sinner a couple years ago. Early on at AO. Some great hitting from both guys, even if there were mental lapses and racquet smashes. But Shapo was pretty clearly the superior shotmaker in that match. I really think if he maxed out his talent, he'd be right up there with where Sinner is now, if not even better.
 
Last edited:

nolefam_2024

Talk Tennis Guru
These are professional athletes. They are not sabotaging their own game. They can't play better than what they did which is why they lost the matches they did.

These tall tales like Berdych never showing real games mean nothing to me.
Only 2 I can agree who sabotaged their own game are Marat Safin and Serena Williams. Both could achieve much more.
 

Mainad

Bionic Poster
I think Elena Dementieva should be on that list. Strong athlete with a great ground game but absolutely awful serve. I believe it held her back from fulfilling her true potential.
 

NedStark

Professional
See his match vs Zverev at Paris 2019, both guys were knocking the cover off the ball. Not sure if the court level highlights are still up on YT, but those really give you a better idea of how hard and heavy he could hit. And how effortlessly he could redirect pace and run Zverev around the court.

EDIT: I also recall a great 5-set match he played vs Sinner a couple years ago. Early on at AO. Some great hitting from both guys, even if there were mental lapses and racquet smashes. But Shapo was pretty clearly the superior shotmaker in that match. I really think if he maxed out his talent, he'd be right up there with where Sinner is now, if not even better.
Fixing his toss will go a long way.
 

BeatlesFan

Bionic Poster
McEnroe by far. After Fed, he's clearly the most talented tennis player ever. He went 82-3 in 1984 but meets Tatum in December. He promptly loses loses both his rubbers in the Davis Cup in Sweden, then after Lendl beats him in the '85 USO final, takes a sabbatical.

He was never the same player, squandering his chances to win more slams. He descended into drug use, steroid abuse and all sorts of tacky off court drama with an extremely high maintenance wife.
 

NedStark

Professional
Dimitrov for trying to imitate Federer (especially the serves - he actually has more success with imitating Fed BH/slice/FH, but his serve is a failure) and failing. At least a Dimitrov with a real good serve would have been a completely different beast.

Also, the fact that Dimitrov plays as a grinder show that Dimitrov has been copying Federer strokes without understanding Federer tennis/strategy.
 

Cabeza del Demonio

Professional
McEnroe by far. After Fed, he's clearly the most talented tennis player ever. He went 82-3 in 1984 but meets Tatum in December. He promptly loses loses both his rubbers in the Davis Cup in Sweden, then after Lendl beats him in the '85 USO final, takes a sabbatical.

He was never the same player, squandering his chances to win more slams. He descended into drug use, steroid abuse and all sorts of tacky off court drama with an extremely high maintenance wife.
Hard to say he "sabotaged" his career when he's got 7 Majors, 4 years at #1, a boatload of career titles, and a firm spot in the all-time pantheon.

He did sabotage his 1990 Australian Open chances, though :cool:
 

Shaolin

G.O.A.T.
These are professional athletes. They are not sabotaging their own game. They can't play better than what they did which is why they lost the matches they did.

These tall tales like Berdych never showing real games mean nothing to me.
Only 2 I can agree who sabotaged their own game are Marat Safin and Serena Williams. Both could achieve much more.

Disagree.

Players like Rios, Nalbandian, nowadays Kyrgios could have been MUCH better than their results with just a little better work ethic and focus.
 
Top