tennisaddict
Bionic Poster
Being a Fed fan or not has nothing to do with it, it's just my opinion.
4 out of 17 of Fed's slams came at AO which was an almost insignificant event in Borg's day, yes I know you can't award him hypothetical slams but given how amazing he was on grass I find it hard to believe that he wouldn't have won several if the event had the importance it has today (and that it did since 1995).
Borg's mastery over two slams which were complete polar opposites at the time is the feat I regard to be one of the most impressive in tennis history (winning Wimbledon-FO double today just doesn't compare in my eyes) and one that I don't think anyone else was capable of in tennis ever (not even Laver or Rosewall).
His performance at his worst slam-USO is very comparable to Fed's performance at his worst slam-FO with about the same level of competition more or less, while individually Connors and McEnroe at USO weren't on Nadal's level at the FO, combined they made it about as tough for someone to win it (I also think the depth was better than the largely lackluster modern CC era).
I'm not one of those who believe that finals don't count for anything and the title win is the only thing that matters, for me Fed was a much, much better claycourter than Sampras (the greatest player of previous era) long before he won FO in 2009 and Borg gets his due from me for making 4 USO finals (or even only 3 if we discount the one on green clay).
Furthemore while Fed is a beast indoors so was Borg which further speaks to his versatility as a player (given that he won most if not all of his indoor titles on carpet while Fed did on indoor HC).
Good post, except for the bolded part. A victory at FO and 4 other finals and innumerable SF's over almost a decade is not "comparable" to Borg's USO achievement, but clearly better which puts Fed at a higher pedestal.
I agree that if Borg had played AO, he would have been at 14 or 15 majors and hence he ranks more than Sampras for winning on such disparate surfaces.
The combination of 5 plus finals on all surfaces , winning 17 of them and having 5 YEC, 302 weeks - all makes Fed way ahead of the competition.